A Comparative Examination of the Concept of Justice in the Political Philosophy of Plato and Aristotle

Document Type : Research Paper

Author

professor in Department of political science, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran

Abstract

Given the importance of the concept of justice in the existing legal systems of the world and its overwhelming influence on the Islamic philosophy, this research seeks to genealogize the concept of justice in the writings of Aristotle and Plato and critique the basic arguments made by these two giant thinkers. The basic assumption of this research is that in the view of Plato, justice is an inherently individual enterprise which ultimately enters into the public space of society. In his theory, governance is the art of the wise. On the other hand, Aristotle defines justice as a virtue which gives one what he deserves.  Aristotle is of the belief that the virtue of everything lies in observing the boundaries of moderation. Aristotle further argues that moderation is in nature of things and nature itself is unequal and justice is the continuation of these inequalities. Instead of giving a generalized definition of justice like Plato, Aristotle applies more caution to the concept of justice. This arises from the inductive and experimental approach of Aristotle and his general avoidance of generalization.
 

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

Soures
1. Akhavan Kazemi, Bahram (2007), Justice in Political Thoughts of Islam, Qom, Institute of Boostan ketab, Second  Edition. (In Persian)
2. Akhavan Kazemi, Bahram (2002), Justice in the political system of Islam, Tehran, Contemporary Danesh Institute(In Persian).
3. Akhavan Kazemi, Bahram (1999), "Justice and Autocracy in Farabi's Political Philosophy", Quarterly Journal of Imam Sadiq University, No. 9, pp. 65-33. (In Persian)
4. Akhavan Kazemi, Bahram (2010) "Review and Evaluation of Platonic Justice from the Point of View of Alavi's Thoughts" Alawi's Journal, No. 1, Spring and Summer, p. 139-161. (In Persian)
5. Aristotle Talis (1979), Al-Khalah, (translated into Arabic), Ishaq ibn Hinin, Fichteh, and Phrases;
Abdul Rahman Badooi, Al-Qawit, and the Press Club. (In Persian)
6. Aristotle (Bi), Nicomachean Ethics, Persian Translation, Tehran, University of Tehran. (In Persian)
7. Aristotle (1364), Faithful, Nico Mack's Ethics, Collection and Translation by Reza Mashayekhi, Tehran, Dehkhoda Book Store, (In Persian)
8. Plato (1360), Republic, spiritual benefits, Tehran, Translation and Publishing Agency. (In Persian)
9. Bashirieh, Hossein, Government of Allah, Tehran, New Scientist Publishing House, First year, 1374. (In Persian)
10. Bashirieh, Hossein, and Musa Ghanini-Nejad (1997), "Religion and justice in the opinion of scholars," transgression [religion and justice], Review, third year, number two and third, spring and summer, P. 344. (In Persian)
11. Bern, Jean (1373), Aristotle and Masha's Philosophy, Seyyed Abolqasem Pourhosseini, Tehran, Amir Kabir Publishing House. (In Persian)
12. Popper, Carl. R (1364), Open Society and its enemies, Ali Asghar Mohajer, Tehran, Public Joint Stock Company. (In Persian)
13. Javan, Moses (1336), The Foundations of Law, C 1, Tehran, Ramin Kamal Co. (In Persian)
14. Russell is superior (1365), History of Western Philosophy, First Counselor, Najaf Daribandari, Tehran, Flight Publishing. (In Persian)
15Davari Ardakani, Reza, Farabi, Tehran, New Design, First Season, 1374.
16. Office of the University of Tehran (1989), Income on Islamic Law, Tehran. (In Persian)
17. Halabi, Ali Asghar (1993), History of Political Thoughts in Iran and the Islamic World, Tehran, Behbahani. (In Persian)
18. Foster, Michael B. (1373), The Lord of the Political Thought, First Counselor, Javad Sheikholeslami, Tehran, Scientific and Cultural Company, Second Edition, First Edition. (In Persian)
19. Alem, Abdul Rahman (1373), Political Science Foundation, Tehran, Publishing. (In Persian)
20. Enayat, Hamid (1351), the Foundation for Political Philosophy in the West, from each Tahabs, Tehran, Tehran University. (In Persian)
21. Maghy, Bryan (1375), Great Philosophers, Familiarity with Western Philosophy, Ezatollah Fooladvand, Tehran, Kharazmi. (In Persian)
22. Naimi, Sheikh Abdullah, Shiite philosophers, Seyyed Ajafarzaghan, Tehran, Publishing Organization and Teaching the Islamic Revolution, 1988. (In Persian)
23. Naghibzadeh, Mir Abdolhossein (1372), An Introduction to Philosophy, Tehran, Tahoori Library, Second Edition. (In Persian)
24. Hashemi Haeri, Elahe (1373), Greek philosophy from another point of view, Tehran, Mashkat Publication.(In Persian)
25-Hoffe, otfried(1991), La Justice Politique, traduit et adapte de L,Allemand par Jean- Christophe merle, Presse universitaires de France (P.U.F).

26- Perelman, chaim,(1970) Justice et raison, edition de universite de Bruxelles, 2e edition.
27- Khadduri, Majid(1984), The Islamic Conception of Justice, Baltimore and London: The Johns Hopkins university press.
28- Madkour, (I.), (1934),La Place d'al-Farabi dans L'ecole Pilosophique musulmane, Paris.
29- Rawls, Jhon,(1987) A theory of Justices, Oxford University Press, Traduction fracaise: Theorie de La Justice, Paris, Editions du seuil.
30-Rosenthal, Erwin, I.J.(1962), Political thought in medieval ISLAM, Cambridge at tht universtiy press.
31-Vecchio, George DEL. (1938), Justice, Droit, ETAT, Librairie Du Recueil SIREY .
 
32-Velastos,(1971), Justice and Happiness in the Republic , Plato: A collection of critical Essays, ed.G. Vlastos, New york: Ancher Books

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics