The Evolution of Normative and Legal Authority within the Catholic Church: An Exploration of External and Internal Influences from the 4th to the 15th Century

Mirahmadi, Mansour; Arya, Soroosh

doi:10.22099/jls.2024.48132.4995

The Evolution of Normative and Legal Authority within the Catholic Church: An Exploration of External and Internal Influences from the 4th to the 15th Century

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

Mansour Mirahmadi ¹
Soroosh Arya ²

¹ Associate professor of SBU

² Phd candidate of Shahid Beheshti University

10.22099/jls.2024.48132.4995

Abstract

Introduction: The Catholic Church, throughout its long history, has exerted a profound influence on the lives of Christians in Western Europe. The development of its authority, both normative and legal, has been a subject of keen scholarly interest. Scholars have debated whether this authority was primarily shaped by external factors, such as political and institutional conditions, or by the internal content of the religion itself. This article delves into the intricate process of how the Catholic Church's authority evolved, examining the roles played by both external and internal religious dynamics.

Historical Background: To comprehend the development of the Catholic Church's authority, it is imperative to consider the historical context. From the 4th to the 15th century, the Catholic Church navigated a complex path, marked by significant events and transformations. The church's authority was not static but evolved in response to external pressures and internal theological developments.
External Factors: The Role of Political and Institutional Conditions
External factors played a pivotal role in shaping the authority of the Catholic Church. One of the most profound external influences was its connection with the Roman Empire. The Roman Empire's embrace of Christianity under Emperor Constantine in the 4th century provided the Church with unprecedented political support and resources. This alliance significantly bolstered the Church's authority and facilitated its expansion across Western Europe.
However, the fall of the Roman Empire to barbarian invasions ushered in a period of statelessness and turmoil. During this tumultuous era, the Catholic Church emerged as a stabilizing force, assuming administrative and governance functions that were once held by the state. This transition from Roman patronage to ecclesiastical governance further solidified the Church's authority, as it became an essential institution in a fragmented and politically unstable Europe.
Internal Factors: Theological Developments and Doctrinal Authority
While external factors undoubtedly played a crucial role, the internal content of the Catholic faith should not be overlooked. Theological developments within the Church, driven by figures like Augustine of Hippo and Thomas Aquinas, contributed significantly to the formation of normative and legal authority.
Augustine's profound theological reflections on original sin, salvation, and the nature of the Church itself laid the groundwork for key doctrinal positions. His emphasis on the Church as the custodian of salvation and the necessity of sacraments for salvation greatly bolstered the Church's authority. Moreover, Augustine's teachings on the primacy of divine grace in salvation solidified the Church's role as the mediator of God's grace to humanity.
Thomas Aquinas, in the 13th century, further refined Catholic theology. His Summa Theologica provided a comprehensive synthesis of Christian thought, including ethical and legal principles. Aquinas's articulation of natural law and his exploration of the relationship between faith and reason strengthened the Church's moral and legal authority. The Summa Theologica became a foundational text for centuries of Catholic scholarship and jurisprudence.
The Intersection of External and Internal Factors
It is crucial to recognize that external and internal factors were not isolated but intersected in complex ways. The Church's connection to the Roman Empire, for instance, facilitated the dissemination of theological ideas and ecclesiastical authority. Conversely, theological developments informed the Church's response to external challenges and crises.
The Seven Sacraments: A Case Study
One illustrative example of how external and internal factors converged is the formulation of the seven sacraments within the Catholic Church. This doctrinal development was not merely an internal theological exercise but had profound implications for the Church's authority.
The Council of Trent in the 16th century, building upon centuries of theological reflection, officially defined the seven sacraments. These rituals, including baptism, confirmation, and the Eucharist, became central to the Church's teachings and practices. The authority of the Catholic Church was intimately tied to its exclusive claim to administer these sacraments, which were seen as essential for salvation.

Conclusion: In conclusion, the development of the Catholic Church's authority from the 4th to the 15th century was a multifaceted process influenced by both external and internal factors. While external factors, such as its connection to the Roman Empire and the vacuum left by the fall of Rome, played a pivotal role, internal theological developments and doctrinal authority were equally significant. The Catholic Church's evolution into a dominant religious and moral authority in Western Europe was a result of the dynamic interplay between these external and internal factors. Its claim to administer the seven sacraments, guided by theological giants like Augustine and Aquinas, solidified its normative and legal authority. This intricate relationship between external and internal influences highlights the complexity of historical developments within religious institutions. Understanding the nuanced interplay between these factors is essential for comprehending the enduring impact of the Catholic Church on Western European society during this transformative period.

Keywords

Main Subjects

Public Law

References

Arrunada, B. (2004). Catholic confessions of sin as third-party moral enforcement. The Gruter Institute Working Papers on Law, Economics, and Evolutionary Biology, 3(1), 2.1-35

Benedict, P. (2014). The second wave of Protestant expansion. In The Cambridge History of Christianity (Reprint edition, Vol. 6, pp. 125–142). Cambridge University Press.

Brakke, D. (1994). Canon formation and social conflict in fourth-century Egypt: Athanasius of Alexandria’s thirty-ninth Festal Letter. Harvard Theological Review, 87(4), 395–419.

Carr, M. (2017). Blood and Faith: The Purging of Muslim Spain, 1492-1614. Oxford University Press.

Cary, P. (2007). Sola Fide: Luther and Calvin. Concordia Theological Quarterly, 71(3–4), 265–281.

Church, F. F. (1975). Sex and salvation in Tertullian. The Harvard Theological Review, 68(2), 83–101.

Cunningham, L. S. (2009). An Introduction to Catholicism. Cambridge University Press

Dunn, J. D. G. (2009). Beginning from Jerusalem: Christianity in the Making, Vol 2. Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing.

Ekelund, R. B., Hébert, R. F., & Tollison, R. D. (1989). An economic model of the medieval church: Usury as a form of rent seeking. Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization, 5(2), 307–331.

Estes, J. M. (2003). Luther on the Role of Secular Authority in the Reformation. Lutheran Quarterly, 17(2), 199–225.

Frantzen, A. J. (1982). The tradition of penitentials in Anglo-Saxon England. Anglo-Saxon England, 11, 23–56.

https://doi.org/10.1017/S0263675100002556/

Freeze, G. L. (1985). Handmaiden of the State? The Church in Imperial Russia Reconsidered. The Journal of Ecclesiastical History, 36(1), 82–102. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022046900023964/

Fukuyama, F. (2011). The Origins of Political Order: From Prehuman Times to the French Revolution. Profile Books.

Gannon, P. J. (1942). Review of The Life and Times of St. Leo the Great, by T. Jalland. Studies: An Irish Quarterly Review, 31(124), 521–524.

Gerrish, B. A. (1965). Priesthood and Ministry in the Theology of Luther. Church History, 34(4), 404–422. https://doi.org/10.2307/3163119/

Gudziak, B. A. (1996). The Kyivan Metropolitanate Preceding the Union of Brest. Logos, 37(219–271), 219–271.

Hanson, R. P. C. (1972). The Reaction of the Church to the Collapse of the Western Roman Empire in the Fifth Century. Vigiliae Christianae, 26(4), 272–287. https://doi.org/10.2307/1583559

Harries, J. (2012). Imperial Rome AD 284 to 363: The New Empire. Edinburgh University Press.

Horujy, S. S. (2019). The Two Sorts of Hesychast Ethics. Russian Studies in Philosophy, 57(1), 40–69.

Hsia, R. P.-C. (2014). The Cambridge History of Christianity (Reprint edition). Cambridge University Press.

John, E. (1976). The Papacy and the Historian: Romans and Germans. New Blackfriars, 57(671), 152–159. JSTOR.

Jr, T. E. D. (1969). The Theory of Charisma. The Sociological Quarterly, 10(3), 306–318. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1533-8525.1969.tb01294.x/

Kelly, H. A. (2016). Heaven Can Wait: Purgatory in Catholic Devotional and Popular Culture by Diana Walsh Pasulka (review). The Catholic Historical Review, 102(1), 124–125.

https://doi.org/10.1353/cat.2016.0010/

Kingdon, R. (2014). The Calvinist Reformation in Geneva. In The Cambridge History of Christianity (Vol. 6, pp. 90–102). Cambridge University Press.

Louth, A. (2013). Introducing Eastern Orthodox Theology. SPCK.

Lovgren, S. (2006, April 6). Lost Gospel Revealed; Says Jesus Asked Judas to Betray Him. Science.

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2006/04/lost-gospel-judas-revealed-jesus-archaeology/

Lucia Diamond JD cum laude, M. (2001). Roman and Canon Law Research. Legal Reference Services Quarterly, 20(1–2), 99–112. https://doi.org/10.1300/J113v20n01_10/

MacCulloch, D. (2010). A History of Christianity: The First Three Thousand Years. Penguin Books Limited.

Magill, F. N., & Aves, A. (1998). Dictionary of World Biography: The Middle Ages. Routledge.

Mahoney, J. (2015). Process Tracing and Historical Explanation. Security Studies, 24(2), 200–218. https://doi.org/10.1080/09636412.2015.1036610

McKinnon, A. M. (2010). Elective Affinities of the Protestant Ethic: Weber and the Chemistry of Capitalism. Sociological Theory, 28(1), 108–126. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9558.2009.01367.x

Møller, J. (2017). Medieval origins of the rule of law: The Gregorian reforms as critical juncture? Hague Journal on the Rule of Law, 9(2), 265–282.

Negrut, P. (1995). Orthodox Soteriology: Theosis. Churchman, 109(2), 154–170.

Nickles, T. (2017). Scientific Revolutions. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2017). Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University.

https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2017/entries/scientific-revolutions/

Owen, J. M. (2005). When Do Ideologies Produce Alliances? The Holy Roman Empire, 1517-1555. International Studies Quarterly, 49(1), 73–99.

Padinjarekutt, I. (2005). Christianity Through the Centuries. St Pauls BYB.

Philip, M. (2016). Problematizing the Notion of the Bible as an Original Text. International Multidisciplinary Research Journal, Volume IV(Issue IV), 46–51.

Ramelli, I. (2007). Christian Soteriology and Christian Platonism: Origen, Gregory of Nyssa, and the Biblical and Philosophical Basis of the Doctrine of Apokatastasis. Vigiliae Christianae, 61(3), 313–356.

Ricks, J. I., & Liu, A. H. (2018). Process-Tracing Research Designs: A Practical Guide. PS: Political Science & Politics, 51(4), 842–846. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1049096518000975

Ringer, F. K. (2009). Max Weber’s Methodology: The Unification of the Cultural and Social Sciences. Harvard University Press.

Rodriguez, E. (n.d.). Conclave | Roman Catholic Church. In Encyclopedia Britannica. Retrieved December 31, 2020, from https://www.britannica.com/topic/conclave

Rolf, S. (2010). Luther’s Understanding of Imputatio in the Context of his Doctrine of Justification and Its Consequences for the Preaching of the Gospel. International Journal of Systematic Theology, 12(4), 435–451. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2400.2009.00493.x

Shaw, W. M. (Elmien). (2017). Theology of religions in Martin Luther. HTS Theological Studies, 73, 26–32.

Sirks, A. J. (2013). The episcopalis audientia in Late Antiquity. Droit et Cultures. Revue Internationale Interdisciplinaire, 65, 79–88.

Soulis, G. C. (1965). The legacy of Cyril and Methodius to the Southern Slavs. Dumbarton Oaks Papers, 19, 19–43.

Straumann, B. (2008). The peace of Westphalia as a secular constitution. Constellations, 15(2), 173–188.

Straw, C. (2020). Saint Gregory the Great | Biography, Papacy, Legacy, & Facts. In Encyclopedia Britannica.

https://www.britannica.com/biography/St-Gregory-the-Great

Tov, E. (1988). The Septuagint. The Literature of the Jewish People in the Period of the Second Temple and the Talmud, Volume 1 Mikra, 161–188. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004275102_006/

Viola, F., & Barna, G. (2010). Pagan Christianity?: Exploring the Roots of Our Church Practices. Tyndale House Publishers, Inc.

Von Grunebaum, G. E. (1962). Byzantine Iconoclasm and the Influence of the Islamic Environment. History of Religions, 2(1), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1086/462453

Westhelle, V. (2005). Luther on the Authority of Scripture. The Johns Hopkins University Press, 19(4), 373–391.

Zentner, M. H. (2015). The Black Death and Its Impact on the Church and Popular Religion [Undergraduate, The University of Mississippi]. http://thesis.honors.olemiss.edu/338/

Zukowski, J. C. (2009). The Role and Status of the Catholic Church in the Church-State Relationship Within the Roman Empire from AD 306 to 814 [Andrews University].

https://digitalcommons.andrews.edu/dissertations/174/

Zweynert, J. (2016). Economics in Russia: Studies in Intellectual History. Routledge.