Economic Crimes Criminal Procedure; The Connection between Substance and Process

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 PhD candidate of criminal law and criminology, Isfahan Branch, Islamic Azad University, korasgan,Isfahan, Iran

2 Associate professor of criminal law and criminology, Isfahan Branch, Islamic Azad University, korasgan, Isfahan, Iran

3 Assistant Professor of criminal Law and criminology, University of Tehran, (Farabi Campus), Qom, Iran

Abstract

In Iran, economic crimes occupy three positions. The first one is that of the exemplary one. For example, in the Islamic Penal Code, we find crimes that border on the concept of economic crimes. The example of this category is destroying the economic order. The second is the judicial position which are determined as a result of the judicial policy and the third one is the status-based position, which the law-maker explicitly identifies them as economic crimes. Given this, the question is whether the economic crimes have an independent character in the Penal Code? This challenge has caused the economic crimes to be more of a procedural nature and character than a substantive one. This essay examines this challenge in full and introduces its shortcomings in the Iranian penal sysyem.
 

Keywords

Main Subjects


References
1.persian

1- Ebrahimi, Shahram, Hamed Saffai Atashgah, (2015), "The Legislator's Approach to Crime Prevention in the Law on the Promotion of the Health of the Administrative System and Coping with Corruption", Journal of Criminal Law, V. 6, No. 2, PP. 7-31.
2- Ebrahimi, Shahram, Majid Sadegh Nejad Naeini (2016), “Criminological Analysis of Economic Crimes", Journal of Criminal Law Research, V. 2, N. 5, PP. 147-174.
3- Elham, Gholam Hossein, Hossein Ghodouzian (1392) "Analysis of the Concept and Conditions for the Judiciary Realization of with a Comparative Approach in American and Iranian Penal Law", Journal of Criminal Law Research, V. 2, No. 4, PP. 107-135.
4- Elham, Gholam Hossein, Seyyed Mahmoud Mirkhalili, Amir Mohammad Borhanfar (2014), "Challenges for defining the crime of smuggling in Iran's legal system", Journal of jurisprudential views, Vol. 19, No. 68.
5- Bahremand, Baghnazar, Hamid (2010), Iran's Criminal Legitimate Policy Regarding Corruption and its Comparative Study with the United Nations Convention against Corruption, Doctoral Dissertation, Criminal law and Criminology, Tehran University.
6- Tadein, Abbas (2009), studying the reason for the Criminal Procedure, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.
7- Tavasolizadeh, Turan (2013), Prevention of Economic Crimes, Tehran, Jangal Publishing.
8- Janipour, Ali (2014), Special Criminal Courts, Analytical in International Documents and the Iranian Law System, Tehran, Shahre Danesh Publishing.
9- Jamshidi, Alireza (2009), "Prevention of Economic Crimes, from Judicial Actions to Administrative Actions" in a series of lectures presented in the first national conference on the prevention of crime, by the efforts of Mohammad Farajih and Seyyed Mohammad Hossein Sarkashiyan, Printing Office of Deputy of NAJA Education.
10- Hasani, Jafar, Nasrin Mehra (2015), "A Critique on the Concept of Economic Crime in the Islamic Penal Code Approved in 2013", Journal of Criminal Law Studies and Criminology, Vol. 2, No.2 & 3, PP. 45-69.
11- Khaleghi Ali (2015), Notes in the Code of Criminal Procedure, Tehran, Shahre Danesh Publishing.
12- Khodaian Chagini, Zabih Allah (2012), "A comparative study of the institutions of the criminal justice system of France and Iran in countering economic crime", Journal of  Legal Studies, Vol. 4, NO. 2, PP. 31-58.
13- Dadkhodai, Leila (2011), Financial-Administrative Corruption, and Criminal Policy against It, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.
14- Drajj, Behzad (2003), Principle of Innocence and Foundations and Works in Criminal Matters, Master's thesis, Criminal Law and Criminology, Shahid Beheshti University.
15) Rahmdel, Mansour (2007), "Constitution and burden of proof in qualitative matters" Journal of Basic Law, Vol. 4, No. 8, 129-110.
16) Rostami, Wali (2009), "The Taxpayer's Rights", Journal of Law, Vol. 39, No. 1, PP. 107-138.
17) Rostami Tabrizi, Lima, Mohammad Kazem Zare (2016) "Analysis of the Publication of the Conviction Sentence in Iran's Criminal Law from the Viewpoint of Criminal Philosophy", Journal of Criminal Law Research, Vol. 2, No. 4, PP. 140-160.
18) Rostami, Wali, Ahmad Ketabi Roody (2013), "The discretions and Authorities of the Tax System, Time and Method of Tax Collection, Case Study in Iran and the United Kingdom", Journal of Comparative Legal Studies, Vol. 4, No. 2, 165-137.
19) Razavi Fard, Behzad (2016), Strengthening the principle of legality of crimes and Tax penalties, and guaranteeing the implementation of the first steps to prevent tax crimes: with Looking at French law "in promoting the administrative health of the tax system (collection of articles, conference of challenges and the opportunities for health processing of the country's tax system, with an emphasis on preventing Violations), by efforts of Shahram Ebrahimi, Tehran, Mizan Publishing, PP. 129-145.
20- Salimi, Sadiq (2012), Transnational Organized Crime, Tehran, Jangal Publishing.
21- Samawati, Pirouz, Amir (2011), " A Reflection on economic crimes from the perspective of the requirements of economic criminal law"; Journal of Legal Investigations, Attachment No. 56 (Memoir Of Dr. Nurbah), PP. 645-676.
22- Shamloo, Baqir, Majid Moradi (1392), "Limitation of fair trial guarantees in the light of security-ism in the crime of money laundering", Journal of Law of Justice, Vol.77, No.81, PP. 111-159 .
23- Abbasi, Asghar, (2018), combating money laundering in international documents and legal system of Iran, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.
24- Farajih, Mohammad, Mohammad Bagher Moghaddasi (1393), “Populist manifestations in Criminal Drug Policies." Journal of Legal Investigastions, Vol. 17, No. 68, PP. 25-48.
25- Farajih, Mohammad, Mohammad Bagher Moghaddasi (1392), “Criminal Populist Responses to Economic Penetrations" in the Encyclopedia of Criminal Sciences (Collected Papers on New Criminal Sciences), Second Book, Tehran, Mizan Publishing, PP. 1175-1193.
26- Ghadbari, Bahramabadi, Rashid (2010), Developments Of Studying reason in money laundering crime with the approach to international documents, laws and regulations of Iran and England, Master's Thesis, Criminal Law and Criminology, Shahid Beheshti University.
27- Kusha, Ja'far (2011), "Economic security with the confirmation of the prevention and fight against smuggling of goods and money laundering", Journal of Legal Investigastions, Appendix No. 56 (Memoir of Dr. Nouriha), 894-869
28- Kushkei, Gholam Hossein, Nader Alizadeh Sresht (1394), "A Review of the Territory of Security Crimes in the Light of the Competence of the Revolutionary Court", Journal of Criminal Law Research, Vol. 4, No. 12, PP. 99-124.
29-Mohseni, Farbod (2017), "Economic Crime" in the Encyclopedia of Economic Criminal Law under the supervision of Amir Hassan Neyazpour, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.
30- Moazzin Zadegan, Hasan Ali, Abbas Hasani (2014), " Trapping Defense From concept-ology to Journal of Legal Justice", Vol. 78, N. 85, PP. 7-44.
31- Moazzin Zadegan, Hasan Ali, Abbas Hasani (2012), "The State of Trapping Defense in American, French and Iranian Criminal Law", Journal of Criminal Law Doctrines, No. 3, Vol. 78, PP. 23-50.
32- Movahedi, Jafar (1393), Reversing the burden of proof in criminal procedure, Tehran, Majd Publishing.
33- Mahdavipour, Azam (2011); Differential Criminal Policy in the Territory of Economic Delinquency, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.
34) Mehra, Nasrin, Abdolvahid Zahedi (2015), " The New Approach to Criminal Law in the subject of burden of proof of defenses" , Journal of Legal Justice, Vol. 79, No. 90, PP. 63-84.
35- Mir Saeedi, Seyyed Mansour, Mahmoud Zamani (1392), "Economic crime, Definition or Criterion?”, Journal of Criminal Law Research, Vol. 2, No. 4, PP.167-199.
36- Mir Mohammad Sadeghi, Hossein (2017), Financial Crime in the Encyclopedia of Economic Criminal Sciences, under the supervision of Amir Hassan Neyazpour, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.
37-Najafi Ebrahbandadi, Ali Hossein (2013), From White Collar Crime to Economic Crime, Presentations by Michael Elbenson and others, White Collar Crimes, a Circuit Opportunity Approach, Ismail Rahimi Nejad's Translation, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.
38- Najafi Ebrahbandadi, Ali Hossein (2013), About Differential Crime Policy, Preface in: Christian Larser, An Income on Criminal Policy, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.
39- Noorzad, Mojtaba (2010), Economic Crimes in Iran's Criminal Law, Tehran, Jangal Publishing.
40- Walidi, Mohammad Saleh (2014), Economic Criminal Law, Crimes against Economic Security, Vol. 2, Tehran, Jangal Publishing.
41) Yazdiyan Jafari, Jafar (2005), "Trapping, Concept, Foundations and Its Status in Iran's Criminal Law", Specialized Journal of Fiqh and Law, Second Year, No. 2, PP. 132-115
2- Latin
42 - Benson, Micheal and Simpson, Sally(2000), white-collar crime, An opportunity perspective, NEWYORK , Routledge
43- Kofele-Kale, Ndiva(2012) ,Combating Economic Crimes; Balancing competing rights and interests in prosecuting the crime of illicit enrichment, Routledge, London and New york, first published
44- Miller , Banks, Curry , Brett(2009), Expertise ,Experience , and Ideology on Specialized Courts : The Case of the Court of Appeals  for  the Federal Circuit , law and Society Review , Vol. 43 , NO.4 , Doc
45- Patti B, Honorable(2015); The 2015 economic crime guideline amendments, Journal of law and business, New york University, volume 12, Number 1
46-Sjogren , Hans and Goran skogh(2004) , New perspectives  on economic Crime , Edward Elgar publishing Limited