<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!DOCTYPE article PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD Journal Publishing DTD v3.0 20080202//EN" "journalpublishing3.dtd">
<article article-type="Research Paper" dtd-version="3.0" xml:lang="en">
			  <front>
			    <journal-meta>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="pmc"></journal-id>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="publisher-id">دانشگاه شیراز</journal-id>
			    	<journal-title-group>
				      <journal-title>Journal of Legal Studies</journal-title>
			    	</journal-title-group>
			      <issn pub-type="ppub">2008-7926</issn>
			      <publisher>
			        <publisher-name>دانشگاه شیراز</publisher-name>
			      </publisher>
			    </journal-meta>
			    <article-meta>
 			      <article-id pub-id-type="publisher-id">13</article-id>
			      <article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.22099/jls.2018.29099.2895</article-id>		
			      <ext-link xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5039_8080b18786064df0b81925f863ca55ee.pdf"/>		
			      <article-categories>
			        <subj-group subj-group-type="heading">
					          		<subject>حقوق عمومی</subject>
			        	</subj-group>
			      </article-categories>
			      <title-group>
			        <article-title>A Comparative Examination of the Concept of Justice in the Political Philosophy of Plato and Aristotle</article-title>
			        
			      </title-group>
			      
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c1" corresp="yes">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Akhavan</surname>
			            <given-names>Bahram</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>professor in Department of political science, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			      <pub-date pub-type="ppub">
			        <day>22</day>
			        <month>11</month>
			        <year>2018</year>
			      </pub-date>
			      <volume>10</volume>
			      <issue>3</issue>
			      <fpage>1</fpage>
			      <lpage>27</lpage>
			      <history>
			        <date date-type="received">
			          <day>18</day>
			          <month>04</month>
			          <year>2018</year>
			        </date>
			        <date date-type="accepted">
			          <day>16</day>
			          <month>07</month>
			          <year>2018</year>
			        </date>
			      </history>
			      <permissions>
			      	<copyright-statement>Copyright &#x000a9; 2018, دانشگاه شیراز. </copyright-statement>	
			        <copyright-year>2018</copyright-year>
			      </permissions>
			       <self-uri xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5039.html">https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5039.html</self-uri> 		
			      <abstract>
			        <p>Given the importance of the concept of justice in the existing legal systems of the world and its overwhelming influence on the Islamic philosophy, this research seeks to genealogize the concept of justice in the writings of Aristotle and Plato and critique the basic arguments made by these two giant thinkers. The basic assumption of this research is that in the view of Plato, justice is an inherently individual enterprise which ultimately enters into the public space of society. In his theory, governance is the art of the wise. On the other hand, Aristotle defines justice as a virtue which gives one what he deserves.  Aristotle is of the belief that the virtue of everything lies in observing the boundaries of moderation. Aristotle further argues that moderation is in nature of things and nature itself is unequal and justice is the continuation of these inequalities. Instead of giving a generalized definition of justice like Plato, Aristotle applies more caution to the concept of justice. This arises from the inductive and experimental approach of Aristotle and his general avoidance of generalization.  </p>
			      </abstract>
					<kwd-group kwd-group-type="author">
						<kwd>Justice-Plato</kwd>
						<kwd>Law- Legitimacy</kwd>
						<kwd>Farabi Justice</kwd>
						<kwd>Plato</kwd>
						<kwd>Aristotle</kwd>
						<kwd>Political Philosophy</kwd>
						<kwd>Law</kwd>
						<kwd>Legitimacy</kwd>
						<kwd>Farabi</kwd>
					</kwd-group>
			    </article-meta>
			  </front>
<back>
	<ref-list>
		<ref id="R1">
			<label>1</label>
			<element-citation>الف. فارسی</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R2">
			<label>2</label>
			<element-citation>اخوان کاظمى، بهرام (1386)، عدالت در اندیشه های سیاسی اسلام،قم، موسسه بوستان کتاب (مرکز چاپ و نشر دفتر تبلیغات اسلامی حوزه علمیه قم)، چا پ دوم.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R3">
			<label>3</label>
			<element-citation>اخوان کاظمى، بهرام (1381)، عدالت درنظام سیاسی اسلام، تهران، موسسه دانش و اندیشه معاصر.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R4">
			<label>4</label>
			<element-citation>اخوان کاظمى، بهرام(1378)، «عدالت و خودکامگی در فلسفه سیاسی فارابی»، فصلنامه پژوهشی دانشگاه امام صادق(ع)،شماره 9، ص 65-33.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R5">
			<label>5</label>
			<element-citation>اخوان کاظمى، بهرام(1389) « نقد و ارزیابی عدالت افلاطونی از منظر اندیشه علوی» پژوهشنامه علوی ،شماره اول،بهار و تابستان،ص 139-161.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R6">
			<label>6</label>
			<element-citation>ارسطو(بی تا)، اخلاق نیکوماخس، ترجمه‏ى فارسى، تهران، دانشگاه تهران.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R7">
			<label>7</label>
			<element-citation>ارسطو(1364)،الاخلاق، اخلاق نیکو ماک، جمع‏آورى و ترجمه‏ى رضا مشایخى، تهران،کتابفروشى دهخدا،</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R8">
			<label>8</label>
			<element-citation>افلاطون(1360)، جمهورى، فوائد روحانى، تهران، بنگاه ترجمه و نشر کتاب.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R9">
			<label>9</label>
			<element-citation>بشیریه، حسین(1374)، دولت عقل، تهران، مؤسسه‏ى نشر علوم نوین.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R10">
			<label>10</label>
			<element-citation>بشیریه، حسین، و موسى‏غنى‏نژاد(1376)، «دین و عدالت در نظرخواهى از دانشوران، «افتراح [دین و عدالت]»، نقد ونظر، سال سوم، شماره‏ى دوم و سوم، بهار و تابستان، ص 34ـ4.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R11">
			<label>11</label>
			<element-citation>برن، ژان (1373)،ارسطو و حکمت مشاء، سیدابوالقاسم پورحسینى، تهران، مؤسسه‏ى انتشارات امیرکبیر.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R12">
			<label>12</label>
			<element-citation>پوپر، کارل. ر. (1364)،جامعه‏ى باز و دشمنانش، على اصغر مهاجر، تهران، شرکت سهامى انتشار.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R13">
			<label>13</label>
			<element-citation>جوان، موسى(1336)، مبانى حقوق، ج 1، تهران، شرکت رنگین کمال</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R14">
			<label>14</label>
			<element-citation>راسل، برتر اند(1365)،تاریخ فلسفه‏ى غرب، ج اول، نجف دریابندرى، تهران، نشر پرواز.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R15">
			<label>15</label>
			<element-citation>داورى اردکانى،رضا (1374)، فارابى، تهران، طرح نو.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R16">
			<label>16</label>
			<element-citation>دفتر همکارى حوزه و دانشگاه(1368)، درآمدى بر حقوق اسلامى، تهران، سمت.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R17">
			<label>17</label>
			<element-citation>حلبى، على‏اصغر(1372)، تاریخ اندیشه‏هاى سیاسى در ایران و جهان اسلامى، تهران، بهبهانى.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R18">
			<label>18</label>
			<element-citation>فاستر، مایکل ب. (1373)، خداوندان اندیشه‏ى سیاسى، ج اول، جواد شیخ الاسلامى، تهران، شرکت انتشارات علمى و فرهنگى، ویراسته دوم، چاپ اول.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R19">
			<label>19</label>
			<element-citation>عالم، عبدالرحمن (1373)، بنیادهاى علم سیاست، تهران،نشر نی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R20">
			<label>20</label>
			<element-citation>عنایت، حمید(1351)، بنیاد فلسفه‏ى سیاسى در غرب، از هر اکلیت تا هابز، تهران، دانشگاه تهران،</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R21">
			<label>21</label>
			<element-citation>مگى، برایان(1375)، فلاسفه‏ى بزرگ، آشنایى با فلسفه‏ى غرب، عزت‏الله فولادوند، تهران،خوارزمى.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R22">
			<label>22</label>
			<element-citation>نعمه‏ى، شیخ عبدالله(1367)، فلاسفه شیعه، سیدجعفرغضبان، تهران، سازمان انتشارات و</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R23">
			<label>23</label>
			<element-citation>آموزش انقلاب اسلامى.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R24">
			<label>24</label>
			<element-citation>نقیب‏زاده، میر عبدالحسین(1372)، درآمدى به فلسفه، تهران، کتابخانه‏ى طهورى، چاپ دوم.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R25">
			<label>25</label>
			<element-citation>هاشمى حائرى، الهه(1373)، فلسفه‏ى یونان از دیدگاهى دیگر، تهران، انتشارات مشکات.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R26">
			<label>26</label>
			<element-citation> ب. عربی</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R27">
			<label>27</label>
			<element-citation>ارسطا طالیس(1979)، الاخلاق، (ترجمه به عربى)، اسحق بن‏حنین، حققه و شرحه و قدّم له؛ الدکتور</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R28">
			<label>28</label>
			<element-citation>عبدالرحمن بدوى، الکویت، وکالة المطبوعات.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R29">
			<label>29</label>
			<element-citation> ج . منابع انگلیسى و فرانسه</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R30">
			<label>30</label>
			<element-citation>Hoffe, otfried (1991), La Justice Politique, traduit et adapte de L,Allemand par Jean- Christophe merle, Presse universitaires de France (P.U.F).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R31">
			<label>31</label>
			<element-citation>Perelman, chaim,(1970) Justice et raison, edition de universite de Bruxelles, 2e edition.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R32">
			<label>32</label>
			<element-citation>Khadduri, Majid (1984), The Islamic Conception of Justice, Baltimore and London: The Johns Hopkins university press.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R33">
			<label>33</label>
			<element-citation>Madkour, Ibrahim, (1934), La Place d'al-Farabi dans L'ecole Pilosophique musulmane, Paris.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R34">
			<label>34</label>
			<element-citation>Rawls, Jhon,(1987) A theory of Justices, Oxford University Press, Traduction fracaise: Theorie de La Justice, Paris, Editions du seuil.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R35">
			<label>35</label>
			<element-citation>Rosenthal, Erwin, I.J. (1962), Political thought in medieval islam, Cambridge at tht universtiy press.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R36">
			<label>36</label>
			<element-citation>Vecchio, George DEL. (1938), Justice, Droit, ETAT, Librairie Du Recueil SIREY.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R37">
			<label>37</label>
			<element-citation>Velastos,(1971), Justice and Happiness in the Republic , Plato: A collection of critical Essays, ed.G. Vlastos, New york: Ancher Books</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R38">
			<label>38</label>
			<element-citation> _||_</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R39">
			<label>39</label>
			<element-citation>1. Akhavan Kazemi, Bahram (2007), Justice in Political Thoughts of Islam, Qom, Institute of Boostan ketab, Second  Edition. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R40">
			<label>40</label>
			<element-citation>2. Akhavan Kazemi, Bahram (2002), Justice in the political system of Islam, Tehran, Contemporary Danesh Institute(In Persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R41">
			<label>41</label>
			<element-citation>3. Akhavan Kazemi, Bahram (1999), "Justice and Autocracy in Farabi's Political Philosophy", Quarterly Journal of Imam Sadiq University, No. 9, pp. 65-33. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R42">
			<label>42</label>
			<element-citation>4. Akhavan Kazemi, Bahram (2010) "Review and Evaluation of Platonic Justice from the Point of View of Alavi's Thoughts" Alawi's Journal, No. 1, Spring and Summer, p. 139-161. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R43">
			<label>43</label>
			<element-citation>5. Aristotle Talis (1979), Al-Khalah, (translated into Arabic), Ishaq ibn Hinin, Fichteh, and Phrases;</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R44">
			<label>44</label>
			<element-citation>Abdul Rahman Badooi, Al-Qawit, and the Press Club. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R45">
			<label>45</label>
			<element-citation>6. Aristotle (Bi), Nicomachean Ethics, Persian Translation, Tehran, University of Tehran. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R46">
			<label>46</label>
			<element-citation>7. Aristotle (1364), Faithful, Nico Mack's Ethics, Collection and Translation by Reza Mashayekhi, Tehran, Dehkhoda Book Store, (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R47">
			<label>47</label>
			<element-citation>8. Plato (1360), Republic, spiritual benefits, Tehran, Translation and Publishing Agency. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R48">
			<label>48</label>
			<element-citation>9. Bashirieh, Hossein, Government of Allah, Tehran, New Scientist Publishing House, First year, 1374. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R49">
			<label>49</label>
			<element-citation>10. Bashirieh, Hossein, and Musa Ghanini-Nejad (1997), "Religion and justice in the opinion of scholars," transgression [religion and justice], Review, third year, number two and third, spring and summer, P. 344. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R50">
			<label>50</label>
			<element-citation>11. Bern, Jean (1373), Aristotle and Masha's Philosophy, Seyyed Abolqasem Pourhosseini, Tehran, Amir Kabir Publishing House. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R51">
			<label>51</label>
			<element-citation>12. Popper, Carl. R (1364), Open Society and its enemies, Ali Asghar Mohajer, Tehran, Public Joint Stock Company. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R52">
			<label>52</label>
			<element-citation>13. Javan, Moses (1336), The Foundations of Law, C 1, Tehran, Ramin Kamal Co. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R53">
			<label>53</label>
			<element-citation>14. Russell is superior (1365), History of Western Philosophy, First Counselor, Najaf Daribandari, Tehran, Flight Publishing. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R54">
			<label>54</label>
			<element-citation>15Davari Ardakani, Reza, Farabi, Tehran, New Design, First Season, 1374.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R55">
			<label>55</label>
			<element-citation>16. Office of the University of Tehran (1989), Income on Islamic Law, Tehran. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R56">
			<label>56</label>
			<element-citation>17. Halabi, Ali Asghar (1993), History of Political Thoughts in Iran and the Islamic World, Tehran, Behbahani. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R57">
			<label>57</label>
			<element-citation>18. Foster, Michael B. (1373), The Lord of the Political Thought, First Counselor, Javad Sheikholeslami, Tehran, Scientific and Cultural Company, Second Edition, First Edition. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R58">
			<label>58</label>
			<element-citation>19. Alem, Abdul Rahman (1373), Political Science Foundation, Tehran, Publishing. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R59">
			<label>59</label>
			<element-citation>20. Enayat, Hamid (1351), the Foundation for Political Philosophy in the West, from each Tahabs, Tehran, Tehran University. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R60">
			<label>60</label>
			<element-citation>21. Maghy, Bryan (1375), Great Philosophers, Familiarity with Western Philosophy, Ezatollah Fooladvand, Tehran, Kharazmi. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R61">
			<label>61</label>
			<element-citation>22. Naimi, Sheikh Abdullah, Shiite philosophers, Seyyed Ajafarzaghan, Tehran, Publishing Organization and Teaching the Islamic Revolution, 1988. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R62">
			<label>62</label>
			<element-citation>23. Naghibzadeh, Mir Abdolhossein (1372), An Introduction to Philosophy, Tehran, Tahoori Library, Second Edition. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R63">
			<label>63</label>
			<element-citation>24. Hashemi Haeri, Elahe (1373), Greek philosophy from another point of view, Tehran, Mashkat Publication.(In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R64">
			<label>64</label>
			<element-citation>25-Hoffe, otfried(1991), La Justice Politique, traduit et adapte de L,Allemand par Jean- Christophe merle, Presse universitaires de France (P.U.F).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R65">
			<label>65</label>
			<element-citation>26- Perelman, chaim,(1970) Justice et raison, edition de universite de Bruxelles, 2e edition.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R66">
			<label>66</label>
			<element-citation>27- Khadduri, Majid(1984), The Islamic Conception of Justice, Baltimore and London: The Johns Hopkins university press.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R67">
			<label>67</label>
			<element-citation>28- Madkour, (I.), (1934),La Place d'al-Farabi dans L'ecole Pilosophique musulmane, Paris.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R68">
			<label>68</label>
			<element-citation>29- Rawls, Jhon,(1987) A theory of Justices, Oxford University Press, Traduction fracaise: Theorie de La Justice, Paris, Editions du seuil.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R69">
			<label>69</label>
			<element-citation>30-Rosenthal, Erwin, I.J.(1962), Political thought in medieval ISLAM, Cambridge at tht universtiy press.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R70">
			<label>70</label>
			<element-citation>31-Vecchio, George DEL. (1938), Justice, Droit, ETAT, Librairie Du Recueil SIREY .</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R71">
			<label>71</label>
			<element-citation>32-Velastos,(1971), Justice and Happiness in the Republic , Plato: A collection of critical Essays, ed.G. Vlastos, New york: Ancher Books</element-citation>
		</ref>
	</ref-list>
		</back>
</article>
<article article-type="Research Paper" dtd-version="3.0" xml:lang="en">
			  <front>
			    <journal-meta>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="pmc"></journal-id>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="publisher-id">دانشگاه شیراز</journal-id>
			    	<journal-title-group>
				      <journal-title>Journal of Legal Studies</journal-title>
			    	</journal-title-group>
			      <issn pub-type="ppub">2008-7926</issn>
			      <publisher>
			        <publisher-name>دانشگاه شیراز</publisher-name>
			      </publisher>
			    </journal-meta>
			    <article-meta>
 			      <article-id pub-id-type="publisher-id">13</article-id>
			      <article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.22099/jls.2018.26991.2614</article-id>		
			      <ext-link xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5026_1764a1d831275a6e2fbe2a26a646b470.pdf"/>		
			      <article-categories>
			        <subj-group subj-group-type="heading">
					          		<subject>تجارت بین الملل</subject>
			        	</subj-group>
			      </article-categories>
			      <title-group>
			        <article-title>The New Oil Order of Iran and Its Impact on Designing Upstream Contracts in Oil Industry</article-title>
			        
			      </title-group>
			      
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c1" corresp="yes">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Bahmaei</surname>
			            <given-names>Mohammad Ali</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>Assistant Professor in international trade law department, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c2">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Zare Sheibani</surname>
			            <given-names>Davood</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>PhD student in international trade law department, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran.</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			      <pub-date pub-type="ppub">
			        <day>22</day>
			        <month>11</month>
			        <year>2018</year>
			      </pub-date>
			      <volume>10</volume>
			      <issue>3</issue>
			      <fpage>29</fpage>
			      <lpage>65</lpage>
			      <history>
			        <date date-type="received">
			          <day>18</day>
			          <month>12</month>
			          <year>2017</year>
			        </date>
			        <date date-type="accepted">
			          <day>18</day>
			          <month>06</month>
			          <year>2018</year>
			        </date>
			      </history>
			      <permissions>
			      	<copyright-statement>Copyright &#x000a9; 2018, دانشگاه شیراز. </copyright-statement>	
			        <copyright-year>2018</copyright-year>
			      </permissions>
			       <self-uri xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5026.html">https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5026.html</self-uri> 		
			      <abstract>
			        <p>Even though the Buy-back contracts is introduced as sole method for performing upstream Oil projects, by virtue of laws such as budget and development program laws, after Islamic revolution of Iran, new regulations were passed in recent decades that indicated on formation of new legal order in petroleum industry. The Sprout of Iran&#039;s new oil and gas order, initially formed by a change in attitudes towards foreign investment, grew up by changing the scope of private sector intervention in the economy and developed by introducing and prescribing various oil contracts. On the other hand in the event of this developments, petroleum ministry unveiled a new model of contract named Iran Petroleum Contract (IPC). Although IPC is based on the principles of Iran&#039;s new oil order, it seems that it has not used all the capacities articulated in this order. Explaining the fundamentals and content of this order, the ratio of the new contract to these developments and eventually the ability to apply other contractual patterns will be discussed in this article.  </p>
			      </abstract>
					<kwd-group kwd-group-type="author">
						<kwd>New Oil Order</kwd>
						<kwd>foreign investment</kwd>
						<kwd>privatization</kwd>
						<kwd>General principles</kwd>
						<kwd>new Iran Petroleum Contract</kwd>
						<kwd>production sharing</kwd>
					</kwd-group>
			    </article-meta>
			  </front>
<back>
	<ref-list>
		<ref id="R1">
			<label>1</label>
			<element-citation>الف. فارسی</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R2">
			<label>2</label>
			<element-citation>ابراهیمی، سید نصرالله و شیریجیان (1391) «محمد، قراردادهای بالادستی نفت و گاز جمهوری اسلامی ایران و تبیین دلالت های قانونی و الزامات قراردادهای جدید»، فصلنامه اقتصاد انرژی ایران، سال سوم، شماره 10، بهار 1393،صص 39-1.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R3">
			<label>3</label>
			<element-citation>ابراهیمی، سید نصرالله، صادقی مقدم، محمدحسن و سراج، نرگس (1391)، «انتقادهای وارده بر قراردادهای بیع متقابل صنعت نفت و گاز ایران و پاسخ‌های آن»، فصلنامه حقوق، مجله دانشکده حقوق و علوم سیاسی دانشگاه تهران، دوره 42، زمستان،4، صص19-1.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R4">
			<label>4</label>
			<element-citation>اصغریان، مجتبی (1395)، قراردادهای بین‌المللی نفتی خدماتی در بخش بالادستی و قابلیت اعمال آن‌ها در حقوق ایران، رساله‌‌ دکتری حقوق بین‌الملل، دانشگاه شهید بهشتی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R5">
			<label>5</label>
			<element-citation>ایرانپور، فرهاد (1386)، «مبانی عمومی قراردادهای نفتی»، فصلنامه حقوق، مجله دانشکده حقوق و علوم سیاسی دانشگاه تهران، دوره 37، پائیز، 3، صص 28-1.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R6">
			<label>6</label>
			<element-citation>ایمانی، مقصود و درخشان، مسعود (1394). «نشست از دارسی تا‌‌‌ آی‌پی‌سی»، قابل مشاهده در: از-دارسی-تا-آی-پی-سی/http://icmstudy.ir/tag، به تاریخ 22 نوامبر 2015</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R7">
			<label>7</label>
			<element-citation>حاتمی، علی و کریمیان، اسماعیل (1393) حقوق سرمایه‌گذاری خارجی در پرتو قانون و قراردادهای سرمایه‌گذاری، تهران: انتشارات تیسا.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R8">
			<label>8</label>
			<element-citation>درخشان مسعود (1393) «قراردادهای نفتی از منظر تولید صیانتی و ازدیاد برداشت: رویکرد اقتصاد مقاومتی»، دو فصلنامه علمی پژوهشی مطالعات اقتصاد اسلامی، بهار و تابستان ، 2، صص 52-7.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R9">
			<label>9</label>
			<element-citation>رمضانی قوام‌آبادی، محمدحسین و سیمائی صراف، حسین (1393) «از مالکیت تا حاکمیت: مطالعه‌‌ی تطبیقی محیط زیست در حقوق و فقه اسلامی» دو فصلنامه‌‌ دانش حقوق مدنی، بهار و تابستان، 1، صص 12-1.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R10">
			<label>10</label>
			<element-citation>زارع شیبانی، داوود (1391)، مفهوم سرمایه‌گذاری در حقوق بین‌الملل سرمایه‌گذاری، پایان‌نامه‌ی کارشناسی ارشد حقوق تجارت بین‌الملل، دانشگاه شهید بهشتی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R11">
			<label>11</label>
			<element-citation>شیروی، عبدالحسین (1393) حقوق نفت و گاز، تهران: نشر میزان.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R12">
			<label>12</label>
			<element-citation>موحد، محمدعلی (1376) «قراردادهای نفتی پس از درنگی بیست‌ساله»، مجله اقتصاد انرژی، بهار، 2 و 3، صص 87-79.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R13">
			<label>13</label>
			<element-citation>موسوی، سید حسن (1395) تحلیل حقوقی الگوی قراردادی خدمت در بخش بالادستی صنعت نفت و گاز ایران، (با تأکید بر تحلیل الگوی قرادادی جدید «‌‌‌آی‌پی‌سی»)، رساله دکتری حقوق خصوصی، دانشگاه شهید بهشتی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R14">
			<label>14</label>
			<element-citation>نیکبخت، حمیدرضا و آرین، محمد (1394) «طراحی الگوهای قراردادی جدید برای توسعه‌‌ی میادین ‌هیدروکربوری ‌‌‌ایران: بررسی و نقد قانون جدید وزارت نفت»، فصلنامه تحقیقات حقوقی، پائیز، 71، صص 120-75.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R15">
			<label>15</label>
			<element-citation>نیکبخت، حمیدرضا و موسوی، سید حسن (1394) «اصول و ساختار الگوی جدید قراردادهای نفتی ‌‌‌ایران»، فصلنامه تحقیقات حقوقی، زمستان، 72، صص 69-35.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R16">
			<label>16</label>
			<element-citation>ب. انگلیسی</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R17">
			<label>17</label>
			<element-citation>Atwell, J. E. (1980) "Changing Relationships between Host Countries and International Petroleum Companies", Houston Law Review, Vol. 17,pp. 1002-20.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R18">
			<label>18</label>
			<element-citation>Bernard Taverne,(1996) Production Sharing Agreements in Principle and in  Practice, in Upstream Oil and Gas Agreements, edithed by Matryn R. David. Sweet &amp; Maxwell Pub. London.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R19">
			<label>19</label>
			<element-citation>Bindemann, Kirsten,(1999)"Production Sharing Agreements: An Economic Analysis", Oxford Institute For Energy Studies.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R20">
			<label>20</label>
			<element-citation>Blinn Keith. W., Claude. Duval, Honoré L. Leuch &amp; André. Pertuzio,(1986) International Petroleum Exploration and Exploitation Agreements: Legal, Economic and Policy Aspects, Borrows Publications, Uptated and Expanded in 2009.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R21">
			<label>21</label>
			<element-citation>Bunter. Michael A. G., (2009)"The Iranian Buy Back Agreements", Oil, Gas &amp; Energy Law, OGEL 1, pp.1-20</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R22">
			<label>22</label>
			<element-citation>  Fight, Andrew (2006) Introduction to Project Finance, Butterworth-Heinemann publication, 1st Edition.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R23">
			<label>23</label>
			<element-citation>Machmud Tengku Nathan,(2000) The Indonesian Production Sharing Contract: An Investor Perspective, Kluwer Law International.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R24">
			<label>24</label>
			<element-citation>M. Sornarajah,(2009) "Portfolio Investment and the Definition of Investment", ICSID REVIEW – Foreign Investment Law Journal, 24(2), pp. 516-520.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R25">
			<label>25</label>
			<element-citation>Robert Fabrikant (1975), "Production Sharing Contracts in the Indonesian Petroleun Industry, Harvard International Law Journal", Vol. 16, pp.42-68.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R26">
			<label>26</label>
			<element-citation>Shiravi Abdolhossein and Amin Majd Fatameh,(2015) "Foreign Investment in Iran’s Upstream oil and Gas Operations: a Legal Perspective", Journal of World Energy Law and BusinessVol. 8, No. 3,pp. 269-287.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R27">
			<label>27</label>
			<element-citation>Shiravi Abdolhossein and Ebrahimi Seyed Nasrollah,(‌2006), "Exploration and Development of Iran’s oilfields through buyback", Natural Resources Forum,30, pp.199-206.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R28">
			<label>28</label>
			<element-citation>Shiravi Abdolhossein &amp; Ebrahimi Seyyed Nasrollah.(2003) "The Contractual Form of Iran’s Buy-back Contracts in Comparison with Production Sharing and Service Contract", Society of Petroleum Engineers, pp.1-17</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R29">
			<label>29</label>
			<element-citation> _||_</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R30">
			<label>30</label>
			<element-citation>Ebrahimi seyed nasrollah, sadeqi moqadam, mohammad Hassan seraj, narges . The Criticisms made by the Iranian Oil and Gas Industry about the interconnected contracts and its responses.  Journal of Faculty of Law and Political Science 2012; 42 (4): 1-19.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R31">
			<label>31</label>
			<element-citation>Asqarian mojtaba. International Oil Service Contracts in the Upstream Sectior and their ability to comply with Iranian law.  Ph.D. Thesis in international law, Shahid Beheshti University 2016.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R32">
			<label>32</label>
			<element-citation>Iranpour farhad. Basic Principles of Oil Contracts. Journal of Faculty of Law and Political Science 2007; 37 (3): 1-28.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R33">
			<label>33</label>
			<element-citation>Emani maqsud, derakhshan masoud. Session "from Darcy to IPC"2015.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R34">
			<label>34</label>
			<element-citation>http://icmstudy.ir/tag</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R35">
			<label>35</label>
			<element-citation>Hatami ali, karimian esmaeel. Foreign Investment Rights in the Light of Law and Investment Contracts.  Tisa Publication 2014 .</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R36">
			<label>36</label>
			<element-citation>Derakhshan mosoud. Oil Contracts from the Perspective of Protective Production and Enhanced Recovery: Resilient Economy approach, Journal of Islamic Studies 2014; 2: 7-52</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R37">
			<label>37</label>
			<element-citation>Qavam abadi ramezani, saraf mohammad hossein, simaii saraf hossein. From Ownership to Sovereignty: Comparative study of the Environment in Islamic law and Jurisprudence</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R38">
			<label>38</label>
			<element-citation>Journal of Civil Rights 2014; 1: 1-12</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R39">
			<label>39</label>
			<element-citation>Zare sheibani davoud. The concept of investing in international investment law. Master's Degree in International Trade Law. Master's Thesis in International Trade Law, shahid beheshti university 2012.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R40">
			<label>40</label>
			<element-citation>Shiravi abodolhossein. Oil and Gas law, mizan publication,tehran 2014.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R41">
			<label>41</label>
			<element-citation>Movahed mohammad ali. Oil Contracts after a twenty-year pause. Journal of Energy Economics 1997; 2,3: 79-87.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R42">
			<label>42</label>
			<element-citation>Mousavi seyed Hassan. Legal analysis of the service model in the upstream sector  in Iranian oil and gas industry (with Emphasizing the analysis of a new contract template: IPC.  Ph.D. Thesis in private  law. Shahid Beheshti University 2016.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R43">
			<label>43</label>
			<element-citation>Nikbakht hamidreza, mohammad arian. Designing new contractual templates for the development of Iran's hydrocarbon fields: Review and critique of the new oil ministry law, Journal of Legal Research 2015; 71: 75-120</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R44">
			<label>44</label>
			<element-citation>Nikhbakht hamidreza, seyed Hassan mousavi. Principles and structure of the new model of Iranian oil contracts. Journal of Legal Research 2015; 72: 35-69</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R45">
			<label>45</label>
			<element-citation>A. Shiroui Khouzani and S.N.Ebrahimi,(2003) The Contractual Form of Iran’s Buy-back Contracts in Comparison with Production Sharing and Service Contract, Society of Petroleum Engineers.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R46">
			<label>46</label>
			<element-citation>Alshiatii(1987), "Protection of Investment in La Haye", p 32 et s .</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R47">
			<label>47</label>
			<element-citation>Atwell, J. E., (1980) "Changing Relationships Between Host Countries and International Petroleum Companies", Houston Law Review, Vol. 17.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R48">
			<label>48</label>
			<element-citation>Bernard Taverne(1996) Petroleum, Upstream Oil and Gaz Agreement, Production sharing contract, Sweet and Maxwell.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R49">
			<label>49</label>
			<element-citation>Bindemann, Kirsten,(1999)"Production Sharing Agreements: An Economic Analysis", Oxford Institute For Energy Studies.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R50">
			<label>50</label>
			<element-citation>Blinn K. W., C. Duval, H. L. Leuch &amp; A. Pertuzio, International Petroleum Exploration and Exploitation Agreements: Legal, Economic and Policy Aspects, Borrows Publications, 1986, Uptated and Expanded in 2009.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R51">
			<label>51</label>
			<element-citation>Bunter. Michael A. G., "The Iranian Buy Back Agreements", P. 11 at www.geoconsuiting.co.uk.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R52">
			<label>52</label>
			<element-citation>Fight Andrew,(2006) Introduction to Project Finance, Butterworth-Heinemann publication.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R53">
			<label>53</label>
			<element-citation>Machmud Tengku Nathan,(2000) The Indonesian Production Sharing Contract: An Investor Perspective, Kluwer Law International.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R54">
			<label>54</label>
			<element-citation>M. Sornarajah,(2009) “Portfolio Investment and the Definition of Investment”, ICSID REVIEW – Foreign Investment Law Journal, 24(2)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R55">
			<label>55</label>
			<element-citation>Robert Fabrikant(1975), Production Sharing Contracts in the Indonesian Petroleun Industry, Harvard International Law Journal, Vol. 16.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R56">
			<label>56</label>
			<element-citation>Shiravi Abdolhossein and Amin Majd Fatameh,(2015) Foreign investment in Iran’s upstream oil and gas operations: a legal perspective, Journal of World Energy Law and BusinessVol. 8, No. 3.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R57">
			<label>57</label>
			<element-citation>Shiravi Abdolhossein and Ebrahimi Seyed Nasrollah,( 2006), Exploration and development of Iran’s oilfields through buyback, Natural Resources Forum,30.</element-citation>
		</ref>
	</ref-list>
		</back>
</article>
<article article-type="Research Paper" dtd-version="3.0" xml:lang="en">
			  <front>
			    <journal-meta>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="pmc"></journal-id>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="publisher-id">دانشگاه شیراز</journal-id>
			    	<journal-title-group>
				      <journal-title>Journal of Legal Studies</journal-title>
			    	</journal-title-group>
			      <issn pub-type="ppub">2008-7926</issn>
			      <publisher>
			        <publisher-name>دانشگاه شیراز</publisher-name>
			      </publisher>
			    </journal-meta>
			    <article-meta>
 			      <article-id pub-id-type="publisher-id">13</article-id>
			      <article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.22099/jls.2018.23911.2243</article-id>		
			      <ext-link xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5027_9ff7b991ecf1243807e5e5c1ba582efb.pdf"/>		
			      <article-categories>
			        <subj-group subj-group-type="heading">
					          		<subject>حقوق جزا و جرمشناسی</subject>
					          		<subject>سیاست جنایی</subject>
			        	</subj-group>
			      </article-categories>
			      <title-group>
			        <article-title>The evaluation of “Criminal Causation” based on Islamic Wisdom</article-title>
			        
			      </title-group>
			      
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c1" corresp="yes">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Javidi</surname>
			            <given-names>Mojtaba</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>Assistant Professor of Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			      <pub-date pub-type="ppub">
			        <day>22</day>
			        <month>11</month>
			        <year>2018</year>
			      </pub-date>
			      <volume>10</volume>
			      <issue>3</issue>
			      <fpage>67</fpage>
			      <lpage>99</lpage>
			      <history>
			        <date date-type="received">
			          <day>26</day>
			          <month>12</month>
			          <year>2016</year>
			        </date>
			        <date date-type="accepted">
			          <day>09</day>
			          <month>09</month>
			          <year>2018</year>
			        </date>
			      </history>
			      <permissions>
			      	<copyright-statement>Copyright &#x000a9; 2018, دانشگاه شیراز. </copyright-statement>	
			        <copyright-year>2018</copyright-year>
			      </permissions>
			       <self-uri xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5027.html">https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5027.html</self-uri> 		
			      <abstract>
			        <p>The principle of causality is one of the most important philosophical principles which is discussed not only in natural objects but also in human behaviors such as, criminal behaviors. However, the analysis of causality in human behaviors is different from its analysis in natural objects. Due to its epistemological basis, the “criminal causation” approach has not had the ability to analyze this principle. This article has investigated and criticized the “criminal causation” based on Islamic jurisprudence. Moreover, this study has referred to and explained the most important weaknesses of this approach in analyzing causality in criminal behavior, namely, the confusion between the concepts of “cause” and “conditions” of genesis, the sufficiency of seeking for cause and neglect of reasoning and meaning, the etiology based on the presupposition and the previous researcher’s mental plan, the thought of determinism in explaining the criminal behavior , the rejection of unnatural causes in committing crimes, the shift from the ultimate cause to the agentive material cause, and the focus on conditions of genesis instead of real and creative causes of genesis.  </p>
			      </abstract>
					<kwd-group kwd-group-type="author">
						<kwd>criminal causation</kwd>
						<kwd>causality</kwd>
						<kwd>positivist criminology</kwd>
						<kwd>criminality</kwd>
						<kwd>Islamic Wisdom</kwd>
						<kwd>philosophy of criminology</kwd>
					</kwd-group>
			    </article-meta>
			  </front>
<back>
	<ref-list>
		<ref id="R1">
			<label>1</label>
			<element-citation>1- قرآن کریم</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R2">
			<label>2</label>
			<element-citation>2- آرتور برت، ادوین(1369)، مبادی مابعدالطبیعه علم نوین، ترجمه عبدالکریم سروش، تهران: انتشارات علمی و فرهنگی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R3">
			<label>3</label>
			<element-citation>3- آرون، ریمون(1370) مراحل اساسی اندیشه در جامعه‌شناسی (متن کامل)، ترجمه باقر پرهام، چاپ دوم، تهران: انتشارات و آموزش انقلاب اسلامی (شرکت سهامی).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R4">
			<label>4</label>
			<element-citation>4- ادیب سلطانی، میرشمس‌الدین(1359)، رساله وین، چاپ اول، تهران: مرکز ایرانی مطالعه فرهنگ‌ها.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R5">
			<label>5</label>
			<element-citation>5- استیس، والتر ترنس(1377)، دین و نگرش نوین، ترجمه احمدرضا جلیلی، ویراستار: مصطفی ملکیان، چاپ اول، تهران: انتشارات حکمت</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R6">
			<label>6</label>
			<element-citation>6- ایمان، محمدتقی (1391)، فلسفه روش تحقیق در علوم انسانی، چاپ اول، قم: پژوهشگاه حوزه و دانشگاه.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R7">
			<label>7</label>
			<element-citation>7- پاپکین، ریچارد و استرول، آوروم (1392) کلیات فلسفه، ترجمه سید جلال الدین مجتبوی، چاپ بیست و نهم، تهران: انتشارات حکمت.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R8">
			<label>8</label>
			<element-citation>8- پیکا، ژرژ (1370) جرم‌شناسی، ترجمه علی حسین نجفی ابرندآبادی، چاپ اول، تهران: انتشارات دانشگاه شهید بهشتی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R9">
			<label>9</label>
			<element-citation>9- چمپیون، دین جان(1385)، روش تحقیق در عدالت کیفری و جرم‌شناسی، ترجمه علی شایان، جلد 1، چاپ اول، تهران: نشر دادگستر</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R10">
			<label>10</label>
			<element-citation>10- حسن‌زاده آملی، حسن (1378) ممدالهمم در شرح فصوص الحکم، چاپ اول، تهران: سازمان انتشارات وزارت ارشاد اسلامی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R11">
			<label>11</label>
			<element-citation>11- داوری اردکانی، رضا (1374) فلسفه چیست؟ چاپ دوم، تهران: پژوهشگاه علوم انسانی و مطالعات فرهنگی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R12">
			<label>12</label>
			<element-citation>12- داوری اردکانی، رضا (1390)، درباره علم، ویراست سوم، چاپ اول، تهران: انتشارات هرمس.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R13">
			<label>13</label>
			<element-citation>13- دِکِسِرِدی، والتر اِس(1394)، جرم‌شناسی انتقادی معاصر، ترجمه و تحقیق از: مهرداد رایجیان اصلی، حمیدرضا دانش ناری، چاپ دوم، تهران: نشر دادگستر.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R14">
			<label>14</label>
			<element-citation>14- دورکیم، امیل(1359)، تقسیم کار اجتماعی، ترجمه حسن حبیبی، چاپ اول، بی‌جا: قلم.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R15">
			<label>15</label>
			<element-citation>15- دورکیم، امیل(1391)، درس‌های جامعه‌شناسی(فیزیک اخلاقیات و حقوق)، ترجمه سید جمال‌الدین موسوی، چاپ اول، تهران: نشر نی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R16">
			<label>16</label>
			<element-citation>16- دورکیم، امیل(1368)، قواعد روش جامعه‌شناسی، ترجمه علی‌محمد کاردان، تهران: انتشارات دانشگاه تهران.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R17">
			<label>17</label>
			<element-citation>17- سلیمی، علی و داوری، محمد(1380)، جامعه‌شناسی کجروی(مجموعه مطالعات کجروی و کنترل اجتماعی، کتاب اول)، چاپ اول، قم: پژوهشکده حوزه و دانشگاه.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R18">
			<label>18</label>
			<element-citation>18- سوزنچی، حسین(1389)، «معنا، امکان و راهکارهای تحقق علم دینی»، چاپ اول، تهران: پژوهشکده مطالعات فرهنگی و اجتماعی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R19">
			<label>19</label>
			<element-citation>19- سیدامامی، کاووس(1391)، پژوهش در علوم سیاسی(رویکردهای اثبات‌گرا، تفسیری و انتقادی)، چاپ دوم (ویرایش جدید)، تهران: انتشارات دانشگاه امام صادق (علیه‌السلام).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R20">
			<label>20</label>
			<element-citation>20- صانعی دره‌بیدی، منوچهر(1384)، مبانی اندیشه‌های فلسفی (فلسفه عمومی)، چاپ اول، تهران: انتشارات امیرکبیر.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R21">
			<label>21</label>
			<element-citation>21- صفاری، علی(1383) «درآمدی بر جرم‌شناسی انتقادی و انواع آن»، علوم جنایی (مجموعه مقالات در تجلیل از استاد دکتر محمد آشوری)، جمعی از نویسندگان، ، چاپ اول، تهران: سازمان مطالعه و تدوین کتب علوم انسانی در دانشگاه ها (سمت).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R22">
			<label>22</label>
			<element-citation>22- طالب‌زاده، سیدحمید(1384)، تحلیلی فلسفی از نسبت ریاضیات و علم جدید، نشریه فلسفه، بهار و تابستان 1384، شماره 10، صص 51-76.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R23">
			<label>23</label>
			<element-citation>23- طباطبایی، جواد، حاج منوچهری، فرامرز و اشرف امامی، علی، در دائره المعارف بزرگ اسلامی (ذیل واژه حکمت)، بی‌تا، تهران: مرکز دائره‌المعارف بزرگ اسلامی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R24">
			<label>24</label>
			<element-citation>24- طباطبایی، سید محمدحسین(1391)، اصول فلسفه و روش رئالیسم، جلد دوم، چاپ بیست و یکم، تهران: انتشارات صدرا.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R25">
			<label>25</label>
			<element-citation>25- --------------------(1391)، اصول فلسفه و روش رئالیسم، جلد سوم، چاپ بیست و یکم، تهران: انتشارات صدرا.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R26">
			<label>26</label>
			<element-citation>26- --------------------(1391)، اصول فلسفه و روش رئالیسم، جلد پنجم، چاپ هفدهم، تهران: انتشارات صدرا.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R27">
			<label>27</label>
			<element-citation>27- --------------------(1386)، ترجمه تفسیر المیزان، 20 جلد، مترجم: سیدمحمدباقر موسوی همدانی، چاپ بیست و چهارم، قم: دفتر انتشارات اسلامی(وابسته به جامعه مدرسین حوزه علمیه قم).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R28">
			<label>28</label>
			<element-citation>28- علم‌الهدی، جمیله(1384)، مبانی تربیت اسلامی و برنامه‌ریزی درسی (بر اساس فلسفه صدرا)، چاپ اول، تهران: انتشارات دانشگاه امام صادق(علیه‌السلام).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R29">
			<label>29</label>
			<element-citation>29- فروغی، محمدعلی(1361)، سیر حکمت در اروپا، جلد سوم(از آغاز سده نوزدهم میلادی تا زمان حاضر)، چاپ سوم، بی‌جا: انتشارات صفی علیشاه.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R30">
			<label>30</label>
			<element-citation>30- فری، انریکو(1389)، جرم‌شناسی اثبات‌گرا، ترجمه میر روح‌الله صدیق، چاپ اول، ایلام: انتشارات رامان.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R31">
			<label>31</label>
			<element-citation>31- کاپلستون، فردریک چارلز(1388)، تاریخ فلسفه(فلسفه اواخر قرون وسطا و دوره رنسانس از اوکام تا سوئارس)، جلد سوم، ترجمه ابراهیم دادجو، چاپ نخست، تهران: انتشارات علمی و فرهنگی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R32">
			<label>32</label>
			<element-citation>32- ---------------------(1388)، تاریخ فلسفه(از هابز تا هیوم)، جلد پنجم، ترجمه امیر جلال‌الدین اعلم، چاپ هفتم، تهران: انتشارات علمی و فرهنگی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R33">
			<label>33</label>
			<element-citation>33- ---------------------(1388)، تاریخ فلسفه(از بنتام تا راسل)، جلد هشتم، ترجمه بهاءالدین خرمشاهی، چاپ ششم، تهران: انتشارات علمی و فرهنگی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R34">
			<label>34</label>
			<element-citation>34- ---------------------(1388)، تاریخ فلسفه(از مِن دوبیران تا سارتر)، جلد نهم، ترجمه عبدالحسین آذرنگ و سید محمود یوسف ثانی، چاپ چهارم، تهران: انتشارات علمی و فرهنگی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R35">
			<label>35</label>
			<element-citation>35-کرو و سمنز (1394) پژوهش جرم‌شناسی، برگردان توسط آزاده واعظی، با دیباچه دکتر عباس شیری، چاپ اول، تهران: نشر میزان.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R36">
			<label>36</label>
			<element-citation>36- کلینی، محمد بن یعقوب بن اسحاق(1407 ق)‏، الکافی، تصحیح توسط غفاری، علی‌اکبر و آخوندی، محمد، چاپ چهارم، تهران: دارالکتب الإسلامیة.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R37">
			<label>37</label>
			<element-citation>37- کیاشمشکی، ابوالفضل(1390) کاربرد نظریه اعتباریات علامه طباطبایی در علوم انسانی، علامه طباطبایی فیلسوف علوم انسانی- اسلامی، به کوشش عبدالحسین خسروپناه، جلد دوم، چاپ اول، تهران: پژوهشگاه فرهنگ و اندیشه اسلامی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R38">
			<label>38</label>
			<element-citation>38- کی‌نیا، مهدی(1369)، مبانی جرم‌شناسی، جلد 1، چاپ دوم، تهران: انتشارات دانشگاه تهران.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R39">
			<label>39</label>
			<element-citation>39- لب‌خندق، محسن(1394) تبیین فرآیند تکوین و تحول فرهنگ با تأکید بر حکمت صدرایی، رساله دکتری در رشته فرهنگ و ارتباطات، دانشکده علوم اجتماعی دانشگاه باقرالعلوم (ع).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R40">
			<label>40</label>
			<element-citation>40- لنکستر، لین و(1383)، خداوندان اندیشه سیاسی، جلد سوم، قسمت اول(هگل، آگوست کنت، جان استوارت میل)، ترجمه علی رامین، چاپ پنجم، تهران: انتشارات امیرکبیر.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R41">
			<label>41</label>
			<element-citation>41- مارشال، گوردون(1388)، فرهنگ جامعه‌شناسی آکسفورد، ترجمه حمیرا مشیرزاده، چاپ اول، تهران: انتشارات میزان.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R42">
			<label>42</label>
			<element-citation>42- مردیها، مرتضی (1395)، «معنا و مبنای تبیین در علوم اجتماعی»، فصلنامه مطالعات میان رشته‌ای در علوم انسانی، دوره هشتم، شماره 4، صص 79-104.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R43">
			<label>43</label>
			<element-citation>43- مگوایر، مایک، مورگان، راد، رینر، رابرت (1393) دانشنامه جرم‌شناسی آکسفورد، جلد دوم، ترجمه دکتر حمیدرضا ملک محمدی، چاپ اول، تهران: نشر میزان.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R44">
			<label>44</label>
			<element-citation>44- مطهری، مرتضی(1391)، مقدمه و پاورقی بر اصول فلسفه و روش رئالیسم، جلد سوم، چاپ بیست و یکم، تهران: انتشارات صدرا.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R45">
			<label>45</label>
			<element-citation>45- ------------(1391)، مقدمه و پاورقی بر اصول فلسفه و روش رئالیسم، جلد پنجم، چاپ هفدهم، تهران: انتشارات صدرا.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R46">
			<label>46</label>
			<element-citation>46- ------------(1377)، انسان و سرنوشت در مجموعه آثار استاد شهید مطهری، ج 1، تهران: انتشارات صدرا.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R47">
			<label>47</label>
			<element-citation>47- نجفی ابرندآبادی، علی حسین (1390)، مقاله «از جرم‌شناسی تا آسیب اجتماعی‌شناسی»، یادنامه شادروان دکتر رضا نوربها، ضمیمه مجله تحقیقات حقوقی، دانشگاه شهید بهشتی، صص 1015-1031.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R48">
			<label>48</label>
			<element-citation>48- نجفی ابرندآبادی، علی‌حسین(1392) مقاله جرم‌شناسی حقوقی (درآمدی بر جرم‌شناسی حقوق کیفری عمومی)، دائره‌المعارف علوم جنایی، کتاب دوم، چاپ نخست، تهران: نشر میزان.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R49">
			<label>49</label>
			<element-citation>49- نجفی ابرندآبادی، علی حسین، هاشم بیکی، حمید(1395)، دانشنامه جرم‌شناسی، چاپ چهارم، ویراست چهارم، تهران: انتشارات گنج دانش.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R50">
			<label>50</label>
			<element-citation>50- نوربها، رضا (1377) زمینه جرم‌شناسی، چاپ اول، تهران: کتابخانه گنج دانش.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R51">
			<label>51</label>
			<element-citation>51- والک لیت، ساندرا (1386)، شناخت جرم‌شناسی، ترجمه حمیدرضا ملک محمدی، چاپ اول، تهران: نشر میزان.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R52">
			<label>52</label>
			<element-citation>52- وایت، راب و هینز، فیونا (1390) جرم و جرم‌شناسی، ترجمه علی سلیمی، چاپ چهارم، قم: پژوهشگاه حوزه و دانشگاه.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R53">
			<label>53</label>
			<element-citation>53- Carrabine, E &amp; Iganski, P &amp; Lee, M &amp; Plummer, k &amp; South, N. (2004) Criminology: A Sociological Introduction. First Edition, Routledge.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R54">
			<label>54</label>
			<element-citation>54- Hill, D, Pond, DA. (1952) ‘Reflections on a Hundred Capital Cases Submitted to Electroencephalography’, Journal of Mental Science, Volume 98, Issue 410. </element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R55">
			<label>55</label>
			<element-citation>55- Humphreys, P. (2003) Mathematical Modeling in the Social Sciences, In S. T. Roth (Ed.), The Blackwell Guide to the Philosophy of the Social Sciences, Malden: Blackwell Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R56">
			<label>56</label>
			<element-citation>56- Loomis, SD, Bohnert, PJ, and Huncke, S.(1967) Predictions of EEG Abnormalities in Adolescent Delinquents, Archives of General Psychiatry.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R57">
			<label>57</label>
			<element-citation>57- Morrison,W. (1995) Theoretical Criminology: from Modernity to Post-Modernism, First Edition, London, Sydney: Cavendish Publishing Limited.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R58">
			<label>58</label>
			<element-citation>58- Moyer, KE. (1976) The Psychobiology of Aggression, New York: Harper &amp; Row.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R59">
			<label>59</label>
			<element-citation>59- Nye, Robert A. (1976)  Heredity or Milieu: The Foundations of Modern European Criminological Theory, The University of Chicago Press, Isis, Vol. 67, No. 3 (Sep 1976), pp. 334-355.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R60">
			<label>60</label>
			<element-citation>60- Wright, Richard A, Miller J.Mitchell. (2005) Encyclopedia of Criminology, Routledge, New York &amp; London, Vol. 1.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R61">
			<label>61</label>
			<element-citation>61-Vold, George B, Bernard, Thomas J, Snipes, Jeffrey B. (1998) Theoretical Criminology, Fourth Edition, New York: Oxford University Press.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R62">
			<label>62</label>
			<element-citation> _||_</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R63">
			<label>63</label>
			<element-citation>References</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R64">
			<label>64</label>
			<element-citation>1. Holy Quran</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R65">
			<label>65</label>
			<element-citation>2. Arthur Bert Edwin (1990) Metaphysics of Modern Sciences, translated by Soroush Abd al-karim, Scientific and Cultural Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R66">
			<label>66</label>
			<element-citation>3. Aron Reymond (1991) Basic Stage of Thinking in a Sociology, translated by Parham Baqir, 2th Edition, Education of Islamic Revolution publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R67">
			<label>67</label>
			<element-citation>4- Adib Soltani Mir Shams al-din, (1980), Treatise of Vienna, 1th Edition, Iranian Center of Studying Cultures (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R68">
			<label>68</label>
			<element-citation>5-Stais Walter Trans (1998), Religion and Modern attitude, translated by Jalili Ahmad Reza, 1th Edition, Hekmat Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R69">
			<label>69</label>
			<element-citation>6- Iman Mohammad Taghi (2012) Philosophy of Human Research Methods, 1th Edition, Department of Religious Center and University (in persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R70">
			<label>70</label>
			<element-citation>7- Papkin Richard and Arom Sterol (2013) General of Philosophy, translated by Mojtabavi, Seyyed jalal al-din, 29th Edition, Hekmat Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R71">
			<label>71</label>
			<element-citation>8- Pica Georges, (1991) Criminology, translated by Najafi Abrandabadi, Ali Hossein, 1th Edition, University of Shahid Beheshti publishing  (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R72">
			<label>72</label>
			<element-citation>9- Champioon Din Jan, (2006), Research Methodology of Criminal Justice and Criminology, translated by Shayan Ali, Vol. 1, 1th Edition, Dadghostar Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R73">
			<label>73</label>
			<element-citation>10- Hassanzade Amoli Hassan (1999) “Momahhed al-hemmam in explaining of Fossous al-hekam”, 1th Edition, Ministry of Islamic Guidance publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R74">
			<label>74</label>
			<element-citation>11- Davari Ardakani Reza (1995), What is Philosophy? 2th Edition, Department of Humanities and Cultural Studies (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R75">
			<label>75</label>
			<element-citation>12- Davari Ardakani Reza (2011) About Science, 1th Edition, Hermes Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R76">
			<label>76</label>
			<element-citation>13- Dekeseredy, Walter S (2015) Contemporary Critical Criminology, translated by Rayejian Asli Mehrdad and Daneshnari Hamid Reza, 2th Edition, Dadghostar Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R77">
			<label>77</label>
			<element-citation>14- Durkheim Emil (1980) Division of Social Work, translated by Habibi Hassan, Ghalam Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R78">
			<label>78</label>
			<element-citation>15- Durkheim Emil (2012) Sociology Lessons (The Physics of Morals and Law), translated by Mousavi Seyyed Jalal al-din, Ney Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R79">
			<label>79</label>
			<element-citation>16- Durkheim Emil (1989) The Rules of Sociological Method, translated by Kardan Mohammad Ali, University of Tehran Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R80">
			<label>80</label>
			<element-citation>17- Salimi Ali and Davari Mohammad (2001) Sociology of Criminality, 1th Edition, Department of Religious Center and University (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R81">
			<label>81</label>
			<element-citation>18- Souzanchi, Hossein (2010) Religious Science: Meaning, Possibility and Solutions, 1th Edition, Department of Cultural and Sociologic Studies (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R82">
			<label>82</label>
			<element-citation>19- Seyyed Emami Kavous, (2012) Research in Political Sciences (Positivist, Interpretative and Critical approachs), 2th Edition, Imam Sadiq University Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R83">
			<label>83</label>
			<element-citation>20- Sanei Darrebidi Manouchehr (2005) Basics of Philosophical Thoughts, 1th Edition, Amir Kabir Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R84">
			<label>84</label>
			<element-citation>21- Saffari Ali (2004)” Introduction to Criminology and Its Types”, Criminal Sciences, A group of writers, 1th Edition, Samt Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R85">
			<label>85</label>
			<element-citation>22-Talebzade Seyyed Hamid (2005)”A Philosophical Analysis of the Relation of Mathematics and Modern science”, Journal of Philosophy, spring &amp; summer 2005, No. 10, pp. 51-76 (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R86">
			<label>86</label>
			<element-citation>23. Tabatabaei Javad, Haj Manouchehri Faramarz, Ashraf Emami Ali, The Great Islamic Encyclopedia (the word of “Hekmat”,) The Center of Great Islamic Encyclopedia (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R87">
			<label>87</label>
			<element-citation>24- Tabatabaei Seyyed Mohammad Hossein  (2012) Principles Of Philosophy and Method of Realism, Vol 2, 21th Edition, Sadra Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R88">
			<label>88</label>
			<element-citation>25- Tabatabaei Seyyed Mohammad Hossein (2012) Principles Of Philosophy and Method of Realism, Vol 3, 21th Edition, Sadra Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R89">
			<label>89</label>
			<element-citation>26- Tabatabaei Seyyed Mohammad Hossein  (2012) Principles Of Philosophy and Method of Realism, Vol 5, 17th Edition, Sadra Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R90">
			<label>90</label>
			<element-citation>27- Tabatabaei Seyyed Mohammad Hossein (2007), Translation of Al-Mizans's Interpretation, translated by Mousavi Hamedani Seyyed Mohammad Baqir, 24th Edition, The Center of Islamic Publication (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R91">
			<label>91</label>
			<element-citation>28- Alam al-hoda Jamileh (2005) The Basics of Islamic Education and Planning Lessons, 1th Edition, Imam Sadiq University Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R92">
			<label>92</label>
			<element-citation>29- Foroughi Mohammad Ali (1982) The Evolution of Philosophy in Europe, Vol. 3, 3th Edition, Safi Ali Shah publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R93">
			<label>93</label>
			<element-citation>30- Ferri Enrico (2010) Positivist Criminology, translated by Seddiq Rooho-Allah, 1th Edition, Raman Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R94">
			<label>94</label>
			<element-citation>31- Copleston Fredrick Charles (2009) A History of Philosophy, Vol.3, translated by Dadjoo Ebrahim, 1th Edition, Scientific and Cultural publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R95">
			<label>95</label>
			<element-citation>32- Copleston Fredrick Charles (2009) A History of Philosophy, Vol.5, translated by Alam Amir Jalal al-din, 7th Edition, Scientific and Cultural publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R96">
			<label>96</label>
			<element-citation>33- Copleston Fredrick Charles (2009) A History of Philosophy, Vol.8, translated by Khorramshahi Baha al-din, 6th Edition, Scientific and Cultural publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R97">
			<label>97</label>
			<element-citation>34- Copleston Fredrick Charles (2009) A History of Philosophy, Vol.9, translated by Azarang Abd al-Hossein and Yousof Sani Seyyed Mahmood, 4th Edition, Scientific and Cultural publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R98">
			<label>98</label>
			<element-citation>35- Crow lain and Semmens Natasha (2015) Researching Criminology, translated by Vaezi A. 1th Edition, Mizan Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R99">
			<label>99</label>
			<element-citation>36- Koleini Mohammad- ebn Jacob (1986) Al-kafi, 1th Edition, The Center of Islamic Books</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R100">
			<label>100</label>
			<element-citation>37- Kiashemshaki Abolfazl (2011)”Application of “Etebariat” theory in the Islamic Human Sciences”, Allame Tabatabaei: The Philosopher of Islamic Human Sciences, 1th Edition, Research Center for Islamic Culture and thought (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R101">
			<label>101</label>
			<element-citation>38- Keynia Mahdi (1990) The Basics of Criminology, Vol. 1, 2th Edition, University of Tehran Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R102">
			<label>102</label>
			<element-citation>39- Labkhandagh Mohsen (2015), Explaining the Process of Emergence and Transformation of Cultures, with Emphasis on Sadra's Wisdom, Ph.D. in culture and communication, University of Baqir Al-uloum (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R103">
			<label>103</label>
			<element-citation>40- Lanckester L.V (2004) The Lords of Political Thought, Vol. 3, (Hegel, Auguste Comte, John Stuart Mill), translated by Ramin Ali, 5th Edition, Amir Kabir Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R104">
			<label>104</label>
			<element-citation>41- Marshal Gourdon (2009) The Oxford Dictionary of Philosophy, translated by Moshirzade Homeira, 1th Edition, Mizan Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R105">
			<label>105</label>
			<element-citation>42- Mardiha Morteza (2016) The Meaning and Basis of Explanation in the Social Sciences, The Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies in the Humanities, Vol. 8, No. 4, pp. 79-104.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R106">
			<label>106</label>
			<element-citation>43- Maguaier Mike, Mourgan Rad, Reaner Robert  (2014) The Oxford Dictionary of Criminology, Vol. 2, translated by Malek Mohammadi Hamid Reza, 1th Edition, Mizan Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R107">
			<label>107</label>
			<element-citation>44- Motahhari Morteza  (2012) Introduction to the Principles Of Philosophy and Method of Realism, Vol 3, 21th Edition, Sadra Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R108">
			<label>108</label>
			<element-citation>45- Motahhari Morteza  (2012) Introduction to the Principles Of Philosophy and Method of Realism, Vol 5,17th Edition, Sadra Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R109">
			<label>109</label>
			<element-citation>46- Motahhari Morteza (1998) The Human and Destiny, The Collection of the Motahhari books, Vol 1, Sadra Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R110">
			<label>110</label>
			<element-citation>47- Najafi Abrand Abadi Ali Hossein (2011) From Criminology to Social Pathology, attached to The Journal of Legal Research, University of Shahid Beheshti, pp.115-131 (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R111">
			<label>111</label>
			<element-citation>48- Najafi Abrand Abadi Ali Hossein, Legal Criminology, Encyclopedia of Criminal Sciences, Vol.2. 1th Edition, Mizan Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R112">
			<label>112</label>
			<element-citation>49- Najafi Abrand Abadi Ali Hossein, Hashem Beighi Hamid (2016) The Encyclopedia of Criminology, 4th Edition, Ghange Danesh Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R113">
			<label>113</label>
			<element-citation>50- Nourbaha Reza (1998) The Introduction to Criminology, 1th Edition, Ghange Danesh Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R114">
			<label>114</label>
			<element-citation>51- Walk Lit Sandra (2007) The Cognition of Criminology, translated by Malek Mohammadi Hamidreza, 1th Edition, Mizan Publishing (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R115">
			<label>115</label>
			<element-citation>52- White Robert and Haines Fiona (2011) The Crime and Criminology. translated by Salimi Ali, 4th Edition, Department of Religious Center and University (in persian).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R116">
			<label>116</label>
			<element-citation>53- Carrabine, E &amp; Iganski, P &amp; Lee, M &amp; plummer, k &amp; South, N (2004) criminology: a sociological introduction, first edition, Routledge.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R117">
			<label>117</label>
			<element-citation>54- Hill, D , Pond, DA (1952) ‘Reflections on a hundred capital cases submitted to electroencephalography’, Journal of Mental Science</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R118">
			<label>118</label>
			<element-citation>55- Humphreys, P (2003) Mathematical Modeling in the Social Sciences, In S. T. Roth (Ed.), The Blackwell guide to the philosophy of the social sciences, Malden: Blackwell Publishing</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R119">
			<label>119</label>
			<element-citation>56- Loomis, SD, Bohnert, PJ, and Huncke, S (1967) ‘Predictions of EEG abnormalities in adolescent delinquents’, Archives of General Psychiatry</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R120">
			<label>120</label>
			<element-citation>57-Morrison, W (1995) Theoretical Criminology: from modernity to post-modernism, first edition, London, Sydney: Cavendish Publishing Limited</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R121">
			<label>121</label>
			<element-citation>58- Moyer, KE (1976) The Psychobiology of Aggression, New York: Harper &amp; Row</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R122">
			<label>122</label>
			<element-citation>59- Nye, Robert  A (1976)  Heredity or Milieu: The Foundations of Modern European Criminological Theory, The University of Chicago Press, Isis, Vol. 67, No. 3 (Sep 1976), pp. 334-355</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R123">
			<label>123</label>
			<element-citation>60- Wright, Richard A, Miller J.Mitchell (2005) Encyclopedia of Criminology, Routledge, New York &amp; London, vol. 1</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R124">
			<label>124</label>
			<element-citation>61-Vold, George B, Bernard, Thomas J, Snipes, Jeffrey B. (1998) Theoretical Criminology, Fourth Edition, New York: Oxford University Press</element-citation>
		</ref>
	</ref-list>
		</back>
</article>
<article article-type="Research Paper" dtd-version="3.0" xml:lang="en">
			  <front>
			    <journal-meta>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="pmc"></journal-id>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="publisher-id">دانشگاه شیراز</journal-id>
			    	<journal-title-group>
				      <journal-title>Journal of Legal Studies</journal-title>
			    	</journal-title-group>
			      <issn pub-type="ppub">2008-7926</issn>
			      <publisher>
			        <publisher-name>دانشگاه شیراز</publisher-name>
			      </publisher>
			    </journal-meta>
			    <article-meta>
 			      <article-id pub-id-type="publisher-id">13</article-id>
			      <article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.22099/jls.2018.26820.2585</article-id>		
			      <ext-link xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5028_cdf168d5008a6ffd8985ef5ceeb592bb.pdf"/>		
			      <article-categories>
			        <subj-group subj-group-type="heading">
					          		<subject>بین الملل کیفری</subject>
			        	</subj-group>
			      </article-categories>
			      <title-group>
			        <article-title>Examining theExclusionary Rule of Evidence in International Criminal Tribunals for Former Yugoslavia and Rwanda</article-title>
			        <subtitle>Exclusionary rule of Evidence</subtitle>
			      </title-group>
			      
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c1">
			          <name>
			            <surname>daryabeygy</surname>
			            <given-names>simindokht</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>MA. in Criminal Law and criminology, Humanity Faculty, University of Guilan, Rasht, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c2" corresp="yes">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Janipour</surname>
			            <given-names>Mojtaba</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>Asociate Professor  of Criminal Law and Criminology, University of Guilan, Rasht, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c3">
			          <name>
			            <surname>sobhani</surname>
			            <given-names>Mahin</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>Assistant Professor of international Law, University of Guilan, Rasht, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			      <pub-date pub-type="ppub">
			        <day>22</day>
			        <month>11</month>
			        <year>2018</year>
			      </pub-date>
			      <volume>10</volume>
			      <issue>3</issue>
			      <fpage>100</fpage>
			      <lpage>130</lpage>
			      <history>
			        <date date-type="received">
			          <day>25</day>
			          <month>09</month>
			          <year>2017</year>
			        </date>
			        <date date-type="accepted">
			          <day>09</day>
			          <month>09</month>
			          <year>2018</year>
			        </date>
			      </history>
			      <permissions>
			      	<copyright-statement>Copyright &#x000a9; 2018, دانشگاه شیراز. </copyright-statement>	
			        <copyright-year>2018</copyright-year>
			      </permissions>
			       <self-uri xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5028.html">https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5028.html</self-uri> 		
			      <abstract>
			        <p>The importance of maintaining the fairness of proceedings and protecting the rights of the accused have led various criminal justice systems to provide for special rules to the effect of ensuring fair trial . The exclusionary rule of evidence is one of the most important  safeguards-provisions of these regulations, which makes it impossible to cite evidence obtained in an unauthorized manner in the court. Despite the fact that the International Criminal Tribunal for Yugoslavia and Rwanda, bear the task of prosecution of the perpetrators of the most serious international crimes, they have not  overlooked the rights of the accused. According to Art 95 of rules of procedure and evidence of ICTR and ICTY, the exclusion of evidence obtained through unauthorized methods does not necessarily lead to exclusion of evidence, except when the methods used to obtain evidence cast substantial doubt on reliability of evidence or damage the integrity of the proceedings. The conditions set forth in this article, which their authenication have been granted to the discretion of judges, gives the rule an optional nature and restricts its scope to some extent. This solution is the result of international criminal tribunals&#039; efforts in striking a balance between the rights of the accused and victim which with all its ambiguity in drawing the scope of the rule has been adopted by the ICC.  </p>
			      </abstract>
					<kwd-group kwd-group-type="author">
						<kwd>Exclusionary Rule of Evidence</kwd>
						<kwd>Criminal proceedings</kwd>
						<kwd>Confession</kwd>
						<kwd>Torture</kwd>
						<kwd>Search</kwd>
					</kwd-group>
			    </article-meta>
			  </front>
<back>
	<ref-list>
		<ref id="R1">
			<label>1</label>
			<element-citation>الف. فارسی</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R2">
			<label>2</label>
			<element-citation>تدین، عباس، (1387)، «نظریه­ی بطلان دلیل در فرایند دادرسی کیفری (با تأکید بر حقوق فرانسه»، تحقیقات حقوقی آزاد، دوره 2، شماره 3، 94-76</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R3">
			<label>3</label>
			<element-citation>زراعت، عباس، (1390)، بطلان در آیین دادرسی کیفری، تهران، نشر میزان</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R4">
			<label>4</label>
			<element-citation>صبوری پور، مهدی، (1394)، «قاعده­ی رد ادله در حقوق ایالات متحده و مقایسه­ی آن با ضمانت اجراهای مشابه در حقوق ایران»، آموزه­های حقوق کیفری، دانشگاه علوم اسلامی رضوی، شماره 9، 129-154</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R5">
			<label>5</label>
			<element-citation>فرجیها، محمد و محمدباقر مقدسی، (1387)، «رویکرد تطبیقی به قاعده­ی معتبر ناشناختن ادله در نظام عدالت کیفری کامن­لا و ایران»، فصلنامه­ی مدرس علوم انسانی، دوره 12، شماره 3، 113-144</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R6">
			<label>6</label>
			<element-citation>مؤذن زادگان، حسنعلی و سهیل مقدم، سحر (1395)، «قاعده­ی بطلان دلیل در دادرسی کیفری (با تأکید بر حقوق آمریکا)»، مطالعات حقوق کیفری و جرم شناسی دانشگاه تهران، دوره 3، شماره 2، 51-81</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R7">
			<label>7</label>
			<element-citation>ب. انگلیسی</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R8">
			<label>8</label>
			<element-citation>Alamuddin, Amal, (2010), “Collection of Evidence”, In Khan K, Buisman C, Gosnell C (eds.) “Principles of Evidence in International Criminal Justice”. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 231–305</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R9">
			<label>9</label>
			<element-citation>Ambos, Kai, (2003), “International Criminal Procedure: Adversarial, Inquisitorial or mixed?”, International Criminal Law Review, Vol. 3, pp. 1-37</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R10">
			<label>10</label>
			<element-citation>Beller, Brian, (2003), “A Comparative Study of Exclusion of Evidence on the Grounds of the Means by which it was Obtained”, Case Western Reserve University Scholl of Law International War Crimes Project, Iss. 14</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R11">
			<label>11</label>
			<element-citation>Boas, Gideon, et al, (2011), “International Criminal Procedure”, New York, Cambridge University Press.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R12">
			<label>12</label>
			<element-citation>Brooke, David Anthony, (1999), “Confessions, Illegally-Improperly Obtained Evidence and Entrapment under The Police and Criminal Evidence act 1984: Changing Judicial and Public Attitudes to The Police and Criminal Investigations”, PHD. Thesis, University of London</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R13">
			<label>13</label>
			<element-citation>Charter of the International Military Tribunal, 1945.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R14">
			<label>14</label>
			<element-citation>Choo, Andrew and Susan Nash, (2007), “Improperly Obtained Evidence in the Commonwealth”, The International Journal of Evidence and Proof, Vol. 11, pp. 75-105</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R15">
			<label>15</label>
			<element-citation>Choo, Andrew, (2013), “England and Wales: Fair Trial Analysis and the Presumed Admissibility of Physical Evidence”, In Thaman, C. Stephen, “Exclusionary Rules in Comparative Law”, iusgentium, Comparative Perspectives on Law and Justice, Vol. 20, pp. 331-354</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R16">
			<label>16</label>
			<element-citation>Cryer, Robert, et al, (2010), “An Introduction to International Criminal Law and Procedure”, Second edition, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R17">
			<label>17</label>
			<element-citation>Einarsdottir, KatrinOlof, (2010), “Comparing the Rules of Evidence Applicable Before the ICTY, ICTR and the ICC”, Meistararitgerðtil Mag. Jur. prófs í lögfræði</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R18">
			<label>18</label>
			<element-citation>Hsieh, Kuo-Hsing, (2014), “The Exclusionary Rule of Evidence: A Comparative Analysis and Proposals for Reform”, AshgatePublishing, International and Comparative Criminal Justice Series, England, available at www.ashgate.com</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R19">
			<label>19</label>
			<element-citation>International Military Tribunal for the Far East, 1946</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R20">
			<label>20</label>
			<element-citation>Keane, Adrian, McKeown, Paul, (2011), “The modern law of evidence”, 9th edition, Oxford University press, London</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R21">
			<label>21</label>
			<element-citation>Madden, Micael, (2014), “The Exclusion of Improperly Obtained Evidence at the International Criminal Court”, Master of Law Thesis, Dalhousie University, Nova Scotia, Canada</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R22">
			<label>22</label>
			<element-citation>Mellifont, Kerri Anne, (2007), “Australian Exclusionary Rule”, DSc. Thesis on Juridical Science, Queensland University of Technology</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R23">
			<label>23</label>
			<element-citation>Rajamae, Heidi, (2011), “Legality of a Contractual Waiver of Human Rights in the European context”, Master Thesis in International Human Right Law, Lund University, Lund, Sweden</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R24">
			<label>24</label>
			<element-citation>Roach, Kent, (1999), “Four Models of Criminal Process”, Journal of Criminal Law and criminology, Vol. 89, Iss. 2, pp. 671-716</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R25">
			<label>25</label>
			<element-citation>Schabas, William A., (1997). “Sentencing by International Tribunals: A Human Rights Approach”, Duke Journal of Comparative and International Law, Vol. 7, pp. 461-517</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R26">
			<label>26</label>
			<element-citation>Sharma, S.N, (2016), “Toward Crime Control Model”, Journal of Indian Law Institute, Vol. 49, pp. 543-550</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R27">
			<label>27</label>
			<element-citation>Slobogin, Christopher. (2013), “A Comparative Perspective on the Exclusionary Rule in Search and Seizure Cases”, Vanderbilt Public Law Research Paper, No. 13-21</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R28">
			<label>28</label>
			<element-citation>Thaman, C. Stephen, (2013), “Balancing Truth Against Human Rights: A Theory of Modern Exclusionary Rules”, In Thaman C. Stephen, “Exclusionary Rules in Comparative Law”, iusgentium, Comparative Perspectives on Law and Justice, Vol. 20, pp. 403-444</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R29">
			<label>29</label>
			<element-citation>The Royal Commission on Criminal Justice, Report, Cm 2263, (1993), London: HMSO</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R30">
			<label>30</label>
			<element-citation>Tyler, R. Tom, (1990), “Why People Obey the Law”, Yale University press, New Haven and London</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R31">
			<label>31</label>
			<element-citation>Viebig, Petra, (2016), “Illicitly Obtained Evidence at the International Criminal Court”, Asser Publishing, International Criminal Justice Series, Vol. 4, available at www.springer.com</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R32">
			<label>32</label>
			<element-citation>      </element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R33">
			<label>33</label>
			<element-citation>Map v. Ohio, Case No. 367, U.S. 643, 19 June 1961</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R34">
			<label>34</label>
			<element-citation>Olmstead v. United States, Case No. 277 U.S. 438, 485, 4 June 1928</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R35">
			<label>35</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. AugustinNdindiliyimana et al, Case No. ICTR-00-56-T, 22 September 2008</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R36">
			<label>36</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. Dario Kordic´ and Mario Čerkez, Case No. IT-95-14-2-T, 25 June 1999</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R37">
			<label>37</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. DraganNikolić, Case No. IT-94-2-PT, 9 October 2002</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R38">
			<label>38</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. EdouardKarmera et al, Case No. ICTR-98-44-T, 2 November 2007</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R39">
			<label>39</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. Germain Katanga and Mathieu Ngudjolo Chui, Case No, ICC-01/04-01/07-2635 -PT, 17 December 2010</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R40">
			<label>40</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. Jean-BoscoBarayagwiza, Case No. ICTR-97-19-A, 3 November 1999</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R41">
			<label>41</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. Lubanga, Case No. ICC-01/04-01/06-1981-T, 24 June 2009</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R42">
			<label>42</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. MicoStanisic and Zupljanin, Case No. ICTR-08-91-T, 16 December 2009</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R43">
			<label>43</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. Milan Martic, Case No IT-95-11-T, 19 January 2006</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R44">
			<label>44</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. RadoslavBrdjanin, Case No. IT-99-36-T, 1 September 2004.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R45">
			<label>45</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. RadoslavBrdjanin, Case No. IT-99-36-T, 3 October 2003</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R46">
			<label>46</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. Radovan Karadzic, Case No. IT-95-5/18-T, 30 September 2010</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R47">
			<label>47</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. ZdravkoMucic, Case No. IT-96-21-PT, 9 February 1998</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R48">
			<label>48</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. ZejnilDelalic et al, Case No, IT-96-21-T, 2 September 1997</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R49">
			<label>49</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. ZejnilDelalic et al, Case No. IT-96-21-A, 20 February 2001</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R50">
			<label>50</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. ZejnilDelalic et al, Case No. IT-96-21-T, 2 September 1999</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R51">
			<label>51</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. ZejnilDelalic et al, Case No. IT-96-21-T, 25 September 1997</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R52">
			<label>52</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. ZejnilDelalic et al, Case No. IT-96-21-T, 8 September 1997</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R53">
			<label>53</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v.ZoranKupreškic´ et al, Case No. IT-95-16-T, 14 January 2000</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R54">
			<label>54</label>
			<element-citation>R v. Grant, Case No. 2 S.C.R. 353, 17 July 2009</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R55">
			<label>55</label>
			<element-citation>Scoppola v. Italy, Case No. ECtHR. (no. 2) [GC], no. 10249/03, 17 September 2009</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R56">
			<label>56</label>
			<element-citation>Weeks v. United States, Case No. 232, U.S. 383, 24 February 1914</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R57">
			<label>57</label>
			<element-citation> _||_</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R58">
			<label>58</label>
			<element-citation>Tadayyon, Abbas, (2008) “Theory of Exclusionary Rule in Criminal Procedure (By Emphasis on France Law)”  Azad Legal Researches, Vol. 2, No. 3, pp. 76-94.(In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R59">
			<label>59</label>
			<element-citation>Zeraat, Abbas, (2012) Nullity in Criminal Procedure, Mizan Legal Foundation, Tehran.(In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R60">
			<label>60</label>
			<element-citation>Sabouripour, Mahdi (2015)“The Exclusionary Rule (The Principle of Rejecting Evidences) in Law of the United States and Comparing with the Similar Sanctions in the Law of Iran”, Criminal Law Doctrines,Vol. 9, Spring &amp; Summer, pp. 129-154.(In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R61">
			<label>61</label>
			<element-citation>Farajiha, Mohammad &amp;  Moghadasi, Mohammad Bagher (2008) “Comparative Approach to the Exclusionary Rule in the Common Law and Iran’s Criminal Justice System”, Comparative Law Researches, Vol. 12, N0. 3, Tom 58, autumn, pp. 113-144. (In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R62">
			<label>62</label>
			<element-citation>Moazenzadegan, Hassan Ali &amp; Soheilmoghadam, Sahar (2016-2017) “Exclusionary Rule on Criminal Procedure (By Emphasis on American Law)”, Criminal Law and Criminology Studies, Vol. 3, No 2, Autumn &amp; Winter, pp. 243-267.(In Persian)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R63">
			<label>63</label>
			<element-citation>Alamuddin, Amal, (2010), “Collection of Evidence”, In Khan K, Buisman C, Gosnell C (eds.) Principles of Evidence in International Criminal Justice. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 231–305</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R64">
			<label>64</label>
			<element-citation>Ambos, Kai, (2003), “International Criminal      Procedure: Adversarial, Inquisitorial or mixed?”, International Criminal      Law Review, Vol. 3, pp. 1-37</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R65">
			<label>65</label>
			<element-citation>Beller, Brian, (2003), “A Comparative Study of      Exclusion of Evidence on the Grounds of the Means by which it was      Obtained”, Case Western Reserve University Scholl of Law International War      Crimes Project, Iss. 14</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R66">
			<label>66</label>
			<element-citation>Boas, Gideon, et al, (2011), “International Criminal      Procedure”, New York, Cambridge University Press.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R67">
			<label>67</label>
			<element-citation>Brooke, David Anthony, (1999), “Confessions,      Illegally-Improperly Obtained Evidence and Entrapment under The Police and      Criminal Evidence act 1984: Changing Judicial and Public Attitudes to The      Police and Criminal Investigations”, PHD. Thesis, University of London</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R68">
			<label>68</label>
			<element-citation>Charter of the International Military Tribunal,      1945.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R69">
			<label>69</label>
			<element-citation>Choo, Andrew and Susan Nash, (2007), “Improperly      Obtained Evidence in the Commonwealth”, The International Journal of      Evidence and Proof, Vol. 11, pp. 75-105</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R70">
			<label>70</label>
			<element-citation>Choo, Andrew, (2013), “England and Wales: Fair Trial      Analysis and the Presumed Admissibility of Physical Evidence”, In Thaman,      C. Stephen, “Exclusionary Rules in Comparative Law”, iusgentium,      Comparative Perspectives on Law and Justice, Vol. 20, pp. 331-354</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R71">
			<label>71</label>
			<element-citation>Cryer, Robert, et al, (2010), “An Introduction to      International Criminal Law and Procedure”, Second edition, Cambridge,      Cambridge University Press</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R72">
			<label>72</label>
			<element-citation>Einarsdottir, KatrinOlof, (2010), “Comparing the      Rules of Evidence Applicable Before the ICTY, ICTR and the ICC”,      Meistararitgerðtil Mag. Jur. prófs í lögfræði</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R73">
			<label>73</label>
			<element-citation>Hsieh, Kuo-Hsing, (2014), “The Exclusionary Rule of      Evidence: A Comparative Analysis and Proposals for Reform”,      AshgatePublishing, International and Comparative Criminal Justice Series,      England, available at www.ashgate.com</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R74">
			<label>74</label>
			<element-citation>International Military Tribunal for the Far East,      1946</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R75">
			<label>75</label>
			<element-citation>Keane, Adrian, McKeown, Paul, (2011), “The modern      law of evidence”, 9th edition, Oxford University press, London</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R76">
			<label>76</label>
			<element-citation>Madden, Micael, (2014), “The Exclusion of Improperly      Obtained Evidence at the International Criminal Court”, Master of Law      Thesis, Dalhousie University, Nova Scotia, Canada</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R77">
			<label>77</label>
			<element-citation>Mellifont, Kerri Anne, (2007), “Australian Exclusionary      Rule”, DSc. Thesis on Juridical Science, Queensland University of      Technology</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R78">
			<label>78</label>
			<element-citation>Rajamae, Heidi, (2011), “Legality of a Contractual      Waiver of Human Rights in the European context”, Master Thesis in      International Human Right Law, Lund University, Lund, Sweden</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R79">
			<label>79</label>
			<element-citation>Roach, Kent, (1999), “Four Models of Criminal      Process”, Journal of Criminal Law and criminology, Vol. 89, Iss. 2, pp.      671-716</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R80">
			<label>80</label>
			<element-citation>Schabas, William A., (1997). “Sentencing by      International Tribunals: A Human Rights Approach”, Duke Journal of Comparative      and International Law, Vol. 7, pp. 461-517</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R81">
			<label>81</label>
			<element-citation>Sharma, S.N, (2016), “Toward Crime Control Model”,      Journal of Indian Law Institute, Vol. 49, pp. 543-550</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R82">
			<label>82</label>
			<element-citation>Slobogin, Christopher. (2013), “A Comparative      Perspective on the Exclusionary Rule in Search and Seizure Cases”,      Vanderbilt Public Law Research Paper, No. 13-21</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R83">
			<label>83</label>
			<element-citation>Thaman, C. Stephen, (2013), “Balancing Truth Against      Human Rights: A Theory of Modern Exclusionary Rules”, In Thaman C.      Stephen, “Exclusionary Rules in Comparative Law”,iusgentium, Comparative      Perspectives on Law and Justice, Vol. 20, pp. 403-444</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R84">
			<label>84</label>
			<element-citation>The Royal Commission on Criminal Justice, Report, Cm      2263, (1993), London: HMSO</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R85">
			<label>85</label>
			<element-citation>Tyler, R. Tom, (1990), “Why People Obey the Law”,      Yale University press, New Haven and London</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R86">
			<label>86</label>
			<element-citation>Viebig, Petra, (2016), “Illicitly Obtained Evidence      at the International Criminal Court”, Asser Publishing, International      Criminal Justice Series, Vol. 4, available at www.springer.com</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R87">
			<label>87</label>
			<element-citation>Map v. Ohio, Case No. 367, U.S. 643, 19 June 1961</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R88">
			<label>88</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. Germain Katanga and Mathieu Ngudjolo Chui, Case No, ICC-01/04-01/07-2635 -PT, 17 December 2010</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R89">
			<label>89</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. Lubanga, Case No. ICC-01/04-01/06-1981-T, 24 June 2009</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R90">
			<label>90</label>
			<element-citation>R v. Grant, Case No. 2 S.C.R. 353, 17 July 2009</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R91">
			<label>91</label>
			<element-citation>Weeks v. United States, Case No. 232, U.S. 383, 24 February 1914</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R92">
			<label>92</label>
			<element-citation>Olmstead v. United States, Case No. 277 U.S. 438,      485, 4 June 1928</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R93">
			<label>93</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. Augustin Ndindiliyimana et al, Case      No. ICTR-00-56-T, 22 September 2008</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R94">
			<label>94</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. Dario Kordic´ and Mario Čerkez, Case      No. IT-95-14-2-T, 25 June 1999</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R95">
			<label>95</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. DraganNikolić, Case No. IT-94-2-PT, 9      October 2002</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R96">
			<label>96</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. EdouardKarmera et al, Case No.      ICTR-98-44-T, 2 November 2007</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R97">
			<label>97</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. Jean-BoscoBarayagwiza, Case No.      ICTR-97-19-A, 3 November 1999</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R98">
			<label>98</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. MicoStanisic and Zupljanin, Case No.      ICTR-08-91-T, 16 December 2009</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R99">
			<label>99</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. Milan Martic, Case No IT-95-11-T, 19      January 2006</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R100">
			<label>100</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor      v. RadoslavBrdjanin, Case No. IT-99-36-T, 1 September 2004.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R101">
			<label>101</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. RadoslavBrdjanin, Case No. IT-99-36-T,      3 October 2003</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R102">
			<label>102</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. Radovan Karadzic, Case No.      IT-95-5/18-T, 30 September 2010</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R103">
			<label>103</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. ZdravkoMucic, Case No. IT-96-21-PT, 9      February 1998</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R104">
			<label>104</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. ZejnilDelalic et al, Case No,      IT-96-21-T, 2 September 1997</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R105">
			<label>105</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. ZejnilDelalic et al, Case No.      IT-96-21-A, 20 February 2001</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R106">
			<label>106</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. ZejnilDelalic et al, Case No.      IT-96-21-T, 2 September 1999</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R107">
			<label>107</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. ZejnilDelalic et al, Case No. IT-96-21-T,      25 September 1997</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R108">
			<label>108</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v. ZejnilDelalic et al, Case No.      IT-96-21-T, 8 September 1997</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R109">
			<label>109</label>
			<element-citation>Prosecutor v.ZoranKupreškic´ et al, Case No.      IT-95-16-T, 14 January 2000</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R110">
			<label>110</label>
			<element-citation>Scoppola v. Italy, Case No. ECTHR. (no. 2) [GC], no.      10249/03, 17 September 2009</element-citation>
		</ref>
	</ref-list>
		</back>
</article>
<article article-type="Research Paper" dtd-version="3.0" xml:lang="en">
			  <front>
			    <journal-meta>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="pmc"></journal-id>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="publisher-id">دانشگاه شیراز</journal-id>
			    	<journal-title-group>
				      <journal-title>Journal of Legal Studies</journal-title>
			    	</journal-title-group>
			      <issn pub-type="ppub">2008-7926</issn>
			      <publisher>
			        <publisher-name>دانشگاه شیراز</publisher-name>
			      </publisher>
			    </journal-meta>
			    <article-meta>
 			      <article-id pub-id-type="publisher-id">13</article-id>
			      <article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.22099/jls.2018.28690.2846</article-id>		
			      <ext-link xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5031_3dc22c94c80414c8f2144f1432ffdf8a.pdf"/>		
			      <article-categories>
			        <subj-group subj-group-type="heading">
					          		<subject>حقوق تجارت</subject>
			        	</subj-group>
			      </article-categories>
			      <title-group>
			        <article-title>Directors ‘Liability in Light of Business Judgment Rule, with emphasis on Delaware’s Laws.</article-title>
			        
			      </title-group>
			      
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c1" corresp="yes">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Soltani</surname>
			            <given-names>Mohammad</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>Assistant Professor, Department of international commercial law, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c2" corresp="yes">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Gholami</surname>
			            <given-names>Vahideh</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>Ph.D. Candidate in the law of oil and gas, Department of international commercial law, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			      <pub-date pub-type="ppub">
			        <day>22</day>
			        <month>11</month>
			        <year>2018</year>
			      </pub-date>
			      <volume>10</volume>
			      <issue>3</issue>
			      <fpage>131</fpage>
			      <lpage>157</lpage>
			      <history>
			        <date date-type="received">
			          <day>05</day>
			          <month>04</month>
			          <year>2017</year>
			        </date>
			        <date date-type="accepted">
			          <day>13</day>
			          <month>10</month>
			          <year>2018</year>
			        </date>
			      </history>
			      <permissions>
			      	<copyright-statement>Copyright &#x000a9; 2018, دانشگاه شیراز. </copyright-statement>	
			        <copyright-year>2018</copyright-year>
			      </permissions>
			       <self-uri xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5031.html">https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5031.html</self-uri> 		
			      <abstract>
			        <p>Business judgment rule refers to the presumption that directors are not responsible for losses that may be suffered as a result of a decision that directors made or authorized in good faith. It protects directors from personal civil liability for the decisions they make on behalf of a corporation, even though the decision proves to be erroneous. This rule is applicable upon an examination of certain preconditions, but prevents courts to second-guess director’s decisions. The basis of this rule lays on the fact that if discretion of management of the company is referred to directors, they must be protected against claims on application of this discretion. Otherwise, management of modern companies is impossible. Therefore, this article examines the standard of liability as business judgment should be regarded as a rule which prevents courts from reviewing directors’ decisions absent grounds breach of fiduciary duties (such as of self-dealing, lack of independence or irrational decisions). This article will discuss emergence and application of business judgment rule in Delaware courts and analyzes the existence of this rule in Iran’s legal system.    </p>
			      </abstract>
					<kwd-group kwd-group-type="author">
						<kwd>Board</kwd>
						<kwd>Directors</kwd>
						<kwd>Business Judgment Rule</kwd>
						<kwd>Liability</kwd>
						<kwd>Control</kwd>
						<kwd>Good faith</kwd>
					</kwd-group>
			    </article-meta>
			  </front>
<back>
	<ref-list>
		<ref id="R1">
			<label>1</label>
			<element-citation>الف) فارسی</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R2">
			<label>2</label>
			<element-citation>امینی، منصور و ابراهیمی، عیسی (1390)، «حسن نیت در قراردادها، از نظریه تا عمل، نگاهی به موضوع در نظام حقوقی کامن لو»، مجله حقوق تطبیقی، دوره 2، شماره 2، صص23-43.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R3">
			<label>3</label>
			<element-citation>پاسبان، محمدرضا (1395)، حقوق شرکت‌های تجاری، ویراست دوم، تهران: انتشارات سمت.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R4">
			<label>4</label>
			<element-citation>ستوده تهرانی، حسن (1396)،‌ حقوق تجارت، ج دوم، تهران: انتشارات دادگستر.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R5">
			<label>5</label>
			<element-citation>عرفانی، محمود (1387)، حقوق تجارت، ج دوم (شرکت‌های تجاری)، تهران: انتشارات جنگل.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R6">
			<label>6</label>
			<element-citation>نوری یوشانلویی، جعفر و جوهر، سعید (1393)، «مفهوم شناسی مسئولیت اجتماعی شرکت­های تجاری در حقوق آلمان، فرانسه، انگلستان و ایران با رویکرد تطبیقی»، مجله حقوق تطبیقی، دوره 5، شماره 2، صص 603-627.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R7">
			<label>7</label>
			<element-citation>ب) انگلیسی</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R8">
			<label>8</label>
			<element-citation>American Law Institute publications, (1994), Principles of Corporate Governance: Analysis and Recommendations, American Law institute publications, Philadelphia.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R9">
			<label>9</label>
			<element-citation>American Law Institute, (2016) Model Business Corporations Act., American Law institute, Philadelphia,</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R10">
			<label>10</label>
			<element-citation>Arrow, Kenneth. J. (1974), The Limits of Organization, New York: W. W. Norton and Company.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R11">
			<label>11</label>
			<element-citation>Avi-Yonah, Rueven. S. (2005) »The cyclical transformations of the corporate form: a historical perspective on corporate social responsibility«. Del. J. Corp. l. 30, pp.767-818.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R12">
			<label>12</label>
			<element-citation>Bainbridge Stephan. M. (2002) »Why a Board? Group Decision-making in Corporate Governance« 55-VAND. L. REV., pp.1-57.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R13">
			<label>13</label>
			<element-citation>Bainbridge, Stephen M. (2004). »The Business Judgement Rule as Abstention Doctrine,« 57 Vand. L. Rev. pp.83-131</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R14">
			<label>14</label>
			<element-citation>Bainbridge, Stephen M., (2003), .»Director Primacy: The Means and Ends of Corporate Governance«, 97 NW. U. L. REV. pp.547-607.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R15">
			<label>15</label>
			<element-citation>Bainbridge. Stephen. M. (2008), The New Corporate Governance in Theory and Practice, Oxford University Press. Oxford.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R16">
			<label>16</label>
			<element-citation>Bhagat, Sanjai. &amp; Black, Bernard. (2000), »Board Independence and Long-Term Performance« (working paper), J Corp L, 1, 27, pp.231-275</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R17">
			<label>17</label>
			<element-citation>Black, Bernard. S. (1989). »Is corporate law trivial: A political and economic analysis.« Nw. UL Rev., 84, pp.542-598.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R18">
			<label>18</label>
			<element-citation>Black, Bernard. S. (2001)  »The Principal Fiduciary Duties of Boards of Directors«. Asia Bus. L. Rev., 33, pp.3-16</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R19">
			<label>19</label>
			<element-citation>Davis, Kenneth B., Jr. (1988), »Discretion of corporate managers to do good Expense of Shareholder Gain-A Survey of, and Commentary on, the U.S. Corporate Law«, Canada-United states law journal. Vol. 13, pp. 7-77.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R20">
			<label>20</label>
			<element-citation>Dewey, John. (1926). “The historic background of corporate legal personality”. TheYalelawjournal, 35(6), pp. 655-673.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R21">
			<label>21</label>
			<element-citation>Dooley, Michael. P., (1992) »Two Models of Corporate Governance«, 47, Bus. Law, pp.461-529.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R22">
			<label>22</label>
			<element-citation>Easterbrook, Frank. H, Fischel, Daniel R, (1991), The Economic Structure of Corporate law, Cambridge, Harvard University press,</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R23">
			<label>23</label>
			<element-citation>Elhauge, Einer. (2005) »Sacrificing Corporate Profits in the Public Interest«, 80 N.Y.U. L. REV., pp.733- 807.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R24">
			<label>24</label>
			<element-citation>Elson, Charles. M. (2017) »Why Delaware Must Retain its Corporate Dominance and Why it May Not«, Delaware, UniversityofDelaware - JohnL. WeinbergCenterforCorporateGovernance, pp.1-20.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R25">
			<label>25</label>
			<element-citation>Fama, Eugene, &amp; Jensen, Michael. (1983). »Separation of Ownership and Control«. The Journal of Law &amp; Economics, 26(2), pp.301-325.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R26">
			<label>26</label>
			<element-citation>Franks, Julian. R., &amp; Mayer, Colin. (2017). »Evolution of Ownership and Control Around the World: The Changing Face of Capitalism«. European Corporate Governance Institute, Finance working paper No.503/2017.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R27">
			<label>27</label>
			<element-citation>Gold, Andrew. S. A, (2007), »Decision Theory Approach ToThe Business Judgment Rule: Reflections on Disney, Good Faith, And Judicial Uncertainty«, Maryland Law review, Vol. 66, pp.398-474.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R28">
			<label>28</label>
			<element-citation>Gourvish, Terence. R., (1987), »British Business and the Transition to a Corporate Economy: Entrepreneurship and Management Structures«, 39(4) Business History, pp.18-45. </element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R29">
			<label>29</label>
			<element-citation>Grossman, Adelle, (2007).»Director Compliance with Elusive Fiduciary Duties in a Climate of Corporate Governance Reform«, FORDHAM J. CORP. &amp; FIN. L. 12, pp.393-466.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R30">
			<label>30</label>
			<element-citation>Kirby, Maurice.W., (1996), »The Corporate Economy in Britain: Its Rise and Achievements Since 1900«, in Maurice W. Kirby and Mary B. Rose (eds), Business Enterprise in Modern Britain: From the Eighteenth to the Twentieth Century «The Journal of Economic History, vol. 56, issue 04, pp.139-171.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R31">
			<label>31</label>
			<element-citation>Korn/ Ferry International, (2000), 27th Annual Board of Directors Study, pp.33-34</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R32">
			<label>32</label>
			<element-citation>Lawrence A. Cunningham, (1999), »Commonalities and Prescriptions in the Vertical Dimension of Global Corporate Governance«, 84 CORNELL L. REV, pp.1133- 1183</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R33">
			<label>33</label>
			<element-citation>Lewis S. Black, JR., (2007), Why Corporations Choose Delaware, Delaware, Del Dept. Of State Div. Of Corp., pp.1-23</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R34">
			<label>34</label>
			<element-citation>Lowenstein, Roger. (2004), Origins of the crash: The great bubble and its undoing, London, Penguin.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R35">
			<label>35</label>
			<element-citation>Maubossin, Michael. J, (2011), »What Shareholders Value is Really About?«, 22, Harvard Business Review, pp.51-57</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R36">
			<label>36</label>
			<element-citation>Means, Gardiner. C. (1932), The Modern Corporation and Private Property. New York: MacMillan.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R37">
			<label>37</label>
			<element-citation>Melvin, Aron Eisenberg, (1993), »The Divergence of Standards of Conduct and Standards of Review in Corporate Law«, 62 FORDHAM L. REV.pp. 437-468</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R38">
			<label>38</label>
			<element-citation>Millon, David, (1990). »Theories of the Corporation«. DukeLawJournal, pp. 201-262.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R39">
			<label>39</label>
			<element-citation>Mitchell, Sali.Tsuk, »Shareholders as Proxies: The Contours of Shareholder Democracy«, 63WASH. &amp; LEE L. REV., pp.1503-1578.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R40">
			<label>40</label>
			<element-citation>National Association of Corporation Directors of the NACD, (1995), also (1996), Blue ribbon commission on director’s compensation, purpose, principles and best practices.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R41">
			<label>41</label>
			<element-citation>Parkinson, J.K.,( 1995), Corporate Power and Responsibility: Issues in the Theory of Company Law, Oxford., Oxford University Press.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R42">
			<label>42</label>
			<element-citation>Pitelis, Christos. N., &amp; Sugden, R. (1986). »The separation of ownership and control in the theory of the firm: a reappraisal«. International Journal of Industrial Organization, 4(1), pp. 69-86;</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R43">
			<label>43</label>
			<element-citation>Rhee, Robert. J. (2009), »Fiduciary exemption for public necessity: Shareholder profit, public good, and the Hobson's choice during a national crisis.« 17, Geo. Mason L. Rev. pp.661-736.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R44">
			<label>44</label>
			<element-citation>Rosenberg, David. (2007), »Galactic Stupidity and the Business Judgment Rule« Journal of Corporation Law, Iowa City 32.2, pp.301-322.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R45">
			<label>45</label>
			<element-citation>Sharfman, Bernard. S. (2014), »Shareholder wealth maximization and its implementation under corporate law«. Fla. L. Rev. 66, pp.389-431.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R46">
			<label>46</label>
			<element-citation> Smith, Adam, (1776), WealthofNations, 5th edn, Book V, ch.1, New York, (Edwin Cannan, ed.1904, originally published.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R47">
			<label>47</label>
			<element-citation>Smith, D. Gordon, (2015), The Modern Business Judgment Rule, Research Handbook On Mergers And Acquisitions, Forthcoming. Boston, BYU Law Research Paper Series. No.15-09.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R48">
			<label>48</label>
			<element-citation>Smith, Terry, (2015), »What Exactly Do We Mean by Shareholders Value? Financial Times, January«, pp.6-8</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R49">
			<label>49</label>
			<element-citation>Spencer, Herbert, »Railway Morals and Railway Policy«, (1854), 100 Edinburg Review, , pp. 420-461,</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R50">
			<label>50</label>
			<element-citation>Sprague, Robert, &amp; Lyttle, Aaron. J. (2010), »Shareholder primacy and the business judgment rule: Arguments for expanded corporate democracy. « 16, 1, Stan. JL Bus. &amp; Fin., pp.1-26.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R51">
			<label>51</label>
			<element-citation>Thompson, Robert. B., &amp; Thomas, R. S., (2004), »The new look of shareholder litigation: acquisition-oriented class actions. «57, Vand. L. Rev,, pp.133-211.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R52">
			<label>52</label>
			<element-citation>Aronson v. Lewis, 473 A.2d 805, 812 (Del. 1984).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R53">
			<label>53</label>
			<element-citation>BNS Inc. v. Koppers Co., 683 F. Supp. 473, 74 (D. Del. 1988).In re Citigroup Inc. S'holder Derivative Litig., 964 A.2d 124 (Del. Ch. 2009.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R54">
			<label>54</label>
			<element-citation>Bodell v. Gen. Gas &amp;Elec. Corp., 140 A. 264, 267 (Del. 1927)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R55">
			<label>55</label>
			<element-citation>Brehm v. Eisner. 746. A2d, 262-64 (Del2000).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R56">
			<label>56</label>
			<element-citation>Casey v. Woodruff, 49 N.Y.S.2d 625, 643 (N.Y. Sp. Term 1944).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R57">
			<label>57</label>
			<element-citation>Cede &amp; Co. v. Technicolor, Inc., 634 A.2d 345 (Del. 1993)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R58">
			<label>58</label>
			<element-citation>Corwin v. KKR Financial Holdings LLC, 125 A. 3d 304, 313-14 (Del. 2015),</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R59">
			<label>59</label>
			<element-citation>Cuker v. Mikalauskas, 547 Pa. 600, 692 A.2d 1042 (1997).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R60">
			<label>60</label>
			<element-citation>Disney II, 746 A.2d 244, 256 (Del. 2000) (en banc)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R61">
			<label>61</label>
			<element-citation>Disney IV, 907 A.2d 693, 699–745 (Del. Ch. 2005).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R62">
			<label>62</label>
			<element-citation>Dodge V. Ford Motors Co, 170 N.W. 668 (Mich. 1919);</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R63">
			<label>63</label>
			<element-citation>Emerald Partners v. Berlin, No. Civ. A. 9700, 2001 WL 115340, at *25 n.63 (Del. Ch. Feb. 7, 2001).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R64">
			<label>64</label>
			<element-citation>In re Dow Chemical Company Derivative Litigation, No. 4349, 2010 Del. Ch. LEXIS, at *2 (Del. Ch. Jan. 11, 2010).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R65">
			<label>65</label>
			<element-citation>In re RJR Nabisco, Inc. S’holders Litig. Civ. A. No. 10389, 1989 WL 7036, at *13 n.13 (Del. Ch. Jan. 31, 1989).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R66">
			<label>66</label>
			<element-citation>Lyondell, 970 A.2d at 243.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R67">
			<label>67</label>
			<element-citation>Marony v. Applegate. 266 A.D. 412, 422, (N.Y. App. Div. 1943)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R68">
			<label>68</label>
			<element-citation>Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors of Integrated Health Services, Inc. v. Elkins. No. Civ. A. 20228-NC, 2004 WL 1949290 (Del. Ch. Aug. 24, 2004). n. 92.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R69">
			<label>69</label>
			<element-citation>Paramount Communications, Inc. v. Time Inc., 571 A.2d 1140 (Del. 1989).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R70">
			<label>70</label>
			<element-citation>Percy v. Millaudon, 8. Mart. (n.s.) 68 (La. 1829).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R71">
			<label>71</label>
			<element-citation>Perrine v. Pennroad Corp., 487-8 A.2d 479 (Del. 1946)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R72">
			<label>72</label>
			<element-citation>Robinson v. Pittsburgh Oil Refining Corp., 126 A. 46 (Del. Ch. 1924).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R73">
			<label>73</label>
			<element-citation>Selheimer v. Manganese Corp., Spering’s Appeal, 71 Pa. 11, 20 (1872).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R74">
			<label>74</label>
			<element-citation>Shlensky v. Wrigley. 237 N.E.2d 776 (Ill. App. 1968)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R75">
			<label>75</label>
			<element-citation>Smith v. Van Gorkom, 488 A.2d 858 (Del. 1985) (en banc).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R76">
			<label>76</label>
			<element-citation> Spering’s Appeal, 71 Pa. at 24.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R77">
			<label>77</label>
			<element-citation>Stone v Ritter, No. 93, 2006 WL 3169168 (Del. Nov. 6, 2006).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R78">
			<label>78</label>
			<element-citation>The Walt Disney Company Derivative Litigation, Disney II, 746 A.2d 244, 264 (Del. 2000)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R79">
			<label>79</label>
			<element-citation>Unocal Corp. v. Mesa Petroleum Co., 493 A.2d 946 (Del. 1985</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R80">
			<label>80</label>
			<element-citation> _||_</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R81">
			<label>81</label>
			<element-citation>1-     Amini, Mansour, Ebrahimi, Esa, “Good faith in contracts, from theory to practice, analysis of the issue in common law system”, Comparative law reviews, N0.2, 2001.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R82">
			<label>82</label>
			<element-citation>2-     Paseban, Mohammad Reza, “The law of commercial companies”, Second version, SAMT publications, 2016.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R83">
			<label>83</label>
			<element-citation>3-     , Sotoudeh Tehran, Hassan, “Commercial law”, volume 2, Dadgostar Publications, 2017.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R84">
			<label>84</label>
			<element-citation>4-     Erfani, Mahmood, Commercial law, Volume 2 (commercial companies), Jungle Publications,  2007.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R85">
			<label>85</label>
			<element-citation>Noury Youshanloey, Jafar, Johar, Saeid, “The concept of corporate social responsibility in Germany, France, Britain and Iran with Comparative Approach”</element-citation>
		</ref>
	</ref-list>
		</back>
</article>
<article article-type="Research Paper" dtd-version="3.0" xml:lang="en">
			  <front>
			    <journal-meta>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="pmc"></journal-id>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="publisher-id">دانشگاه شیراز</journal-id>
			    	<journal-title-group>
				      <journal-title>Journal of Legal Studies</journal-title>
			    	</journal-title-group>
			      <issn pub-type="ppub">2008-7926</issn>
			      <publisher>
			        <publisher-name>دانشگاه شیراز</publisher-name>
			      </publisher>
			    </journal-meta>
			    <article-meta>
 			      <article-id pub-id-type="publisher-id">13</article-id>
			      <article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.22099/jls.2018.26990.2609</article-id>		
			      <ext-link xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5032_c199d191b6ed7e2ec8e1c77c577d72aa.pdf"/>		
			      <article-categories>
			        <subj-group subj-group-type="heading">
					          		<subject>حقوق جزا و جرمشناسی</subject>
			        	</subj-group>
			      </article-categories>
			      <title-group>
			        <article-title>Economic Crimes Criminal Procedure; The Connection between Substance and Process</article-title>
			        
			      </title-group>
			      
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c1">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Soltanifard</surname>
			            <given-names>Hosein</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>PhD candidate of criminal law and criminology, Isfahan  Branch, Islamic Azad University, korasgan, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c2" corresp="yes">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Malmeir</surname>
			            <given-names>Mahmood</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>Associate professor  of criminal law and criminology, Isfahan  Branch, Islamic Azad University, korasgan, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c3">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Alipour</surname>
			            <given-names>Hasan</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>Assistant Professor of criminal Law and criminology, University of Tehran, (Farabi Campus), Qom, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			      <pub-date pub-type="ppub">
			        <day>22</day>
			        <month>11</month>
			        <year>2018</year>
			      </pub-date>
			      <volume>10</volume>
			      <issue>3</issue>
			      <fpage>159</fpage>
			      <lpage>194</lpage>
			      <history>
			        <date date-type="received">
			          <day>24</day>
			          <month>10</month>
			          <year>2017</year>
			        </date>
			        <date date-type="accepted">
			          <day>14</day>
			          <month>02</month>
			          <year>2018</year>
			        </date>
			      </history>
			      <permissions>
			      	<copyright-statement>Copyright &#x000a9; 2018, دانشگاه شیراز. </copyright-statement>	
			        <copyright-year>2018</copyright-year>
			      </permissions>
			       <self-uri xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5032.html">https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5032.html</self-uri> 		
			      <abstract>
			        <p>In Iran, economic crimes occupy three positions. The first one is that of the exemplary one. For example, in the Islamic Penal Code, we find crimes that border on the concept of economic crimes. The example of this category is destroying the economic order. The second is the judicial position which are determined as a result of the judicial policy and the third one is the status-based position, which the law-maker explicitly identifies them as economic crimes. Given this, the question is whether the economic crimes have an independent character in the Penal Code? This challenge has caused the economic crimes to be more of a procedural nature and character than a substantive one. This essay examines this challenge in full and introduces its shortcomings in the Iranian penal sysyem.  </p>
			      </abstract>
					<kwd-group kwd-group-type="author">
						<kwd>Economic crimes</kwd>
						<kwd>Differential procedure</kwd>
						<kwd>Substance and Process</kwd>
						<kwd>Criminal proceedings</kwd>
					</kwd-group>
			    </article-meta>
			  </front>
<back>
	<ref-list>
		<ref id="R1">
			<label>1</label>
			<element-citation>الف) فارسی</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R2">
			<label>2</label>
			<element-citation>ابراهیمی، شهرام و صفایی آتشگاه، حامد (1394)، «رویکرد قانون‌گذار به پیشگیری از جرم در قانون ارتقاء سلامت نظام اداری و مقابله با فساد»، پژوهش‌نامه حقوق کیفری، دوره 6، شماره 2، صص 31-7.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R3">
			<label>3</label>
			<element-citation>ابراهیمی، شهرام و صادق‌نژاد نائینی، مجید (1392)، «تحلیل جرم شناختی جرائم اقتصادی»، فصلنامه پژوهش حقوق کیفری، دوره 2، شماره 5، صص 174-147.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R4">
			<label>4</label>
			<element-citation>الهام، غلامحسین و گلدوزیان، حسین (1392) «تحلیل مفهوم و شرایط تحقق دام‌گستری با رویکردی تطبیقی در حقوق کیفری آمریکا و ایران»، فصلنامه پژوهش حقوق کیفری، دوره 2، شماره 4، صص 135-107.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R5">
			<label>5</label>
			<element-citation>الهام، غلامحسین و دیگران (1393)، «چالش‌های تعریف جرم قاچاق در نظام حقوقی ایران»، فصلنامه دیدگاه‌های حقوق قضایی، دوره 19، شماره 68 ، صص 78-47 .</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R6">
			<label>6</label>
			<element-citation>بهره‌مند بگ نظر، حمید (1389)، سیاست جنایی تقنینی ایران در قبال فساد و مطالعه تطبیقی آن با کنوانسیون ملل متحد برای مبارزه با فساد، رساله دکتری، حقوق جزا و جرم‌شناسی، دانشگاه تهران.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R7">
			<label>7</label>
			<element-citation>تدین، عباس (1388)، تحصیل دلیل در آیین دادرسی کیفری، تهران: انتشارات میزان.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R8">
			<label>8</label>
			<element-citation>توسلی زاده، توران (1392)، پیشگیری از جرائم اقتصادی، تهران: انتشارات جنگل.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R9">
			<label>9</label>
			<element-citation>جانی پور، علی (1393)، دادگاه‌های کیفری اختصاصی؛ تحلیلی در اسناد بین‌المللی و نظام حقوق ایران، تهران: انتشارات شهر دانش.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R10">
			<label>10</label>
			<element-citation>جمشیدی، علیرضا (1388)، «پیش­گیری از جرائم اقتصادی؛ از اقدامات قضایی تا اقدامات اجرایی» در: مجموعه سخنرانی‌های ارائه شده در نخستین همایش ملی پیشگیری از وقوع جرم، به کوشش محمد فرجیها و سید محمد حسین سرکشیکیان، چاپخانه معاونت آموزش ناجا.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R11">
			<label>11</label>
			<element-citation>حسنی، جعفر و مهرا، نسرین (1394)، «نقدی بر مفهوم جرم اقتصادی در قانون مجازات اسلامی مصوب 1392»، مجله مطالعات حقوق کیفری و جرم‌شناسی، دوره 2، شماره 2 و 3، صص 69-45.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R12">
			<label>12</label>
			<element-citation>خالقی، علی (1394)، نکته­ها در قانون آیین دادرسی کیفری، تهران: انتشارات شهر دانش.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R13">
			<label>13</label>
			<element-citation>خداییان چگنی، ذبیح‌اله (1391)، «بررسی تطبیقی نهادهای نظام عدالت کیفری فرانسه و ایران در مقابله با جرائم اقتصادی»، مجله مطالعات حقوقی، دوره 4، شماره 2، صص 58-31.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R14">
			<label>14</label>
			<element-citation>دادخدایی، لیلا (1390)، فساد مالی-اداری و سیاست جنایی مقابله با آن، تهران: انتشارات میزان.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R15">
			<label>15</label>
			<element-citation>دراج، بهزاد (1382)، اصل برائت؛مبانی و آثار آن در امور کیفری، پایان‌نامه کارشناسی ارشد، حقوق جزا و جرم‌شناسی، دانشگاه شهید بهشتی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R16">
			<label>16</label>
			<element-citation>رحمدل، منصور (1386) «قانون اساسی و بار اثبات در امور کیفری»، فصلنامه حقوق اساسی، سال چهارم، شماره 8، صص 129-110.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R17">
			<label>17</label>
			<element-citation>رستمی، ولی (1388)،«حقوق مؤدیان مالیاتی»، فصلنامه حقوق، دوره 39، شماره 1، صص 128-107.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R18">
			<label>18</label>
			<element-citation>رستمی تبریزی، لمیاء و زارع، محمد کاظم (1392)«تحلیل انتشار حکم محکومیت در حقوق کیفری ایران از نگاه فلسفه کیفری»، فصلنامه پژوهش حقوق کیفری، سال دوم، شماره 4، صص160-140.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R19">
			<label>19</label>
			<element-citation>رستمی، ولی و کتابی رودی، احمد (1392)، «اختیارات و اقتدارات دستگاه مالیاتی؛ زمان و شیوه وصول مالیات، مطالعه موردی در کشور ایران و انگلستان»، مجله مطالعات حقوقی تطبیقی، دوره 4، شماره 2، صص165-137.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R20">
			<label>20</label>
			<element-citation>رضوی فرد، بهزاد (1392)، «تقویت اصل قانونی بودن جرائم و کیفرهای مالیاتی و ضمانت اجرای اولین گام‌های پیشگیری از جرائم مالیاتی: با نگاهی به حقوق فرانسه»؛ در: ارتقای سلامت اداری نظام مالیاتی (مجموعه‌ی مقالات همایش چالش‌ها و فرصت‌های فراروی سلامت نظام مالیاتی کشور، با تأکید بر پیشگیری از تخلف)، به کوشش شهرام ابراهیمی، تهران: انتشارات میزان، صص145 -129.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R21">
			<label>21</label>
			<element-citation>سلیمی، صادق (1391)، جنایت سازمان‌یافته فراملی، تهران: انتشارات جنگل.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R22">
			<label>22</label>
			<element-citation>سماواتی پیروز، امیر (1390)، «تأملی بر جرائم اقتصادی از منظر بایسته‌های حقوق جزای اقتصادی»، مجله تحقیقات حقوقی، ضمیمه شماره 56 (یادنامه شادروان دکتر نوربها)، صص 676-645.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R23">
			<label>23</label>
			<element-citation>شاملو، باقر و مرادی، مجید (1392) «تحدید تضمینات دادرسی عادلانه در پرتو امنیت گرایی در جرم پول‌شویی» مجله حقوقی دادگستری، دوره 77، شماره 81، صص 159-111.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R24">
			<label>24</label>
			<element-citation>عباسی، اصغر (1393)، مبارزه با پول‌شویی در اسناد بین‌المللی و نظام حقوقی ایران، تهران: انتشارات میزان.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R25">
			<label>25</label>
			<element-citation>فرجیها، محمد و مقدسی، محمد باقر (1393)، «جلوه‌های عوام‌گرایی در سیاست‌های کیفری مواد مخدر»، مجله تحقیقات حقوقی، دوره 17، شماره 68، صص 48-25.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R26">
			<label>26</label>
			<element-citation>فرجیها، محمد و مقدسی، محمد باقر (1392) ،«پاسخ‌های کیفری عوام‌گرایانه به مفاسد اقتصادی» در: دایره‌المعارف علوم جنایی (مجموعه مقالات تازه‌های علوم جنایی)، کتاب دوم، تهران: انتشارات میزان، صص1193-1175.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R27">
			<label>27</label>
			<element-citation>قدیری بهرام آبادی، رشید (1389)، تحولات تحصیل دلیل در جرم پول‌شویی با رویکرد به اسناد بین‌المللی، قوانین و مقررات ایران و انگلیس، پایان‌نامه کارشناسی ارشد، حقوق جزا و جرم‌شناسی، دانشگاه شهید بهشتی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R28">
			<label>28</label>
			<element-citation>کوشا، جعفر (1390)، «امنیت اقتصادی با تأیید بر پیشگیری و مبارزه با قاچاق کالا و پول‌شویی»، مجله تحقیقات حقوقی، ضمیمه شماره 56 (یادنامه شادروان دکتر نوربها) صص 894 -869.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R29">
			<label>29</label>
			<element-citation>کوشکی، غلامحسین و علیزاده سرشت، نادر (1394)، «نگاهی به قلمرو جرائم امنیتی در پرتو صلاحیت دادگاه انقلاب»، فصلنامه پژوهش حقوق کیفری، دوره 4، شماره 12، صص124-99.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R30">
			<label>30</label>
			<element-citation>محسنی، فرید (1396)، «جرم اقتصادی»، در: دانشنامه علوم جنایی اقتصادی، زیر نظر امیر حسن نیازپور، تهران: انتشارات میزان.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R31">
			<label>31</label>
			<element-citation>مؤذن‌زادگان، حسن علی و حسنی، عباس(1393)، «دفاع دام‌گستری؛ از مفهوم شناسی تا آثار»، مجله حقوقی دادگستری، دوره 78، شماره 85، صص 44-7.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R32">
			<label>32</label>
			<element-citation>مؤذن‌زادگان، حسن علی و حسنی، عباس (1391)، «وضعیت دفاع دام‌گستری در حقوق کیفری آمریکا، فرانسه و ایران»، مجله آموزه‌های حقوق کیفری، شماره 3، دوره 78، صص 50-23.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R33">
			<label>33</label>
			<element-citation>موحدی، جعفر (1393)، معکوس کردن بار اثبات دلیل در آیین دادرسی کیفری، تهران: انتشارات مجد.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R34">
			<label>34</label>
			<element-citation>مهدوی پور، اعظم (1390)، سیاست کیفری افتراقی در قلمرو بزهکاری اقتصادی، تهران: انتشارات میزان.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R35">
			<label>35</label>
			<element-citation>مهرا، نسرین و زاهدی، عبدالوحید (1394) «رویکرد نوین حقوق کیفری در موضوع بار اثبات دفاعیات»، مجله حقوقی دادگستری، دوره 79، شماره 90، صص 84-63.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R36">
			<label>36</label>
			<element-citation>میرسعیدی، سید منصور و زمانی، محمود (1392)، «جرم اقتصادی؛ تعریف یا ضابطه؟»، فصلنامه پژوهش حقوق کیفری، دوره 2، شماره 4، صص 199-167.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R37">
			<label>37</label>
			<element-citation>میرمحمد صادقی، حسین (1396)، «جرم های مالی»، در: دانشنامه علوم جنایی اقتصادی، زیر نظر امیرحسین نیازپور، تهران: انتشارات میزان.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R38">
			<label>38</label>
			<element-citation>نجفی ابرندآبادی، علی حسین (1391)، «از جرم یقه سفیدی تا جرم اقتصادی»، دیباچه در: مایکل ال بنسون و دیگران، جرائم یقه سفیدی، رویکردی فرصت مدار، ترجمه اسماعیل رحیمی نژاد، تهران: انتشارات میزان.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R39">
			<label>39</label>
			<element-citation>نجفی ابرندآبادی، علی حسین (1392)،«درباره سیاست جنایی افتراقی»،دیباچه در: کریستین لارژر، در آمدی بر سیاست جنایی، تهران: انتشارات میزان.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R40">
			<label>40</label>
			<element-citation>نورزاد، مجتبی (1389)، جرائم اقتصادی در حقوق کیفری ایران، تهران: انتشارات جنگل.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R41">
			<label>41</label>
			<element-citation>ولیدی، محمد صالح (1393) حقوق کیفری اقتصادی، جرائم علیه امنیت اقتصادی، جلد دوم، تهران: انتشارات جنگل.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R42">
			<label>42</label>
			<element-citation>یزدیان جعفری، جعفر (1384)، «دام گستری؛ مفهوم، مبانی و جایگاه آن در حقوق کیفری ایران»، فصلنامه تخصصی فقه و حقوق، سال دوم، شماره 2، صص 132-115.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R43">
			<label>43</label>
			<element-citation>ب) انگلیسی</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R44">
			<label>44</label>
			<element-citation>Benson, Micheal &amp; Simpson, Sally (2000), White-Collar Crime, An Opportunity Perspective, New York: Routledge.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R45">
			<label>45</label>
			<element-citation>Kofele Kale, Ndiva (2012) ,Combating Economic Crimes; Balancing Competing Rights and Interests in Prosecuting the Crime of Illicit Enrichment, First Published, London and New York: Routledge.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R46">
			<label>46</label>
			<element-citation>Miller, Banks &amp; Curry, Brett (2009) "Expertise, Experience and Ideology on Specialized Courts: The Case of the Court of Appeals  for  the Federal Circuit" , Law and Society Review, Vol. 43, No. 4, pp. 839-864.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R47">
			<label>47</label>
			<element-citation>Saris, Patti B. (2015) "The 2015 Economic Crime Guideline Amendments", Journal of Law and Business, Vol.12, No.1, pp. 2-33. Sjogren , Hans.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R48">
			<label>48</label>
			<element-citation> _||_</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R49">
			<label>49</label>
			<element-citation>References</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R50">
			<label>50</label>
			<element-citation>1- Ebrahimi, Shahram, Hamed Saffai Atashgah, (2015), "The Legislator's Approach to Crime Prevention in the Law on the Promotion of the Health of the Administrative System and Coping with Corruption", Journal of Criminal Law, V. 6, No. 2, PP. 7-31.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R51">
			<label>51</label>
			<element-citation>2- Ebrahimi, Shahram, Majid Sadegh Nejad Naeini (2016), “Criminological Analysis of Economic Crimes", Journal of Criminal Law Research, V. 2, N. 5, PP. 147-174.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R52">
			<label>52</label>
			<element-citation>3- Elham, Gholam Hossein, Hossein Ghodouzian (1392) "Analysis of the Concept and Conditions for the Judiciary Realization of with a Comparative Approach in American and Iranian Penal Law", Journal of Criminal Law Research, V. 2, No. 4, PP. 107-135.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R53">
			<label>53</label>
			<element-citation>4- Elham, Gholam Hossein, Seyyed Mahmoud Mirkhalili, Amir Mohammad Borhanfar (2014), "Challenges for defining the crime of smuggling in Iran's legal system", Journal of jurisprudential views, Vol. 19, No. 68.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R54">
			<label>54</label>
			<element-citation>5- Bahremand, Baghnazar, Hamid (2010), Iran's Criminal Legitimate Policy Regarding Corruption and its Comparative Study with the United Nations Convention against Corruption, Doctoral Dissertation, Criminal law and Criminology, Tehran University.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R55">
			<label>55</label>
			<element-citation>6- Tadein, Abbas (2009), studying the reason for the Criminal Procedure, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R56">
			<label>56</label>
			<element-citation>7- Tavasolizadeh, Turan (2013), Prevention of Economic Crimes, Tehran, Jangal Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R57">
			<label>57</label>
			<element-citation>8- Janipour, Ali (2014), Special Criminal Courts, Analytical in International Documents and the Iranian Law System, Tehran, Shahre Danesh Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R58">
			<label>58</label>
			<element-citation>9- Jamshidi, Alireza (2009), "Prevention of Economic Crimes, from Judicial Actions to Administrative Actions" in a series of lectures presented in the first national conference on the prevention of crime, by the efforts of Mohammad Farajih and Seyyed Mohammad Hossein Sarkashiyan, Printing Office of Deputy of NAJA Education.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R59">
			<label>59</label>
			<element-citation>10- Hasani, Jafar, Nasrin Mehra (2015), "A Critique on the Concept of Economic Crime in the Islamic Penal Code Approved in 2013", Journal of Criminal Law Studies and Criminology, Vol. 2, No.2 &amp; 3, PP. 45-69.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R60">
			<label>60</label>
			<element-citation>11- Khaleghi Ali (2015), Notes in the Code of Criminal Procedure, Tehran, Shahre Danesh Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R61">
			<label>61</label>
			<element-citation>12- Khodaian Chagini, Zabih Allah (2012), "A comparative study of the institutions of the criminal justice system of France and Iran in countering economic crime", Journal of  Legal Studies, Vol. 4, NO. 2, PP. 31-58.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R62">
			<label>62</label>
			<element-citation>13- Dadkhodai, Leila (2011), Financial-Administrative Corruption, and Criminal Policy against It, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R63">
			<label>63</label>
			<element-citation>14- Drajj, Behzad (2003), Principle of Innocence and Foundations and Works in Criminal Matters, Master's thesis, Criminal Law and Criminology, Shahid Beheshti University.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R64">
			<label>64</label>
			<element-citation>15) Rahmdel, Mansour (2007), "Constitution and burden of proof in qualitative matters" Journal of Basic Law, Vol. 4, No. 8, 129-110.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R65">
			<label>65</label>
			<element-citation>16) Rostami, Wali (2009), "The Taxpayer's Rights", Journal of Law, Vol. 39, No. 1, PP. 107-138.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R66">
			<label>66</label>
			<element-citation>17) Rostami Tabrizi, Lima, Mohammad Kazem Zare (2016) "Analysis of the Publication of the Conviction Sentence in Iran's Criminal Law from the Viewpoint of Criminal Philosophy", Journal of Criminal Law Research, Vol. 2, No. 4, PP. 140-160.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R67">
			<label>67</label>
			<element-citation>18) Rostami, Wali, Ahmad Ketabi Roody (2013), "The discretions and Authorities of the Tax System, Time and Method of Tax Collection, Case Study in Iran and the United Kingdom", Journal of Comparative Legal Studies, Vol. 4, No. 2, 165-137.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R68">
			<label>68</label>
			<element-citation>19) Razavi Fard, Behzad (2016), Strengthening the principle of legality of crimes and Tax penalties, and guaranteeing the implementation of the first steps to prevent tax crimes: with Looking at French law "in promoting the administrative health of the tax system (collection of articles, conference of challenges and the opportunities for health processing of the country's tax system, with an emphasis on preventing Violations), by efforts of Shahram Ebrahimi, Tehran, Mizan Publishing, PP. 129-145.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R69">
			<label>69</label>
			<element-citation>20- Salimi, Sadiq (2012), Transnational Organized Crime, Tehran, Jangal Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R70">
			<label>70</label>
			<element-citation>21- Samawati, Pirouz, Amir (2011), " A Reflection on economic crimes from the perspective of the requirements of economic criminal law"; Journal of Legal Investigations, Attachment No. 56 (Memoir Of Dr. Nurbah), PP. 645-676.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R71">
			<label>71</label>
			<element-citation>22- Shamloo, Baqir, Majid Moradi (1392), "Limitation of fair trial guarantees in the light of security-ism in the crime of money laundering", Journal of Law of Justice, Vol.77, No.81, PP. 111-159 .</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R72">
			<label>72</label>
			<element-citation>23- Abbasi, Asghar, (2018), combating money laundering in international documents and legal system of Iran, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R73">
			<label>73</label>
			<element-citation>24- Farajih, Mohammad, Mohammad Bagher Moghaddasi (1393), “Populist manifestations in Criminal Drug Policies." Journal of Legal Investigastions, Vol. 17, No. 68, PP. 25-48.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R74">
			<label>74</label>
			<element-citation>25- Farajih, Mohammad, Mohammad Bagher Moghaddasi (1392), “Criminal Populist Responses to Economic Penetrations" in the Encyclopedia of Criminal Sciences (Collected Papers on New Criminal Sciences), Second Book, Tehran, Mizan Publishing, PP. 1175-1193.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R75">
			<label>75</label>
			<element-citation>26- Ghadbari, Bahramabadi, Rashid (2010), Developments Of Studying reason in money laundering crime with the approach to international documents, laws and regulations of Iran and England, Master's Thesis, Criminal Law and Criminology, Shahid Beheshti University.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R76">
			<label>76</label>
			<element-citation>27- Kusha, Ja'far (2011), "Economic security with the confirmation of the prevention and fight against smuggling of goods and money laundering", Journal of Legal Investigastions, Appendix No. 56 (Memoir of Dr. Nouriha), 894-869</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R77">
			<label>77</label>
			<element-citation>28- Kushkei, Gholam Hossein, Nader Alizadeh Sresht (1394), "A Review of the Territory of Security Crimes in the Light of the Competence of the Revolutionary Court", Journal of Criminal Law Research, Vol. 4, No. 12, PP. 99-124.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R78">
			<label>78</label>
			<element-citation>29-Mohseni, Farbod (2017), "Economic Crime" in the Encyclopedia of Economic Criminal Law under the supervision of Amir Hassan Neyazpour, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R79">
			<label>79</label>
			<element-citation>30- Moazzin Zadegan, Hasan Ali, Abbas Hasani (2014), " Trapping Defense From concept-ology to Journal of Legal Justice", Vol. 78, N. 85, PP. 7-44.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R80">
			<label>80</label>
			<element-citation>31- Moazzin Zadegan, Hasan Ali, Abbas Hasani (2012), "The State of Trapping Defense in American, French and Iranian Criminal Law", Journal of Criminal Law Doctrines, No. 3, Vol. 78, PP. 23-50.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R81">
			<label>81</label>
			<element-citation>32- Movahedi, Jafar (1393), Reversing the burden of proof in criminal procedure, Tehran, Majd Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R82">
			<label>82</label>
			<element-citation>33- Mahdavipour, Azam (2011); Differential Criminal Policy in the Territory of Economic Delinquency, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R83">
			<label>83</label>
			<element-citation>34) Mehra, Nasrin, Abdolvahid Zahedi (2015), " The New Approach to Criminal Law in the subject of burden of proof of defenses" , Journal of Legal Justice, Vol. 79, No. 90, PP. 63-84.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R84">
			<label>84</label>
			<element-citation>35- Mir Saeedi, Seyyed Mansour, Mahmoud Zamani (1392), "Economic crime, Definition or Criterion?”, Journal of Criminal Law Research, Vol. 2, No. 4, PP.167-199.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R85">
			<label>85</label>
			<element-citation>36- Mir Mohammad Sadeghi, Hossein (2017), Financial Crime in the Encyclopedia of Economic Criminal Sciences, under the supervision of Amir Hassan Neyazpour, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R86">
			<label>86</label>
			<element-citation>37-Najafi Ebrahbandadi, Ali Hossein (2013), From White Collar Crime to Economic Crime, Presentations by Michael Elbenson and others, White Collar Crimes, a Circuit Opportunity Approach, Ismail Rahimi Nejad's Translation, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R87">
			<label>87</label>
			<element-citation>38- Najafi Ebrahbandadi, Ali Hossein (2013), About Differential Crime Policy, Preface in: Christian Larser, An Income on Criminal Policy, Tehran, Mizan Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R88">
			<label>88</label>
			<element-citation>39- Noorzad, Mojtaba (2010), Economic Crimes in Iran's Criminal Law, Tehran, Jangal Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R89">
			<label>89</label>
			<element-citation>40- Walidi, Mohammad Saleh (2014), Economic Criminal Law, Crimes against Economic Security, Vol. 2, Tehran, Jangal Publishing.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R90">
			<label>90</label>
			<element-citation>41) Yazdiyan Jafari, Jafar (2005), "Trapping, Concept, Foundations and Its Status in Iran's Criminal Law", Specialized Journal of Fiqh and Law, Second Year, No. 2, PP. 132-115</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R91">
			<label>91</label>
			<element-citation>42 - Benson, Micheal and Simpson, Sally(2000), white-collar crime, An opportunity perspective, NEWYORK , Routledge</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R92">
			<label>92</label>
			<element-citation>43- Kofele-Kale, Ndiva(2012) ,Combating Economic Crimes; Balancing competing rights and interests in prosecuting the crime of illicit enrichment, Routledge, London and New york, first published</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R93">
			<label>93</label>
			<element-citation>44- Miller , Banks, Curry , Brett(2009), Expertise ,Experience , and Ideology on Specialized Courts : The Case of the Court of Appeals  for  the Federal Circuit , law and Society Review , Vol. 43 , NO.4 , Doc</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R94">
			<label>94</label>
			<element-citation>45- Patti B, Honorable(2015); The 2015 economic crime guideline amendments, Journal of law and business, New york University, volume 12, Number 1</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R95">
			<label>95</label>
			<element-citation>46-Sjogren , Hans and Goran skogh(2004) , New perspectives  on economic Crime , Edward Elgar publishing Limited</element-citation>
		</ref>
	</ref-list>
		</back>
</article>
<article article-type="Research Paper" dtd-version="3.0" xml:lang="en">
			  <front>
			    <journal-meta>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="pmc"></journal-id>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="publisher-id">دانشگاه شیراز</journal-id>
			    	<journal-title-group>
				      <journal-title>Journal of Legal Studies</journal-title>
			    	</journal-title-group>
			      <issn pub-type="ppub">2008-7926</issn>
			      <publisher>
			        <publisher-name>دانشگاه شیراز</publisher-name>
			      </publisher>
			    </journal-meta>
			    <article-meta>
 			      <article-id pub-id-type="publisher-id">13</article-id>
			      <article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.22099/jls.2018.27826.2721</article-id>		
			      <ext-link xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5050_196c0728f44cd187f2c652a4a6b2c240.pdf"/>		
			      <article-categories>
			        <subj-group subj-group-type="heading">
					          		<subject>حقوق بین الملل</subject>
			        	</subj-group>
			      </article-categories>
			      <title-group>
			        <article-title>The Transfer of the US Embassy to the Occupied Territories of Palestine from the Point of View of International Law</article-title>
			        
			      </title-group>
			      
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c1" corresp="yes">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Maghami</surname>
			            <given-names>Amir</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>Assistant Proffessor in international law , Shahid Ashrafi Esfahani University, Isfahan, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c2">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Mellat</surname>
			            <given-names>Mohammad reza</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>Phd Student In International Law, University Of Qom, Qom, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c3">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Ahsan Nejad</surname>
			            <given-names>Masoud</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>Phd Student In International Law, University Of Qom, Qom, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			      <pub-date pub-type="ppub">
			        <day>22</day>
			        <month>11</month>
			        <year>2018</year>
			      </pub-date>
			      <volume>10</volume>
			      <issue>3</issue>
			      <fpage>195</fpage>
			      <lpage>225</lpage>
			      <history>
			        <date date-type="received">
			          <day>28</day>
			          <month>01</month>
			          <year>2018</year>
			        </date>
			        <date date-type="accepted">
			          <day>18</day>
			          <month>06</month>
			          <year>2018</year>
			        </date>
			      </history>
			      <permissions>
			      	<copyright-statement>Copyright &#x000a9; 2018, دانشگاه شیراز. </copyright-statement>	
			        <copyright-year>2018</copyright-year>
			      </permissions>
			       <self-uri xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5050.html">https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5050.html</self-uri> 		
			      <abstract>
			        <p>Al-Quds (Jerusalem) is a sacred city  among Abrahamic religions of Islam, Christianity and Judaism. It has been subject of many conflicts during the history from past to the present. The United States of America in 1995 during the peace process between Palestine and Zionist regime passed the Embassy Act under which the U.S embassy relocation from Tel-Aviv to al-Quds was approved. This act was suspended by U.S administrations until Trump administration issued an executive order in this regard in December 2017. Being considered by different international instruments and forums, the emphasis is added that the situation in the city is that of under-occupation since 1967 meaning that the East al-Quds is under the illegitimate authority of occupying power (although the authors believe that the whole lands of Palestine are occupied). Therefore, the present paper seeks international legal analysis of the relocation of U.S embassy to al-Quds. That is contrary to international regulations including the laws regarding holy places, customary international law, international law on occupation, the obligation of non-recognition of illegitimate situations and obligations arising from UN general assembly and Security Council resolutions.  </p>
			      </abstract>
					<kwd-group kwd-group-type="author">
						<kwd>Al-Quds (Jerusalem)</kwd>
						<kwd>Palestine</kwd>
						<kwd>Occupation</kwd>
						<kwd>Obligations of Occupying Power</kwd>
						<kwd>Embassy Act</kwd>
						<kwd>the Capital City</kwd>
					</kwd-group>
			    </article-meta>
			  </front>
<back>
	<ref-list>
		<ref id="R1">
			<label>1</label>
			<element-citation>الف.فارسی</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R2">
			<label>2</label>
			<element-citation>باقرزاده، محمدرضا (1380) «علل خودداری از شناسایی اسرائیل از دیدگاه حقوق بین‌الملل»، معرفت، 40، صص 116-113.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R3">
			<label>3</label>
			<element-citation>دانشفر، بهزاد (1393) «بررسی آثار ساخت دیوار حائل بر تشکیل کشور فلسطین»، مطالعات فلسطین، 24، صص 89-108.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R4">
			<label>4</label>
			<element-citation>دهقانی پوده، حمیدرضا (1389) «تحولات قدس و سازمان ملل متحد» ، مجله سیاست خارجی، 92، صص 200-183.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R5">
			<label>5</label>
			<element-citation>دوست محمدی، احمد (1382) «ساکنان و صاحبان اولیه و اصلی سرزمین فلسطین»، مجله دانشکده حقوق و علوم سیاسی دانشگاه تهران، 72، صص 98-65.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R6">
			<label>6</label>
			<element-citation>زمانی، سید قاسم (1378) «حقوق بشردوستانه بین‌المللی و اشغال سرزمین‌های ایران در جنگ تحمیلی»، سیاست دفاعی، 28، صص60-33.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R7">
			<label>7</label>
			<element-citation>صلح‌چی، محمدعلی (1385) «اعتبار قطعنامه‌های مجمع عمومی سازمان ملل متحد در رابطه با بحران فلسطین و اسرائیل»، پژوهش‌نامه حقوق و علوم سیاسی، سال اول، شماره اول، 46، صص 58-39.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R8">
			<label>8</label>
			<element-citation>ضیایی بیگدلی، محمدرضا (1384) «بررسی نظریه مشورتی دیوان بین‌المللی دادگستری در مورد آثار حقوقی ساخت دیوار حائل در سرزمین‌های فلسطین اشغالی». مجله حقوقی گواه، 4، صص 57-54.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R9">
			<label>9</label>
			<element-citation>طباطبایی، سید احمد و محبی، داود (1393) «حقوق بین‌الملل و تشکیل کشور مستقل فلسطینی»، فصلنامه پژوهش روابط بین‌الملل، 11، صص 162-129.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R10">
			<label>10</label>
			<element-citation>طهمورثی، اسماعیل (1397) "جنگ حقوقی فلسطین علیه اسرائیل، ظرفیت‌ها، تهدیدها، الزامات و راهکاره» http://www.tabyincenter.ir/qadim/index.php/free-menu-pajohesh/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R11">
			<label>11</label>
			<element-citation>کمیسیون ملی یونسکو ایران (1397) «یونسکو برای سومین بار، رژیم اشغالگر قدس را محکوم کرد» http://fa.irunesco.org/یونسکو-برای-سومین-بار،-رژیم-اشغالگر-قدس</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R12">
			<label>12</label>
			<element-citation>لسانی، حسام‌الدین و منفرد، مهوش (1396) «تأملی بر مشروعیت سیاست کشتار هدفمند از منظر حقوق بین‌الملل بشردوستانه»، مطالعات حقوقی دانشگاه شیراز, 6، صص 276-245.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R13">
			<label>13</label>
			<element-citation>هاشمی، سید محمدعلی (1394) «مکان‌های مقدس در آموزه‌های اسلامی و حقوق بین‌الملل»، میقات حج، 93، صص 44-21.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R14">
			<label>14</label>
			<element-citation>والاس، ربکا (1387) حقوق بین‌الملل، جلد 2،  ترجمه سید قاسم زمانی، تهران: شهر دانش.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R15">
			<label>15</label>
			<element-citation>ب.انگلیسی</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R16">
			<label>16</label>
			<element-citation>Bellinger, John.   (2017, 05 06). The Security Council Resolution on Syria: Is it Legally   Binding? (201705,18)Retrieved, from Lawfare:   https://www.lawfareblog.com/security-council-resolution-syria-it-legally-binding</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R17">
			<label>17</label>
			<element-citation>Bruno, Simma.   (1994). The Charter of the United Nations: A Commentary. Oxford   University Press.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R18">
			<label>18</label>
			<element-citation>Cattan, Hennry.   (1981). "The Status of Jerusalem under International Law and   United Nations Resolutions". Journal of Palestine Studies, 10.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R19">
			<label>19</label>
			<element-citation>Cortellessa,   Eric.(2017) Trump signs waiver, won’t move US embassy to Jerusalem. (2017, 08   01).  Retrieved from   https://www.timesofisrael.com/trump-signs-waiver-to-keep-us-embassy-in-tel-aviv/  </element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R20">
			<label>20</label>
			<element-citation>D’Amato,   Anthony. (2012) "Israel’s Borders under International Law",   Northwestern University School of Law Public Law and Legal Theory, series,   No.06-34.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R21">
			<label>21</label>
			<element-citation>Eva, Kassoti.   (2015). The Juridical Nature of Unilateral Acts of States in International   Law. Leiden/Boston: Brill Nijhoff.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R22">
			<label>22</label>
			<element-citation>Hirsch, Moshe.,   Housen-Couriel, Deborah., &amp; Lapidot, Ruth. (1995). Whither Jerusalem?:   Proposals and Positions Concerning the future of Jerusalem. Netherlands:   Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R23">
			<label>23</label>
			<element-citation>Joyner, Daniel..   Legal Bindingness of Security Council Resolutions Generally, and Resolution   2334 on the Israeli Settlements in Particular. (2017, 01 09) Retrieved from   Ejil Talk: https://www.ejiltalk.org/legal-bindingness-of-security-council-resolutions-generally-and-resolution-2334-on-the-israeli-settlements-in-particular/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R24">
			<label>24</label>
			<element-citation>Lopez Clara and Sterling Joe (2017)   "Guatemala to move embassy to Jerusalem” (2018, 01, 02) (http://edition.cnn.com/2017/12/24/middleeast/guatemala-jerusalem/index.html)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R25">
			<label>25</label>
			<element-citation>Milanovic, Marco, “Palestine   Sues the United States in the ICJ re Jerusalem Embassy”, (2018, 02, 10)   https://www.ejiltalk.org/palestine-sues-the-united-states-in-the-icj-re-jerusalem-embassy/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R26">
			<label>26</label>
			<element-citation>Öberg, Marko   Divac. (2006) "The Legal Effect of Resolutions of the UN Security   Council and General Assembly in the Jurisprudence of the ICJ", The   European Journal of International Law, 16, pp. 879-906.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R27">
			<label>27</label>
			<element-citation>Organisation of   Islamic Cooperation . (2017). Final Communique Extraordinary Islamic   Summit Conference on Al-Quds Ash-Sharif. Istanbul, Turkey.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R28">
			<label>28</label>
			<element-citation>Prolonged   Occupation and Article 6(3) of the Fourth Geneva Convention (2015) Why the   International Court Got It Wrong Substantively and Procedurally. (2015, 05   16). Retrieved from Ejil Talk:   https://www.ejiltalk.org/prolonged-occupation-and-article-63-of-the-fourth-geneva-convention-why-the-international-court-got-it-wrong-substantively-and-procedurally/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R29">
			<label>29</label>
			<element-citation>President   Trump’s Historic Change of U.S. Policy toward the Status of Jerusalem. (2017,   12 06). Retrieved from advocacy: https://advocacy.ou.org/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R30">
			<label>30</label>
			<element-citation>Sayej, Loureen (2017) . President Trump’s   Recognition of Jerusalem: A Legal Analysis. (2017, 12 11).  Retrieved from Oxford Human Rights Hub:   ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/president-trumps-recognition-of-jerusalem-a-legal-analysis/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R31">
			<label>31</label>
			<element-citation>Scott ,   Anderson., &amp; Schwartz, Yishai (2017) How to Move the U.S. Embassy to   Jerusalem. (2017, 11 30). Retrieved from Forein Policy:   http://foreignpolicy.com/2017/11/30/how-to-move-the-u-s-embassy-to-jerusalem/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R32">
			<label>32</label>
			<element-citation>Stefan, Talmon   (2017) the legalizing and legitimizing general assembly resolutions, 201.   (2017, 06 11).Retrieved from The American Society of International Law:   https://www.asil.org/blogs/legalizing-and-legitimizing-function-un-general-assembly-resolutions</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R33">
			<label>33</label>
			<element-citation>Stoutenburg,   Jenny Grote (2015). Disappearing Island States in International Law,. Brill   Nijhoff.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R34">
			<label>34</label>
			<element-citation>ج.اسناد</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R35">
			<label>35</label>
			<element-citation>A/RES/2253. (1967, 6 4). (2017,06,03) Retrieved from UNISPA: https://unispal.un.org/DPA/DPR/unispal.nsf/0/A39A906C89D3E98685256C29006D4014</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R36">
			<label>36</label>
			<element-citation>ICJ Reports,. Legal Consequences for States of the Continued Presence of South Africa in Namibia (South West Africa) Notwithstanding Security Council Resolution 276 (1970).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R37">
			<label>37</label>
			<element-citation>ICJ, 28 September 2018” The State of Palestine institutes proceedings against the United States of America” (2017, 12, 20) https://www.icj-cij.org/files/case-related/176/176-20180928-PRE-01-00-EN.pdf</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R38">
			<label>38</label>
			<element-citation>ICRC. (2001, 08 07). mplementation of the Fourth Geneva Convention in the occupied Palestinian territories: history of a multilateral process (1997-2001) . Retrieved from International Committee of the Red Cross : https://www.icrc.org/eng/resources/documents/article/other/5fldpj.htm IV Geneva Convention.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R39">
			<label>39</label>
			<element-citation>Knesset. (December 1949). Record of the Knesset Proceedings (Vol. vol 3 ). Israeil</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R40">
			<label>40</label>
			<element-citation>Legal Consequences for States of the continued Presence of South Africa in Namibia (South West Africa) notwithstanding Security Council Resolution 276 (1970), Advisory Opinion, I.C.J. Reports 1971</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R41">
			<label>41</label>
			<element-citation>Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (Advisory Opinion) [2004]</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R42">
			<label>42</label>
			<element-citation>North Sea Continental Shelf, Judgment, I.C.J. Reports 1969</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R43">
			<label>43</label>
			<element-citation>Resolution 181: The Partition Resolution of 29 November 1947. (2000, 05 13). (2017,03,20)Retrieved from 1948: LEST WE FORGET.: http://www.1948.org.uk/un-resolution-181.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R44">
			<label>44</label>
			<element-citation>Resolution 181: The Partition Resolution of 29 November 1947. (2000, 05 13). Retrieved from 1948: LEST WE FORGET.: http://www.1948.org.uk/un-resolution-181/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R45">
			<label>45</label>
			<element-citation>Update of the List of World Heritage in Danger (Retained Properties). (2017, 12 01). Retrieved from UNESCO: http://whc.unesco.org/en/decisions/6926</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R46">
			<label>46</label>
			<element-citation>UN General Assembly Resolution</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R47">
			<label>47</label>
			<element-citation>UN Security Council Resolution UN SC.. United Nations Position on Jerusalem Unchanged, Special Coordinator Stresses, as Security Council Debates United States Recognition of City. (207, 12 08)Retrieved from UN SC: https://www.un.org/press/en/2017/sc13111.doc.htm</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R48">
			<label>48</label>
			<element-citation>UN SC. “United Nations Position on Jerusalem Unchanged, Special Coordinator Stresses, as Security Council Debates United States Recognition of City.” (207, 12 08).  Retrieved from UN SC: https://www.un.org/press/en/2017/sc13111.doc.htm</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R49">
			<label>49</label>
			<element-citation>UN, 21 December 2017,” General Assembly demands all States comply with UN resolutions regarding status of Jerusalem” (2018, 01,05)http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=58330</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R50">
			<label>50</label>
			<element-citation>Update of the List of World Heritage in Danger (Retained Properties). (2017, 12 01). Retrieved from UNESCO: http://whc.unesco.org/en/decisions/6926</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R51">
			<label>51</label>
			<element-citation> _||_</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R52">
			<label>52</label>
			<element-citation>Bagherzadeh, M. (1380). Reasons for not recognizing Israel from the point of view of international law. Knowledge, 40.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R53">
			<label>53</label>
			<element-citation>Daneshfar, B. (1393). Study the effects of building a wall on the formation of a Palestinian state. Palestine Studies, 24.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R54">
			<label>54</label>
			<element-citation>Dehghani h. (1389). Quds and UN developments. Foreign Policy Magazine, 92.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R55">
			<label>55</label>
			<element-citation>Doostmohammadi. (1382). the inhabitants and the primary owners of the land of Palestine. Journal of Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran, 72.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R56">
			<label>56</label>
			<element-citation>Zamani,S. (1378). International humanitarian law and occupation of Iranian lands in the imposed war. Defense Policy, 28.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R57">
			<label>57</label>
			<element-citation>Solh Chi (1385). The credibility of the United Nations General Assembly resolutions on the Palestinian-Israeli crisis. Research Journal of Law and Political Science, Year 1, No. 1, 46.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R58">
			<label>58</label>
			<element-citation>Ziaei Bigdeli, M. (1384). Review the Advisory Opinion of the International Court of Justice on the legal effects of building a retaining wall in Occupied Palestinian Territories. Guard Law Magazine, 4.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R59">
			<label>59</label>
			<element-citation>Tabatabaei, A., &amp; Mohebi, D. (1393). International law and the formation of an independent Palestinian state. Quarterly Journal of International Relations, 11.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R60">
			<label>60</label>
			<element-citation>Lesani, S., &amp; Monfared, M. (1396). Tamilly on the legitimacy of targeted killer politics from the perspective of international humanitarian law. Legal Studies in Shiraz</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R61">
			<label>61</label>
			<element-citation>Wallace, R. (1387). International Law (Vol. 2). (Q. Translator) Tehran: His Custodians.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R62">
			<label>62</label>
			<element-citation>D’Amato, A. (2012). Israel’s borders under international law. Northwestern university school of law public law and legal theory series, No.06-34.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R63">
			<label>63</label>
			<element-citation>Bruno, S. (1994). The Charter of the United Nations: A Commentary. . Oxford University Press.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R64">
			<label>64</label>
			<element-citation>Cattan, H. (1981). The Status of Jerusalem under International Law and United Nations Resolutions. ournal of Palestine Studies, 10.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R65">
			<label>65</label>
			<element-citation>Eva, K. (2015). The Juridical Nature of Unilateral Acts of States in International Law . Leiden/Boston: Brill Nijhoff.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R66">
			<label>66</label>
			<element-citation>Hirsch, M., Housen-Couriel, D., &amp; Lapidot, R. (1995). Whither Jerusalem?: Proposals and Positions Concerning the future of Jerusalem. Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R67">
			<label>67</label>
			<element-citation>Knesset. (December 1949). Record of the Knesset Proceedings (Vol. vol 3 ). Israeil.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R68">
			<label>68</label>
			<element-citation>Öberg, M. D. (2006). the legal effect of resolutions of the UN security council and general assembly in the jurisprudence of the ICJ. The European Journal of International Law, 16.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R69">
			<label>69</label>
			<element-citation>Organisation of Islamic Cooperation . (2017). Final Communique Extraordinary Islamic Summit Conference on Al-Quds Ash-Sharif. Istanbul, Turkey.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R70">
			<label>70</label>
			<element-citation>Reports, I. (1971). LEGAL CONSEQUENCES FOR STATES OF THE CONTINUED PRESENCE OF SOUTH AFRICA IN NAMIBIA (SOUTH WEST AFRICA) NOTWITHSTANDING SECURITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION 276 (1970.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R71">
			<label>71</label>
			<element-citation>Stettner, I.-M. (2017). Positions on the Legal Status of Jerusalem. Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung - Palestinian Territories.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R72">
			<label>72</label>
			<element-citation>Stoutenburg, J. G. (2015). Disappearing Island States in International Law,. Brill Nijhoff.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R73">
			<label>73</label>
			<element-citation>Legal Consequences for States of the continued Presence of South Africa in Namibia (South West Africa) notwithstanding Security Council Resolution 276 (1970), Advisory Opinion, I.C.J. Reports 1971</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R74">
			<label>74</label>
			<element-citation>Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (Advisory Opinion) [2004]</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R75">
			<label>75</label>
			<element-citation>North Sea Continental Shelf, Judgment, I.C.J. Reports 1969</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R76">
			<label>76</label>
			<element-citation>IV Geneva Convention</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R77">
			<label>77</label>
			<element-citation>UN General Assembly Resolution</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R78">
			<label>78</label>
			<element-citation>UN Security Council Resolution</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R79">
			<label>79</label>
			<element-citation>            Web:</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R80">
			<label>80</label>
			<element-citation>President Trump’s Historic Change of U.S. Policy toward the Status of Jerusalem. (2017, 12 06). Retrieved from advocacy: https://advocacy.ou.org/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R81">
			<label>81</label>
			<element-citation>A/RES/2253. (1967, 6 4). Retrieved from UNISPA: https://unispal.un.org/DPA/DPR/unispal.nsf/0/A39A906C89D3E98685256C29006D4014</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R82">
			<label>82</label>
			<element-citation>Bellinger, J. (2017, 05 06). The Security Council Resolution on Syria: Is it Legally Binding? Retrieved from Lawfare: https://www.lawfareblog.com/security-council-resolution-syria-it-legally-binding</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R83">
			<label>83</label>
			<element-citation>Cortellessa, E. (2017, 06 01). Trump signs waiver, won’t move US embassy to Jerusalem. Retrieved from https://www.timesofisrael.com/trump-signs-waiver-to-keep-us-embassy-in-tel-aviv/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R84">
			<label>84</label>
			<element-citation>ICRC. (2001, 08 07). mplementation of the Fourth Geneva Convention in the occupied Palestinian territories: history of a multilateral process (1997-2001) . Retrieved from International Committee of the Red Cross : https://www.icrc.org/eng/resources/documents/article/other/5fldpj.htm</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R85">
			<label>85</label>
			<element-citation>Joyner, D. (2017, 01 09). Legal Bindingness of Security Council Resolutions Generally, and Resolution 2334 on the Israeli Settlements in Particular. Retrieved from Ejil Talk: https://www.ejiltalk.org/legal-bindingness-of-security-council-resolutions-generally-and-resolution-2334-on-the-israeli-settlements-in-particular/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R86">
			<label>86</label>
			<element-citation>Resolution 181: The Partition Resolution of 29 November 1947. (2000, 05 13). Retrieved from 1948: LEST WE FORGET.: http://www.1948.org.uk/un-resolution-181/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R87">
			<label>87</label>
			<element-citation>Sayej, L. (2017, 12 11). President Trump’s Recognition of Jerusalem: A Legal Analysis. Retrieved from Oxford Human Rights Hub: ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/president-trumps-recognition-of-jerusalem-a-legal-analysis/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R88">
			<label>88</label>
			<element-citation>Scott R, A., &amp; Schwartz, Y. (2017, 11 30). How to Move the U.S. Embassy to Jerusalem. Retrieved from Forein Policy: http://foreignpolicy.com/2017/11/30/how-to-move-the-u-s-embassy-to-jerusalem/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R89">
			<label>89</label>
			<element-citation>Stefan, t. a. (2017, 06 11). the legalizing and legitimizing general assembly resolutions, 201. Retrieved from The American Society of International Law: https://www.asil.org/blogs/legalizing-and-legitimizing-function-un-general-assembly-resolutions</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R90">
			<label>90</label>
			<element-citation>UN SC. (207, 12 08). United Nations Position on Jerusalem Unchanged, Special Coordinator Stresses, as Security Council Debates United States Recognition of City. Retrieved from UN SC: https://www.un.org/press/en/2017/sc13111.doc.htm</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R91">
			<label>91</label>
			<element-citation>Update of the List of World Heritage in Danger (Retained Properties). (2017, 12 01). Retrieved from UNESCO: http://whc.unesco.org/en/decisions/6926</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R92">
			<label>92</label>
			<element-citation>Resolution 181: The Partition Resolution of 29 November 1947. (2000, 05 13). Retrieved from 1948: LEST WE FORGET.: http://www.1948.org.uk/un-resolution-181/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R93">
			<label>93</label>
			<element-citation>http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=58330</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R94">
			<label>94</label>
			<element-citation>http://edition.cnn.com/2017/12/24/middleeast/guatemala-jerusalem/index.html</element-citation>
		</ref>
	</ref-list>
		</back>
</article>
<article article-type="Research Paper" dtd-version="3.0" xml:lang="en">
			  <front>
			    <journal-meta>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="pmc"></journal-id>
			      <journal-id journal-id-type="publisher-id">دانشگاه شیراز</journal-id>
			    	<journal-title-group>
				      <journal-title>Journal of Legal Studies</journal-title>
			    	</journal-title-group>
			      <issn pub-type="ppub">2008-7926</issn>
			      <publisher>
			        <publisher-name>دانشگاه شیراز</publisher-name>
			      </publisher>
			    </journal-meta>
			    <article-meta>
 			      <article-id pub-id-type="publisher-id">13</article-id>
			      <article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.22099/jls.2018.26426.2533</article-id>		
			      <ext-link xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5038_9f122fba50fdce91f72b98af2fa91e38.pdf"/>		
			      <article-categories>
			        <subj-group subj-group-type="heading">
					          		<subject>حقوق اقتصادی</subject>
					          		<subject>مسئولیت مدنی</subject>
			        	</subj-group>
			      </article-categories>
			      <title-group>
			        <article-title>Economic Basis of Loss Distribution in Tort Law</article-title>
			        
			      </title-group>
			      
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c1" corresp="yes">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Molodi</surname>
			            <given-names>Mohammad</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>law department,literature and human science faculty, Bu Ali Sina university, Hamadan, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c2">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Haji Azizi</surname>
			            <given-names>Bijan</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>Law department,  literature and  human science faculty, Bu Ali Sina university, Hamadan, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			       <contrib-group>
			       <contrib contrib-type="author" id="c3">
			          <name>
			            <surname>Gholami</surname>
			            <given-names>Negin</given-names>
			          </name>
					  <aff>law department, literature and human science faculty, Bu-Ali Sina university,Hamadan, Iran</aff>
			        </contrib>
			       </contrib-group>
			      <pub-date pub-type="ppub">
			        <day>22</day>
			        <month>11</month>
			        <year>2018</year>
			      </pub-date>
			      <volume>10</volume>
			      <issue>3</issue>
			      <fpage>227</fpage>
			      <lpage>258</lpage>
			      <history>
			        <date date-type="received">
			          <day>19</day>
			          <month>05</month>
			          <year>2017</year>
			        </date>
			        <date date-type="accepted">
			          <day>26</day>
			          <month>09</month>
			          <year>2018</year>
			        </date>
			      </history>
			      <permissions>
			      	<copyright-statement>Copyright &#x000a9; 2018, دانشگاه شیراز. </copyright-statement>	
			        <copyright-year>2018</copyright-year>
			      </permissions>
			       <self-uri xlink:href="https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5038.html">https://jls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_5038.html</self-uri> 		
			      <abstract>
			        <p>In the Iranian laws, loss distribution is mainly the case when two or more causes impose damage and the interference of each one in the realization of damage is the basis for damage distribution between them. In common law, damage distribution in civil liability is considered in a broader sense and it is differentiated from the number of causes. In fact, under loss distribution, those cases are considered where the damages that should reasonably be paid by the imposer are distributed among members of the community via some mechanisms. Mechanisms that distribute damages are strict liability and insurance. Justifying participation of a group of people, who have no role in this damage and giving indemnity, is possible via economic meanslike promoting economic efficiency and realizing distributive justice in society and this is the subject of present study to investigate and analyze these basics.  </p>
			      </abstract>
					<kwd-group kwd-group-type="author">
						<kwd>Economic Analysis</kwd>
						<kwd>Loss Distribution</kwd>
						<kwd>Distributive Justice</kwd>
						<kwd>Corrective Justice</kwd>
						<kwd>Economic Efficiency</kwd>
					</kwd-group>
			    </article-meta>
			  </front>
<back>
	<ref-list>
		<ref id="R1">
			<label>1</label>
			<element-citation>الف) فارسی</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R2">
			<label>2</label>
			<element-citation>ابن­تراب، مریم (1386)، «ضمان عاقله و جایگاه آن در جامعه کنونی»، فقه و حقوق خانواده، شماره 45 و 46، صص 33-12.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R3">
			<label>3</label>
			<element-citation>احمدوند، محسن و ناصری‌مقدم، حسین (1394)، «ضمان عاقله از نگاهی دیگر»، فقه و اصول، شماره101، صص 54-31.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R4">
			<label>4</label>
			<element-citation>ارسطو (1377) اخلاق نیکوماخوس، ترجمه محمد حسن لطفی، تهران: انتشارات طرح نو.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R5">
			<label>5</label>
			<element-citation>بادینی، حسن (1384)، فلسفه مسئولیت مدنی ، تهران: شرکت سهامی انتشار.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R6">
			<label>6</label>
			<element-citation>جالینوسی، احمد و پورنجف، سارا (1386)، «مفهوم عدالت در اسلام و غرب»، دانش سیاسی، شماره 5، صص 128-99.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R7">
			<label>7</label>
			<element-citation>جباری، مصطفی (1388)، «زمان عاقله»، مطالعات حقوق خصوصی،دوره 39، شماره 2، صص 128-113.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R8">
			<label>8</label>
			<element-citation>جعفری لنگرودی، محمد جعفر (1382)، ترمینولوژی حقوقی،  تهران: کتابخانه گنج دانش.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R9">
			<label>9</label>
			<element-citation>خدابخشی، عبدالله (1391)، «توزیع خسارت در مسئولیت مدنی در فرض تعدد اسباب»، فصلنامه حقوق، شماره 25، صص 126-109.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R10">
			<label>10</label>
			<element-citation>خوش­چهره، محمد و عطیه زیوری (1386)، «عدالت و برابری اقتصادی در آراء اندیشمندان اسلامی و اقتصاددانان معاصر»، مجله راهبرد و توسعه، شماره 10، صص 105-73 .</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R11">
			<label>11</label>
			<element-citation>سید فاطمی، سیدمحمد قاری (1380) « تحلیل مفاهیم کلیدی حقوق بشر معاصر: حق، تعهد، آزادی، برابری و عدالت»، مجله تحقیقات حقوقی، شماره 33 و 34، صص 265-209.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R12">
			<label>12</label>
			<element-citation>شهابی، مهدی و آزاده مسعودی­پور (1392)، «تحلیل اقتصادی حقوق و احیاء اندیشه تقصیر در نظام جبران خسارت با تأکید بر رویه قضایی امریکا»، دانشنامه حقوق اقتصادی، دور جدید، شماره 4، صص 56-28.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R13">
			<label>13</label>
			<element-citation>صفایی، سید حسین (1389)، قواعد عمومی قراردادها، تهران: انتشارات سمت.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R14">
			<label>14</label>
			<element-citation>کاتوزیان، امیرناصر (1376)، «حقوق و عدالت»، مجله نقد و نظر، شماره 10و 11، صص57-34.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R15">
			<label>15</label>
			<element-citation>گرجی، ابوالقاسم (1366)، «ضمان عاقله»، فصلنامه حق، شماره 11و 12، صص 94-78.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R16">
			<label>16</label>
			<element-citation>مارکس، کارل و فردریش انگلس (1385)، مانیفست حزب کمونیست، ترجمه محمد پورهرمزان، بی­جا: انتشارات حزب توده.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R17">
			<label>17</label>
			<element-citation>ب) عربی</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R18">
			<label>18</label>
			<element-citation>راوندی، قطب­الدین (1405)، فقه­القرآن، قم: کتابخانه آیت‌الله مرعشی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R19">
			<label>19</label>
			<element-citation>شیخ طوسی(1379ق)، مجمع البیان فی تفسیر القرآن، ج 5، بیروت: داراحیاء التراث العربی.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R20">
			<label>20</label>
			<element-citation>شیخ مفید، محمد بن نعمان (1413)، المقنعه، قم: جامعه مدرسین.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R21">
			<label>21</label>
			<element-citation>عوده، عبدالقادر (1415)، التشریع الجنایی الاسلامی مقارنا بالقانون الوضعی، بیروت.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R22">
			<label>22</label>
			<element-citation>نجفی (صاحب­جواهر)، محمد حسن (1404)، جواهرالکلام فی شرح شرایع الاسلام، تهران: دارالکتاب الاسلامیه.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R23">
			<label>23</label>
			<element-citation>ج)  انگلیسی</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R24">
			<label>24</label>
			<element-citation>Abraham, Kenneth S. (2004) »Tewenty- First Century Insurance and Loss Distribution in Tort Law«, (observed: 2016/11/13) at: https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/7158668.pdf,</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R25">
			<label>25</label>
			<element-citation>Calabresi, Guido (1961), »Some Thoughts on Risk Distribution and the Law of Torts«, The Yale Law Journal, No.4, Vol.7, pp. 499-553.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R26">
			<label>26</label>
			<element-citation>Coelman, Jules L. (1980), »Efficiency, Utility and Wealth Maximization«, Hofstar Law Review, Vol. 8, pp. 509-551.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R27">
			<label>27</label>
			<element-citation>Coleman, Jules L. (1988), »The Economic Structure of Tort Law«, The Yale Law Journal, Vol.97, pp.1233-1253.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R28">
			<label>28</label>
			<element-citation>Coleman, Jules L. (1992), Risks and Wrongs, Cambridge University Press.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R29">
			<label>29</label>
			<element-citation>Coleman, Jules L. (2005), »The Costs of Accidents«, Maryland Law Reveiw, Vol. 64, pp.337-354.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R30">
			<label>30</label>
			<element-citation>Edmonds, Timothy, (2015) » Briefing Parer of Uninsured Drivers and the Motor Insurers Bureau«, (observed: 2016/11/13) at: www.parliament.uk/commonslibrary/intranet.parliament.uk/commons library/papers,</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R31">
			<label>31</label>
			<element-citation>Emons, Winand (1993),»An Introduction to the Legal and Economic Theories of Tort«, Swiss Journal of Economics and Statistics, Vol. 129 (4), pp. 625-642.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R32">
			<label>32</label>
			<element-citation>Fleming, John G. (1984), »Is There a Future for Tort«, Louisiana Law Review, Vol.44, No. 5, pp.1193-1211.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R33">
			<label>33</label>
			<element-citation>Fleming, John G. (1966), »More Thoughts on Loss Distribution«, Osgoode Hall Law Journal, Vol .4, No. 2, pp.161-173.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R34">
			<label>34</label>
			<element-citation>Geistfeld, Mark (2003),»The Role(s) of Economic Analysis in Tort Law«,(observed: 2016/07/05)at: http:// www.scolarship.org/ uc/ item/ 5nt1n0q2.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R35">
			<label>35</label>
			<element-citation>Keting, Gregory C (2000), »Distributive and Corrective Justice in the Tort Law of Accidents«, Southern California Review, Vol. 74, pp.193-224.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R36">
			<label>36</label>
			<element-citation>Lewis, Richard, (2005), »The Relationship between Tort Law and Insurance in England and Walse«, part of the tort and insurance law series, (TIL, Volume16).</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R37">
			<label>37</label>
			<element-citation>Loth, Marc (2015), »Corrective and Distributive Justice in Tort Law«, Maastricht of Journal of European and Comparative Law, Vol.  22, No. 6, pp.788-811.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R38">
			<label>38</label>
			<element-citation>Mooney, Sean F,(1987), »The Liability Crisis- A Perspective«, Villanova Law Review, Vol. 32, Issue.6, Art.3,pp.1235-1264.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R39">
			<label>39</label>
			<element-citation>Nozick, Robert (1999), Anarchy, State and Utopia, London: Blackwell Publishers Ltd.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R40">
			<label>40</label>
			<element-citation>Perdue, Wendy Collins,(2000), »A Reexamination of the Distinction Between "Loss-Allocating" and "Conduct-Regulating Rule”«,  60 La. L. Rev. pp.1251-1258.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R41">
			<label>41</label>
			<element-citation>Posner, Richard A, William M. Landes, (1980), »The Positive Economic Theory of Tort Law«, Georgia Law Review, No. 15, pp.851-924.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R42">
			<label>42</label>
			<element-citation>Priest, George (1987), »The Current Insurance Crisis and Modern Tort Law«, The Yale Law Journal, Vol.96, pp.1521-1590.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R43">
			<label>43</label>
			<element-citation>Rawls, John (1999), A Theory Of Justice, Harvard University Press.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R44">
			<label>44</label>
			<element-citation>Shavell, Steven (2000), »Economic Analysis of Law«, (observed: 2016/07/05) at: http://www.law.harvard.edu/programs/ oline center/,</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R45">
			<label>45</label>
			<element-citation>Tudor, Ionut (2015), »Tort Law from The Perspective of Corrective and Distributive Justice«, Journal of Public Administration Finance and Law, No. 7, pp.171-175.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R46">
			<label>46</label>
			<element-citation>Voyiakis, Emmanue (2012) » Rights, Social Justice and Responsibility in The Law of Tort«, UNSW Law Journal, Vol. 35, No. 2, pp.449-469.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R47">
			<label>47</label>
			<element-citation>Wagner, Gerhard (2006), »Tort Law and Liability Insurance«, The Geneva Papers, 31, pp.277-292.</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R48">
			<label>48</label>
			<element-citation> _||_</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R49">
			<label>49</label>
			<element-citation>Resource in Persian</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R50">
			<label>50</label>
			<element-citation>1-      Ebne Torab, Maryam(2007), Aghele Responsibility and its Position in Current Society, Jurisprudence and Family Law,Issue45-46,pp:12-33</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R51">
			<label>51</label>
			<element-citation>2-      Khosh Chehre ,Mohammad &amp; Zivari, Atyeh(2007),Justice and Economic Equilibrium in the Views of Islamic thinkers and contemporary economists, Strategy and development Journal,Issue 10, pp:73-105</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R52">
			<label>52</label>
			<element-citation>3-      Ahmadvand, Mohsen &amp; Naseri Moghadam, Hossein,(2015 ), Aghele Responsibility from another Glance, Jurisprudence and the principles Journal, Issue:101,pp:31-54</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R53">
			<label>53</label>
			<element-citation>4-      Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics,(1998) Translated By Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Tarhe No Publication,</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R54">
			<label>54</label>
			<element-citation>5-      Badini, Hassan ,(2005) philosophy of Tort Law, Enteshar Co Publication</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R55">
			<label>55</label>
			<element-citation>6-      Jabari, Mostafa(2009), Aghele ‘s Time, Private Law Studies, Issue2, pp:113-128</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R56">
			<label>56</label>
			<element-citation>7-      Jalinousi, Ahmmad, Pour Najaf, Sara,(2006) The concept of justice in Islam and the West, Political Science,Issue5,pp:99-128</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R57">
			<label>57</label>
			<element-citation>8-      Jafari Langroudi, Mohammad Jafar,(2002) Legal terminology, Gang Danesh Library</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R58">
			<label>58</label>
			<element-citation>9-      Khoda Bakhshi, Abdollah(2012) Distribution of Loss in Tort Liability in Multiple Tortfeasor cases, Quarterly Journal of Law,Issue25, pp:109-126</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R59">
			<label>59</label>
			<element-citation>10-  Ravandi, Ghotbedin,(1405) Jurisprudence of al-Quran, Ayatollah Marashi Library</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R60">
			<label>60</label>
			<element-citation>11-  Seyed Fatemi, Seyed Mohammad,(2001) Analysis of key concepts of contemporary human rights: right, commitment, freedom, equality and justice, Journal of Legal Research, Issue:33-34,pp:209-265</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R61">
			<label>61</label>
			<element-citation>12-  Shahabi, Masoud &amp; Azade Masoudi Pour,(2013) Economic analysis of salaries and the restoration of the idea of fault in the compensation system, with an emphasis on the judicial process in the United States, Economic Law Encyclopedia, Issue 4</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R62">
			<label>62</label>
			<element-citation>13-  Sheykh Tousi,(1959) Assembly of Al-Bayan in the commentary of al-Quran, vol 5, Arabic Dar- Al- Ehya- Al- Toras</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R63">
			<label>63</label>
			<element-citation>14-  Sheykh Mofid, Mohammad Ibn Noman,(1992) Al- Moghana, Ghom: society of Lecturer</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R64">
			<label>64</label>
			<element-citation>15-  Safaii, Seyed Hossein,(2010) General rules of contracts, Samt Publication</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R65">
			<label>65</label>
			<element-citation>16-  Abdolghader, Udeh,(1994) Islamic criminal legislation compared to the status law, Beirut</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R66">
			<label>66</label>
			<element-citation>17-   Katouzian, Amir Nasser,(1997) Law and Justice, Criticism &amp; Sight Journal, Issue 10-11, pp:34-57</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R67">
			<label>67</label>
			<element-citation>18-  Gorji, Abu- Al- Ghasem, Aghele Responsibility,(1987) Quarterly Journal of Right,Issue 11-12,pp:78-94</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R68">
			<label>68</label>
			<element-citation>19-  Marx, Karl, Engels, Fredisch ,(2006) Manifest Party of Kommunist, Translated by: Mohammad Pourhormozan</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R69">
			<label>69</label>
			<element-citation>20-  Najafi, Mohammad Hassan,(1983) javaher- Al- kalam, Islamic Dar- Al- Ketab publication</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R70">
			<label>70</label>
			<element-citation>Resource in English</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R71">
			<label>71</label>
			<element-citation>21-   Abraham, Kenneth S.(2004) Tewenty- First Century Insurance And Loss Distribution In Tort Law, (http:// law.bepress.com/uvalwps/uva-publiclaw/art1)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R72">
			<label>72</label>
			<element-citation>22-    Calabresi, Guido (1961), Some Thoughts On Risk Distribution And The Law Of Torts, Faculty Scholarship series</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R73">
			<label>73</label>
			<element-citation>23-  Coelman, Jules.L(1980), Efficiency, Utility And Wealth Maximization, Hofstar Law Review. Vol. 8,</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R74">
			<label>74</label>
			<element-citation>24-  Coleman, Jules. L(1988), The Economic Structure of Tort Law, Faculty Scholarship Series, Paper4691</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R75">
			<label>75</label>
			<element-citation>25-  Coleman, Jules. L(1992), Risks and Wrongs, Cambridge University Press</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R76">
			<label>76</label>
			<element-citation>26-  Coleman, Jules.L (2005), The Costs of Accidents, M.D.L rev, No 64</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R77">
			<label>77</label>
			<element-citation>27-    Edmonds, Timothy,(2015), Briefing Parer of Uninsured drivers and the Motor Insurers Bureau,www.parliament.uk/commons-library/intranet.parliament.uk/commons library/papers</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R78">
			<label>78</label>
			<element-citation>28-  Emons,Winand(1992), An Introduction to the Legal and Economic Theories of Tort, Journal of Economic Literature Classification,</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R79">
			<label>79</label>
			<element-citation>29-  Fleming, John G (1984), Is There A Future For Tort, Louisiana Law Review, Vol:44, Number5</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R80">
			<label>80</label>
			<element-citation>30-  Fleming, John G(1966), More Thoughts On Loss Distribution, Osgoode Hall Law Journal, Vol 4, No 2</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R81">
			<label>81</label>
			<element-citation>31-  Geistfeld, Mark (2003), The Role(s) of Economic Analysis in Tort Law, http:// www.scolarship.org/ uc/ item/ 5nt1n0q2</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R82">
			<label>82</label>
			<element-citation>32-  Keting, Gregory C(2000), Distributive and Corrective Justice In The Tort Law of Accidents, Southern California Review, Vol 74</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R83">
			<label>83</label>
			<element-citation>33-  Lewis, Richard,(2005), The Relationship Between Tort Law and  Insurance  in England And  Walse, part of the tort and insurance law series,(TIL,Volume16)</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R84">
			<label>84</label>
			<element-citation>34-  Loth, Marc (2015), Corrective and Distributive Justice in Tort Law, Maastricht of Journal of European and Comparative Law, Vol  22,No 6</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R85">
			<label>85</label>
			<element-citation>35-  Mooney, Sean F,(1987), The Liability Crisis- A Perspective, Villanova Law Review, Vol. 32, Iss.6, Art.3</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R86">
			<label>86</label>
			<element-citation>36-  Nozick, Robert (1999), Anarchy, State and Utopia, London: Blackwell Publishers Ltd,</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R87">
			<label>87</label>
			<element-citation>37-  Perdue, Wendy Collins,(2000), A Reexamination of the Distinction Between "Loss-Allocating" and "Conduct-Regulating Rule”,  60 La. L. Rev. 1251-1258</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R88">
			<label>88</label>
			<element-citation>38-  Posner, Richard A, William M. Landes,(1980), The Positive Economic Theory of Tort Law, Georgia Law Review, No 15</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R89">
			<label>89</label>
			<element-citation>39-    Priest, George(1987), The Current Insurance Crisis and Modern Tort Law, faculty scholarship series,pager578</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R90">
			<label>90</label>
			<element-citation>40-  Rawls, John (1999), A Theory Of Justice, Harvard University Press</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R91">
			<label>91</label>
			<element-citation>41-  Shavell, Steven (2000), Economic Analysis of Law, http://www.law.harvard.edu/programs/ oline center/</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R92">
			<label>92</label>
			<element-citation>42-  Tudor, Ionut (2015), Tort Law From The Perspective of Corrective and Distributive Justice, Journal of Public Administration Finance and Law, No 7</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R93">
			<label>93</label>
			<element-citation>43-  Voyiakis, Emmanue (2012) Rights, Social Justice and Responsibility in The Law of Tort, UNSW Law Journal, Vol 35, No 2</element-citation>
		</ref>
		<ref id="R94">
			<label>94</label>
			<element-citation>44-  Wagner, Gerhard (2006), Tort Law and Liability Insurance, The Geneva Papers, 31</element-citation>
		</ref>
	</ref-list>
		</back>
</article>